QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:
Nobody said he's a lock for greatness. It's just funny as hell seeing all the arguments to not pay him come crumbling down

Because of how other QBs played in the playoffs?

the dude just ain't making any sense. very baffling. pay brock, cuz herbert had a rough time vs houston? i don't get it.

Originally posted by Furlow:
Jordan Love and Justin Herbert made Purdy a lot of money this weekend lol

I'm sensing a problem here. Does anybody here REALLY think Love is having a cap hit anywhere near $50M a year??


https://www.audacy.com/957thegame/sports/san-francisco-49-ers/why-brock-purdys-incoming-contract-wont-be-what-you-think

This is why those that truly want to compare salaries of QBs and how they affect their teams concerm themselves with GTD money and yearly cap hits.

When the deal is done, we are going to go DIRECTLY to these numbers,...lol.

Originally posted by CatchMaster80:

What is his potential? Haven't we seen that alredy? Do you think he's going to get much better? I don't. He is what we've seen. Good but not great. Able to win most games but not a difference maker.

The 49ers were fortunate to get him with that last pick. Getting a guy that had started for 4 years was a big benefit for a coach that has a complex system. Brock was able to pick it up very quickly. That's the good part. The bad is he doesn't hve a high upside. He's not a physical freak that just needs to be coached up. There isn't a lot of things he can improve on. Maybe learning not to force throws lte in games but thats part of his nature. He knows the system as well as he ever will.

He was elite last year. Experience through reps will improve decision making.

He was one of the best deep passers in 2023. He is great on the move. I think his toolset is good.

Originally posted by TheWooLick:
He was elite last year......He was one of the best deep passers in 2023.......

You're going to have to start saying "2 years ago" @ some point. The clock's ticking.

Originally posted by random49er:

Originally posted by TheWooLick:

You literally asked if fans wanted the 49ers to be like two playoff teams who signed their FQBs. I say yes.

"to be like 2 playoff teams" --- this is a lie,...or a "Wooism" as I call them.

I specifically referred to the Chargers and Packers and NO!! We have higher goals than trying to match the quality of the Packers or Chargers.

Look who is making it personal again. I just explained my post, why does thst trigger an emotional response and insult from you?

I didn't lie about anything, I explained my perspective. You edited out the previous responses to hide this.

I have no idea what your point is, if ypu have one.

__PRESENT

Originally posted by CatchMaster80:
I didn't see him making a lot of great throws that only he could make. He was efficient but that wasn't just him. It was Kyle's play calling. CMCs all around play. Aiyuk and Kittle. The defense stepping up. It wasn't about Purdy making play after play that left us wondering how he made that throw.

The kid form Indy can make every throw on his knees.

QB Efficiency >>> Arm strength

Can't believe you in here arguing that Brock didn't play a role in the the last 2 playoff runs we've had.
__PRESENT

Originally posted by random49er:

Originally posted by TheWooLick:

He was elite last year......He was one of the best deep passers in 2023.......

You're going to have to start saying "2 years ago" @ some point. The clock's ticking.

Everyone understands how seasons work.

What is your point here?

Originally posted by TheWooLick:

Originally posted by random49er:

Originally posted by TheWooLick:
You literally asked if fans wanted the 49ers to be like two playoff teams who signed their FQBs. I say yes.

"to be like 2 playoff teams" --- this is a lie,...or a "Wooism" as I call them.

I specifically referred to the Chargers and Packers and NO!! We have higher goals than trying to match the quality of the Packers or Chargers.

Look who is making it personal again. I just explained my post, why does thst trigger an emotional response and insult from you?

I didn't lie about anything, I explained my perspective. You edited out the previous responses to hide this.

I have no idea what your point is, if ypu have one.

My point is we dont want to be like the Chargers or the Packers. Looking at both squads as they are, they're not our template.

49ers are gonna pay brock and that was known a long time ago. i don't think these playoff games have anything to do with it. and it strikes me as a lil rich to say this guy didn't do well in postseason. well that guy made postseason. we just won 6 games. having a bad postseason is better than not making postseason.

Originally posted by TheWooLick:

Originally posted by random49er:

Originally posted by TheWooLick:
He was elite last year......He was one of the best deep passers in 2023.......

You're going to have to start saying "2 years ago" @ some point. The clock's ticking.

Everyone understands how seasons work.

What is your point here?

Our season is over. The "last year" sauce you add to these posts has expired. Last year for us was 2024 and you now have to say "He was elite 2 seasons ago",... but that doesn't "sound" as great, does it?

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
49ers are gonna pay brock and that was known a long time ago. i don't think these playoff games have anything to do with it. and it strikes me as a lil rich to say this guy didn't do well in postseason. well that guy made postseason. we just won 6 games. having a bad postseason is better than not making postseason.

Having all time stinkers when you get there isn't that much better.

Originally posted by miked1978:
__PRESENT

Originally posted by CatchMaster80:
I didn't see him making a lot of great throws that only he could make. He was efficient but that wasn't just him. It was Kyle's play calling. CMCs all around play. Aiyuk and Kittle. The defense stepping up. It wasn't about Purdy making play after play that left us wondering how he made that throw.

The kid form Indy can make every throw on his knees.

QB Efficiency >>> Arm strength

Can't believe you in here arguing that Brock didn't play a role in the the last 2 playoff runs we've had.
__PRESENT

I never said he didn't play a roll. Of course he did but he wasn't the only reason. If you measure a QB by how good the team does then you must think JG was elite. He took the Niners as far as Brock did and the results were virtually the same. Their stats over the season were very comparable. JG wasn't a top tier QB any more than Brock is.

When I say top tier I'm talking about top 5. If they want to pay Brock the 6th highest salary among QBs then I'm okay with that. There's just nothing that says he shoud be the highest paid. I tired of hearing market value. That's what they put on menus in fancy restaurants. Pay him what he's worth not what some other guy is getting. That's how housing prices ave gotten so inflated.

Originally posted by random49er:

Originally posted by TheWooLick:

Originally posted by random49er:

Originally posted by TheWooLick:

You literally asked if fans wanted the 49ers to be like two playoff teams who signed their FQBs. I say yes.

"to be like 2 playoff teams" --- this is a lie,...or a "Wooism" as I call them.

I specifically referred to the Chargers and Packers and NO!! We have higher goals than trying to match the quality of the Packers or Chargers.

Look who is making it personal again. I just explained my post, why does thst trigger an emotional response and insult from you?

I didn't lie about anything, I explained my perspective. You edited out the previous responses to hide this.

I have no idea what your point is, if ypu have one.

My point is we dont want to be like the Chargers or the Packers. Looking at both squads as they are, they're not our template.

Thanks
What should the team do with Brock Purdy? I think they should sign him and it'll cost them about what these other teams paid plus inflation. As you wisely noted, the cap number will be much lower than the average.

Originally posted by TheWooLick:
Thanks
What should the team do with Brock Purdy? I think they should sign him and it'll cost them about what these other teams paid plus inflation. As you wisely noted, the cap number will be much lower than the average.

the wise play would be let brock negotiate with other clubs, and see what he finds. he may find his market value isn't sky high. after all he was pick 262, and clubs like traits he doesn't really have like size and arm. so we may get a more reasonable deal than ppl think.

Brock getting paid because other QBs played like ass is the worst take I've ever heard.