QB Brock Purdy Thread

Sam Darnold has made a lot of money for Brock Purdy tonight.

What would you guys say to trading Brock for a 2nd and trading our first at #11 next year for McCarthy from the Vikings?

Then the QB on a rookie contract timer resets almost fully and we still get a 2nd for Brock to upgrade DL/EDGE/OL. Can easily sign Greenlaw and some other top free agents as well.

Obviously this is a gamble since McCarthy is a complete unknown and coming off an injury, but where in the draft would he be going this year if he were in the 2025 draft? I have heard top 3? So giving up #11 doesn't seem unreasonable.

If he disappoints we will have a bad record next season and can go to the well again at QB at the top of the 2026 draft. Anyone know if 2026 is a good QB class at the top of the draft?

My biggest concern by far is having to commit to Brock for the next few years even if he regresses further or is the same as this year and can't move off him because of his huge contract.

Question is... who is the real Brock Purdy? The one from his first two years or the one from his last 18 games where he CLEARLY is not worth a contract of more than 35m/yr? If it is the latter we are ****ed for a long time. Recency bias is a thing, but we have a large sample size this past year that is trending down with Brock and I personally don't want to pay him big money until he shows this year was not who he is.

Originally posted by dj43:
Sam Darnold has made a lot of money for Brock Purdy tonight.

you had to go there and try to wake up the circus

Originally posted by Ezekiel38:
What would you guys say to trading Brock for a 2nd and trading our first at #11 next year for McCarthy from the Vikings?

Then the QB on a rookie contract timer resets almost fully and we still get a 2nd for Brock to upgrade DL/EDGE/OL. Can easily sign Greenlaw and some other top free agents as well.

Obviously this is a gamble since McCarthy is a complete unknown and coming off an injury, but where in the draft would he be going this year if he were in the 2025 draft? I have heard top 3? So giving up #11 doesn't seem unreasonable.

If he disappoints we will have a bad record next season and can go to the well again at QB at the top of the 2026 draft. Anyone know if 2026 is a good QB class at the top of the draft?

My biggest concern by far is having to commit to Brock for the next few years even if he regresses further or is the same as this year and can't move off him because of his huge contract.

Question is... who is the real Brock Purdy? The one from his first two years or the one from his last 18 games where he CLEARLY is not worth a contract of more than 35m/yr? If it is the latter we are ****ed for a long time. Recency bias is a thing, but we have a large sample size this past year that is trending down with Brock and I personally don't want to pay him big money until he shows this year was not who he is.

Originally posted by Ezekiel38:
What would you guys say to trading Brock for a 2nd and trading our first at #11 next year for McCarthy from the Vikings?

Then the QB on a rookie contract timer resets almost fully and we still get a 2nd for Brock to upgrade DL/EDGE/OL. Can easily sign Greenlaw and some other top free agents as well.

Obviously this is a gamble since McCarthy is a complete unknown and coming off an injury, but where in the draft would he be going this year if he were in the 2025 draft? I have heard top 3? So giving up #11 doesn't seem unreasonable.

If he disappoints we will have a bad record next season and can go to the well again at QB at the top of the 2026 draft. Anyone know if 2026 is a good QB class at the top of the draft?

My biggest concern by far is having to commit to Brock for the next few years even if he regresses further or is the same as this year and can't move off him because of his huge contract.

Question is... who is the real Brock Purdy? The one from his first two years or the one from his last 18 games where he CLEARLY is not worth a contract of more than 35m/yr? If it is the latter we are ****ed for a long time. Recency bias is a thing, but we have a large sample size this past year that is trending down with Brock and I personally don't want to pay him big money until he shows this year was not who he is.

Pass. Didn't read your explanation, to be clear.

Originally posted by Ezekiel38:
What would you guys say to trading Brock for a 2nd and trading our first at #11 next year for McCarthy from the Vikings?

Then the QB on a rookie contract timer resets almost fully and we still get a 2nd for Brock to upgrade DL/EDGE/OL. Can easily sign Greenlaw and some other top free agents as well.

Obviously this is a gamble since McCarthy is a complete unknown and coming off an injury, but where in the draft would he be going this year if he were in the 2025 draft? I have heard top 3? So giving up #11 doesn't seem unreasonable.

If he disappoints we will have a bad record next season and can go to the well again at QB at the top of the 2026 draft. Anyone know if 2026 is a good QB class at the top of the draft?

My biggest concern by far is having to commit to Brock for the next few years even if he regresses further or is the same as this year and can't move off him because of his huge contract.

Question is... who is the real Brock Purdy? The one from his first two years or the one from his last 18 games where he CLEARLY is not worth a contract of more than 35m/yr? If it is the latter we are ****ed for a long time. Recency bias is a thing, but we have a large sample size this past year that is trending down with Brock and I personally don't want to pay him big money until he shows this year was not who he is.

After Darnold's performance tonight, there is no way Minnesota trades McCarthy.

Originally posted by dj43:

Originally posted by Ezekiel38:
What would you guys say to trading Brock for a 2nd and trading our first at #11 next year for McCarthy from the Vikings?

Then the QB on a rookie contract timer resets almost fully and we still get a 2nd for Brock to upgrade DL/EDGE/OL. Can easily sign Greenlaw and some other top free agents as well.

Obviously this is a gamble since McCarthy is a complete unknown and coming off an injury, but where in the draft would he be going this year if he were in the 2025 draft? I have heard top 3? So giving up #11 doesn't seem unreasonable.

If he disappoints we will have a bad record next season and can go to the well again at QB at the top of the 2026 draft. Anyone know if 2026 is a good QB class at the top of the draft?

