QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by LB49ers:

Originally posted by Cisco0623:

Originally posted by LB49ers:

Originally posted by Montana:

Originally posted by RonnieLott:
Brock didn't win us the game either.

2 interceptions in the 4th quarter were a horror show.

Lol 377 yards 3 tds 116 passer rtg. What an Art the Clown-like horror show for Brock Purdy cause of those two ints.

The real horror show? Moody Two missed fgs, extra pt and what the hell was that onside kick?

Not to mention..defense was ass for the most part..even with Bosa doing as well as he did. Sorensen can't be creative. Hit the road, jack 🎶
Can't win games with a defense that weak and predictable. Rush four ..repeat repeat..no disguises..no blitzes..nothing. Gunna call him Vanilla Ice...Wilks was better..I mean..if you are gunna fire Wilks..get a good replacement for crying out loud. We get this doof lol.

3 weeks in a row. Ball in his hands in the 4th quarter and a chance to win the game and he throws a pick to end it. Once can be a fluke, twice can be a coincidence but 3 times is a trend and that's not to mention the Vikings game and the KC game where he threw backbreaking ints. Then there was last season against The Browns, Vikings and Cincy where he again threw backbreaking ints. And there was the superbowl were again ball in his hands and couldn't get it done. I am not saying he is a bad QB but he is not elite and if we pay him like he is it will set back the franchise.

What's your solution?

Pay him around the 30 million mark which is close to the Baker contract. If he balks let him walk. I think Kyle has shown that with an average QB (see Jimmy G) he can win. And for what it's worth he is still under contract for next year.

That's never going to happen. He is easily a top half of the league starter and the market is always higher for a good qb.

We also lost because of Jimmy g's limitations and I think everyone including Kyle knows that, which is why he tried to move on asap with Lance and now Purdy.

Originally posted by Montana:

Originally posted by CatchMaster80:
If you're going to play what if then you need to remember that the Lions kicker missed 2 extra points as well. Even if he makes one they still win 42-41

Meh but Moody is a third round pick..shouldn't he make those? Another draft bust. Disaster.

No big deal. The used a 3rd rounder on what was supposed to be the best or 2nd bset kicker in the draft. They needed one and pickedhim. He struggled this season and may or may not be back in camp in July. He didn't cost them much and there's no guantee that anyong they picked in that spot would still be on the team. A lot of fans think they can't draft so what difference does it make.

Originally posted by mayo49:

Originally posted by Montana:

Originally posted by mayo49:
Extend, Dirty Purdy and let's get it!

Exciting offseason, Montana. Can't wait to get it going.

Originally posted by random49er:

Originally posted by tankle104:

At the end of the day, Brock has shown tremendous ability to learn and grow from his mistakes. So sure, it isn't good that he threw picks - but I think he's proven that we shouldn't be worried either.

it was more concerning to me when Jimmy or Lance did in camp because they did that in real games too.

But let's be real. Just going by the offseason postings,...you'd be enthused and saying he's going to rewrite history books this year if those stats were 7 TDs, 0 TDs at this point.

??

Couldn't agree more with Jon. Seems like if he got back into coaching he'd be okay with signing Brock

Originally posted by CatchMaster80:

Originally posted by Montana:

Originally posted by CatchMaster80:
If you're going to play what if then you need to remember that the Lions kicker missed 2 extra points as well. Even if he makes one they still win 42-41

Meh but Moody is a third round pick..shouldn't he make those? Another draft bust. Disaster.

No big deal. The used a 3rd rounder on what was supposed to be the best or 2nd bset kicker in the draft. They needed one and pickedhim. He struggled this season and may or may not be back in camp in July. He didn't cost them much and there's no guantee that anyong they picked in that spot would still be on the team. A lot of fans think they can't draft so what difference does it make.

Moody's "value" was slotted @ beginning of the 4th round due to compensatory picks pushing others back. It's said over and over like he was anywhere near the 70th pick or something so i'll just keep squeezing this in if no one wants to say he was 99th over all.

