QB Brock Purdy Thread

i think it is worth paying purdy a big contract because he is a QB and even if he flops. oh well. that's how it is with QBs...just get the deal done on time!

Originally posted by picklejuice:
i think it is worth paying purdy a big contract because he is a QB and even if he flops. oh well. that's how it is with QBs...just get the deal done on time!

yeah.. thats why i don't care about the cash.. just do your job

plus, in a few years it will be a bargain as the cost keeps going up

Originally posted by random49er:
Uhm,...putting 2025 playoff stats in with someone else's career playoff stats?

Do the other 2 QBs you listed not have career playoff stats too?

Herbert
2 games (0-2)
52% Completion
257.5 yards per game
6.87 yards per attempt
2 touchdowns
4 interceptions
60.7 passer rating

Stroud
3 games (2-1)
65.5% Completion
243.6 yards per game
8.5 yards per attempt
4 touchdowns
1 interception
102.2 passer rating

There you go.

I was reading some article criticizing Purdy implying he should have been benched. I thought to myself, idiots will write anything these days.

Then I realized the author was Grant Cohn.

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by picklejuice:
i think it is worth paying purdy a big contract because he is a QB and even if he flops. oh well. that's how it is with QBs...just get the deal done on time!

yeah.. thats why i don't care about the cash.. just do your job

plus, in a few years it will be a bargain as the cost keeps going up

That's why I want a Mahomes type contract for Purdy. Give him 60m on a 10 year contract. In 3 years it won't be a top 10 contract.

Originally posted by Jakemall:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by picklejuice:
i think it is worth paying purdy a big contract because he is a QB and even if he flops. oh well. that's how it is with QBs...just get the deal done on time!

yeah.. thats why i don't care about the cash.. just do your job

plus, in a few years it will be a bargain as the cost keeps going up

That's why I want a Mahomes type contract for Purdy. Give him 60m on a 10 year contract. In 3 years it won't be a top 10 contract.

$600 million for Brock Purdy?

Originally posted by 49ers808:

Originally posted by Jakemall:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by picklejuice:
i think it is worth paying purdy a big contract because he is a QB and even if he flops. oh well. that's how it is with QBs...just get the deal done on time!

yeah.. thats why i don't care about the cash.. just do your job

plus, in a few years it will be a bargain as the cost keeps going up

That's why I want a Mahomes type contract for Purdy. Give him 60m on a 10 year contract. In 3 years it won't be a top 10 contract.

$600 million for Brock Purdy?

Over 10 years? Hell yes.

In 3 years it'll barely be a top 10 contract. In 5-6 years it'll be a bottom 10 contract.

Originally posted by Jakemall:

Originally posted by 49ers808:

Originally posted by Jakemall:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by picklejuice:
i think it is worth paying purdy a big contract because he is a QB and even if he flops. oh well. that's how it is with QBs...just get the deal done on time!

yeah.. thats why i don't care about the cash.. just do your job

plus, in a few years it will be a bargain as the cost keeps going up

That's why I want a Mahomes type contract for Purdy. Give him 60m on a 10 year contract. In 3 years it won't be a top 10 contract.

$600 million for Brock Purdy?

Over 10 years? Hell yes.

In 3 years it'll barely be a top 10 contract. In 5-6 years it'll be a bottom 10 contract.

We'll see. I think the league will catch on to the stupidity that is QB contracts and just paying guys the ridiculous team killing numbers "because so and so got this"

Hard pass for me

Originally posted by bud49:
When all is said and done there will be some that will be upset with the deal either way it goes. I think you pay the man and go on, he's done enough to merrit a 45 to 50 million or so contract. JMO

How much cap space a year, for several years in the future, does he merit right now, though? That is what needs to be figured out.

All the leverage is on the 49ers side. The potential for other teams breaking down the door for Purdy could be a big, big factor -- IF he was due for free agency. But he's not. So the panic button can be put away. We aren't a charity either (for those saying he's earned the right to handicap our team's future due to unfavorable CBA rules he's had to deal with). We aren't doing this "football thing" to make up for the NFL's wrongs.