My biggest concern by far is having to commit to Brock for the next few years even if he regresses further or is the same as this year and can't move off him because of his huge contract.

Question is... who is the real Brock Purdy? The one from his first two years or the one from his last 18 games where he CLEARLY is not worth a contract of more than 35m/yr? If it is the latter we are ****ed for a long time. Recency bias is a thing, but we have a large sample size this past year that is trending down with Brock and I personally don't want to pay him big money until he shows this year was not who he is.

After Darnold's performance tonight, there is no way Minnesota trades McCarthy.

The Lambs must be thrilled.

Originally posted by Ezekiel38:

What would you guys say to trading Brock for a 2nd and trading our first at #11 next year for McCarthy from the Vikings?

Then the QB on a rookie contract timer resets almost fully and we still get a 2nd for Brock to upgrade DL/EDGE/OL. Can easily sign Greenlaw and some other top free agents as well.

Obviously this is a gamble since McCarthy is a complete unknown and coming off an injury, but where in the draft would he be going this year if he were in the 2025 draft? I have heard top 3? So giving up #11 doesn't seem unreasonable.

If he disappoints we will have a bad record next season and can go to the well again at QB at the top of the 2026 draft. Anyone know if 2026 is a good QB class at the top of the draft?

My biggest concern by far is having to commit to Brock for the next few years even if he regresses further or is the same as this year and can't move off him because of his huge contract.

Question is... who is the real Brock Purdy? The one from his first two years or the one from his last 18 games where he CLEARLY is not worth a contract of more than 35m/yr? If it is the latter we are ****ed for a long time. Recency bias is a thing, but we have a large sample size this past year that is trending down with Brock and I personally don't want to pay him big money until he shows this year was not who he is.

Originally posted by dj43:
After Darnold's performance tonight, there is no way Minnesota trades McCarthy.

Let the Raiders pay him 45 and take the comp pick. Re up Jones as the backup. See what O'Connell can do with JJ.

It's time to sign Brock Purdy to an 8 year deal.

Originally posted by dj43:

Sam Darnold has made a lot of money for Brock Purdy tonight.

Purdy didn't need help

Originally posted by elguapo:
Exactly Montana. It's really hard for people to accept reality sometimes.

I think we keep Deebo one more year because BA won't be ready but after this next year he's gone and Ricky will take over. Then we may actually have two receivers that are good at separating.

with our cakewalk of a schedule next year looks like we will be this year's Philadelphia Eagles. So many good players and talent just under performing with new DC (except injuries to every all pro/pro bowl player in our case).

Next year, 13-4 book it!

It's hard for ppl to grasp common sense lol. Trying way too hard to figure things out, getting all belligerent, trapped inside their own ways of thought and reason, limiting their perspectives when the answers are right in their face lol. I agree about Deebo and that next season should be a good one! Hopefully, we stay healthy, kick some ass and lift it up in Santa Clara

Originally posted by Ezekiel38:
What would you guys say to trading Brock for a 2nd and trading our first at #11 next year for McCarthy from the Vikings?

Then the QB on a rookie contract timer resets almost fully and we still get a 2nd for Brock to upgrade DL/EDGE/OL. Can easily sign Greenlaw and some other top free agents as well.

Obviously this is a gamble since McCarthy is a complete unknown and coming off an injury, but where in the draft would he be going this year if he were in the 2025 draft? I have heard top 3? So giving up #11 doesn't seem unreasonable.

If he disappoints we will have a bad record next season and can go to the well again at QB at the top of the 2026 draft. Anyone know if 2026 is a good QB class at the top of the draft?

My biggest concern by far is having to commit to Brock for the next few years even if he regresses further or is the same as this year and can't move off him because of his huge contract.

Question is... who is the real Brock Purdy? The one from his first two years or the one from his last 18 games where he CLEARLY is not worth a contract of more than 35m/yr? If it is the latter we are ****ed for a long time. Recency bias is a thing, but we have a large sample size this past year that is trending down with Brock and I personally don't want to pay him big money until he shows this year was not who he is.

You clearly love losing games

Originally posted by Strwy2Hevn:

Originally posted by Ezekiel38:
What would you guys say to trading Brock for a 2nd and trading our first at #11 next year for McCarthy from the Vikings?

Then the QB on a rookie contract timer resets almost fully and we still get a 2nd for Brock to upgrade DL/EDGE/OL. Can easily sign Greenlaw and some other top free agents as well.

Obviously this is a gamble since McCarthy is a complete unknown and coming off an injury, but where in the draft would he be going this year if he were in the 2025 draft? I have heard top 3? So giving up #11 doesn't seem unreasonable.

If he disappoints we will have a bad record next season and can go to the well again at QB at the top of the 2026 draft. Anyone know if 2026 is a good QB class at the top of the draft?

My biggest concern by far is having to commit to Brock for the next few years even if he regresses further or is the same as this year and can't move off him because of his huge contract.

Question is... who is the real Brock Purdy? The one from his first two years or the one from his last 18 games where he CLEARLY is not worth a contract of more than 35m/yr? If it is the latter we are ****ed for a long time. Recency bias is a thing, but we have a large sample size this past year that is trending down with Brock and I personally don't want to pay him big money until he shows this year was not who he is.

Originally posted by 9ers4eva:

Originally posted by dj43:
After Darnold's performance tonight, there is no way Minnesota trades McCarthy.

Let the Raiders pay him 45 and take the comp pick. Re up Jones as the backup. See what O'Connell can do with JJ.

KOC is a good coach. Minnesota has the same OL problem we have starting with Center. Bill Walsh wanted to build a team to win the division. That worked then and it is still the goal today. JJ will be good if he gets some protection. duh