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:
Couldn't agree more with Jon. Seems like if he got back into coaching he'd be okay with signing Brock

We are signing Brock tho? But Brock has to sign too.

Originally posted by random49er:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Couldn't agree more with Jon. Seems like if he got back into coaching he'd be okay with signing Brock

We are signing Brock tho? But Brock has to sign too.

Lmao

Listened to it and Gruden didnt say "pay him whatever the hell he wants",....which isint his concern.

Who here in their right mind would say no to offering Brock an extension this offseason?

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:
Couldn't agree more with Jon. Seems like if he got back into coaching he'd be okay with signing Brock

yeah he saved our backsides and he has years in our system so it will be an extension hopefully a spring extension and we can focus on offseason with this one a done deal.

I keep seeing post say pay Brock around 30mil a year as that's his value.

Are people just throwing numbers out there and not looking at the entire picture?

Expecting or hoping for 30mil is completely unreasonable.

here's a quick breakdown sorted by avg. per yr to get a general idea of QB salaries.

https://www.spotrac.com/nfl/contracts/_/position/qb/sort/average/dir/desc

30 a yr would make him the 19th highest paid QB. This is even worse when you remove rookie QB numbers. He'd be the 2nd lowest paid vet QB only ahead of Geno Smith. And Brock will be 25 years at his signing along with multiple playoff wins, a Super Bowl appearance, and for a little while last year, in the MVP race.

Originally posted by bmvanthiel:
I keep seeing post say pay Brock around 30mil a year as that's his value.

Are people just throwing numbers out there and not looking at the entire picture?

Expecting or hoping for 30mil is completely unreasonable.

here's a quick breakdown sorted by avg. per yr to get a general idea of QB salaries.

https://www.spotrac.com/nfl/contracts/_/position/qb/sort/average/dir/desc

30 a yr would make him the 19th highest paid QB. This is even worse when you remove rookie QB numbers. He'd be the 2nd lowest paid vet QB only ahead of Geno Smith. And Brock will be 25 years at his signing along with multiple playoff wins, a Super Bowl appearance, and for a little while last year, in the MVP race.

So lowball him to tick him and his agent off so that when he is able to become a FA we are back to square one or OVERPAY? That's savvy.

Originally posted by bmvanthiel:
I keep seeing post say pay Brock around 30mil a year as that's his value.

Are people just throwing numbers out there and not looking at the entire picture?

Expecting or hoping for 30mil is completely unreasonable.

here's a quick breakdown sorted by avg. per yr to get a general idea of QB salaries.

https://www.spotrac.com/nfl/contracts/_/position/qb/sort/average/dir/desc

30 a yr would make him the 19th highest paid QB. This is even worse when you remove rookie QB numbers. He'd be the 2nd lowest paid vet QB only ahead of Geno Smith. And Brock will be 25 years at his signing along with multiple playoff wins, a Super Bowl appearance, and for a little while last year, in the MVP race.

the aav doesn't matter too much i'll look at the early cap hits and when do we have the out. for example.

20m
28m
36m
we have an out here
62m
74m

this is just a sample 5 year 220m deal, which is $44m aav, which is in the wheelhouse i think. now from the team perspective, you can look at it in terms of $84m over 3 which is $28m per year, which is very reasonable. these outs usually you have to absorb some dead cap.

time and again you see players not performing who don't get the full deal, russ and cousins are examples. and even if guys do perform, you can redo the deal to make those seemingly large cap hits more workable. so i think this whole deal is a bit overrated. we just transition from having a cheat code, to having to actually pay a QB1 for his services, and we all knew this day was coming.

Would you do this trade? 1st in 2026, 3rd in 2025 & Purdy for Drake Maye & Christian Gonzalez.

Maye needs improvements. But he would have Shanahan as his HC. And he has great arm strength and other great traits.

Gonzalez has become an elite CB.

Do you guys think Brock deep down has accepted that he is just an average NFL QB? Or do you think he has some denial in believing he is or can be elite?