And as fans with regards to these potential deals,...our concern should really be cap hit money,...cause this is the main number that affects other deals that are to be made for years.

Originally posted by 49ers808:

Originally posted by Jakemall:

Originally posted by 49ers808:

Originally posted by Jakemall:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by picklejuice:
i think it is worth paying purdy a big contract because he is a QB and even if he flops. oh well. that's how it is with QBs...just get the deal done on time!

yeah.. thats why i don't care about the cash.. just do your job

plus, in a few years it will be a bargain as the cost keeps going up

That's why I want a Mahomes type contract for Purdy. Give him 60m on a 10 year contract. In 3 years it won't be a top 10 contract.

$600 million for Brock Purdy?

Over 10 years? Hell yes.

In 3 years it'll barely be a top 10 contract. In 5-6 years it'll be a bottom 10 contract.

We'll see. I think the league will catch on to the stupidity that is QB contracts and just paying guys the ridiculous team killing numbers "because so and so got this"

Hard pass for me

people keep talking about resets.. yet here we are with someone always becoming the highest paid in whatever position.

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:

Originally posted by random49er:
Uhm,...putting 2025 playoff stats in with someone else's career playoff stats?

Do the other 2 QBs you listed not have career playoff stats too?

Herbert
2 games (0-2)
52% Completion
257.5 yards per game
6.87 yards per attempt
2 touchdowns
4 interceptions
60.7 passer rating

Stroud
3 games (2-1)
65.5% Completion
243.6 yards per game
8.5 yards per attempt
4 touchdowns
1 interception
102.2 passer rating

There you go.

Me? It makes ZERO sense to compare the game stats of 1 player directly to the career stats of another,...lol.

Direct it to the guy that had the gaffe as a correction. No interest in what the numbers are without any point made.

Originally posted by LottDMontanaO:

What made Brock Purdy's #1 QBR season so special was that he did it behind an O-line that scored below average across pass protection metrics. Imagine if the 49ers had Philadelphia's O-line in front of him pic.twitter.com/m80yP8DT7z

— David Lombardi (@LombardiHimself) January 12, 2025

Yeah, this season Brock had minimal help essentially across the board.
- run game was super inconsistent and didn't have a consistent pass catching threat. That makes things way more difficult and predictable

- pass pro was average on its best days but Brendel was the worst center in pro football. Mckivitz is super average on his best days

- hold outs didn't do the team any favors. Trent was rusty and Aiyuk was super rusty, he sucked the first month of the season.

- injuries mounted up pretty bad this year, again.

Brock needs more help than just Jennings and Kittle every game, especially when they're injured. This isn't even factoring in the players getting shot or their children passing away (horrific thing to happen).

just a s**t show of a season from start to finish. We won one more game than Carolina… just pathetic

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:

Originally posted by random49er:
Uhm,...putting 2025 playoff stats in with someone else's career playoff stats?

Do the other 2 QBs you listed not have career playoff stats too?

Herbert
2 games (0-2)
52% Completion
257.5 yards per game
6.87 yards per attempt
2 touchdowns
4 interceptions
60.7 passer rating

Stroud
3 games (2-1)
65.5% Completion
243.6 yards per game
8.5 yards per attempt
4 touchdowns
1 interception
102.2 passer rating

There you go.

I posted those also, I left out the passer ratings.

Originally posted by random49er:

Originally posted by bud49:
When all is said and done there will be some that will be upset with the deal either way it goes. I think you pay the man and go on, he's done enough to merrit a 45 to 50 million or so contract. JMO

How much cap space a year, for several years in the future, does he merit right now, though? That is what needs to be figured out.

All the leverage is on the 49ers side. The potential for other teams breaking down the door for Purdy could be a big, big factor -- IF he was due for free agency. But he's not. So the panic button can be put away. We aren't a charity either (for those saying he's earned the right to handicap our team's future due to unfavorable CBA rules he's had to deal with). We aren't doing this "football thing" to make up for the NFL's wrongs.

And as fans with regards to these potential deals,...our concern should really be cap hit money,...cause this is the main number that affects other deals that are to be made for years.

I'm sure Parag and Jed can figure those numbers out, better than you or me.