QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:

Originally posted by TheWooLick:

Without 3 of his 4 best offensive teammates he led the 49ers to the 4th best total offense in the NFL after posting elite numbers in 2023.

Purdy is better than Love or Herbert.

Lol.

Why are you laughing at a statistical fact? Or, do you disagree that Aiyuk, Williams and McCaffery are 3 of the 4 best non QB offensive players?

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:
Never meant anything to you before lol. So you're now switching up and saying Jimmy played well in the playoffs? Brock haters know no end lol

Talk about deflecting. You're the one with the playoffs performance propaganda thing. I mean Lamar Jackson and Josh Allen played lights out in the playoffs, why should Brock be paid as much as them?

Please show me where I said I hate Brock? I've supported him plenty. I'm not gonna run around proclaiming him an elite level QB who deserves and elite level contract when he's not that.

this guy charlie get this he said he would ban me from the site cuz i think herbert is a good QB. that's who you are dealing with. notice no one gets like this in other threads. only QB threads. imagine if we had someone insisting you recognize jennings as the #1 WR in football and getting butthurt when you like other wide receivers around the league. crazy.

Originally posted by TheWooLick:
Why are you laughing at a statistical fact? Or, do you disagree that Aiyuk, Williams and McCaffery are 3 of the 4 best non QB offensive players?

I'm laughing at you cherry picking a yardage statistic that makes our offense look better than it was. You ignored the response to your post yesterday.

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

this guy charlie get this he said he would ban me from the site cuz i think herbert is a good QB. that's who you are dealing with. notice no one gets like this in other threads. only QB threads. imagine if we had someone insisting you recognize jennings as the #1 WR in football and getting butthurt when you like other wide receivers around the league. crazy.

Id ban you for downplaying Brock in the playoffs then turning around and making excuses for Herbert's performance. It's either too much bias or a major lack of understanding

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:

Originally posted by TheWooLick:

Why are you laughing at a statistical fact? Or, do you disagree that Aiyuk, Williams and McCaffery are 3 of the 4 best non QB offensive players?

I'm laughing at you cherry picking a yardage statistic that makes our offense look better than it was. You ignored the response to your post yesterday.

I am not cherry picking anything. He did lead the team to the 4th best total offense. I didn't ignore anything yeatsrday. I acknowledged that I referred to Total Offense when I said 4th best offense.

He also had the 4th most passing yards and 4rd best YPC.

What point are you trying to make? I don't get your beef or your point, you don't counter with any facts or state your point.

Originally posted by TheWooLick:
Without 3 of his 4 best offensive teammates he led the 49ers to the 4th best total offense in the NFL after posting elite numbers in 2023.

Purdy is better than Love or Herbert.

Not a single rational football mind would say brock is better than Herbert. I mean you're never gonna have an objective take regarding the 49ers so I'm not gonna go back and forth with you. That's a waste of time.

Jimmy avg the same yards per game on injury riddled team in 2020. He avg more pt per game that yr as well. And we all KNOW Jimmy ain't it.

What's the common denominator? Kyle.

look I like Brock, I think he's a good QB (better than Jimmy for sure). IMO 2023 could have very well been his best season ever though. He should get paid and be the starter going forward. Acting like he's some elite level QB that you could just input anywhere and make that team much better is fantasy talk.

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
this guy charlie get this he said he would ban me from the site cuz i think herbert is a good QB. that's who you are dealing with. notice no one gets like this in other threads. only QB threads. imagine if we had someone insisting you recognize jennings as the #1 WR in football and getting butthurt when you like other wide receivers around the league. crazy.

Id ban you for downplaying Brock in the playoffs then turning around and making excuses for Herbert's performance. It's either too much bias or a major lack of understanding

i haven't followed you guys on the topic, but that for sure is faith's contradictory logic

ppl get emotionally invested in the QB, hey fair enough, that's being a fan. but at the end of the day we are the 49ers, not the SF brock's. so i hope he gets his payday, deserved btw, and we get a fair offer also. he's not worth a fortune on the market imo. teams look for size and arm and stuff he doesn't really bring to the table.

Some offensive statistics:

Yards: 4th
Points: 13th
Yards per point: 27th
3rd down conversion percentage: 9th
Red Zone TD percentage: 13th
Total Giveaways (includes ST): 27th

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

ppl get emotionally invested in the QB, hey fair enough, that's being a fan. but at the end of the day we are the 49ers, not the SF brock's. so i hope he gets his payday, deserved btw, and we get a fair offer also. he's not worth a fortune on the market imo. teams look for size and arm and stuff he doesn't really bring to the table.

And people get emotionally invested in bringing down a qb, hey fair enough, that's being a hater

Originally posted by TheWooLick:
I am not cherry picking anything. He did lead the team to the 4th best total offense. I didn't ignore anything yeatsrday. I acknowledged that I referred to Total Offense when I said 4th best offense.

He also had the 4th most passing yards and 4rd best YPC.

What point are you trying to make? I don't get your beef or your point, you don't counter with any facts or state your point.

My point is the same as it was yesterday. If you think this was a top 5 offense, you're nuts. Yards mean very little, especially when you are one of the worst teams in the NFL at converting those yards into points (like we were).

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

this guy charlie get this he said he would ban me from the site cuz i think herbert is a good QB. that's who you are dealing with. notice no one gets like this in other threads. only QB threads. imagine if we had someone insisting you recognize jennings as the #1 WR in football and getting butthurt when you like other wide receivers around the league. crazy.

Id ban you for downplaying Brock in the playoffs then turning around and making excuses for Herbert's performance. It's either too much bias or a major lack of understanding

i haven't followed you guys on the topic, but that for sure is faith's contradictory logic

Dude just runs himself in circles lol

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:
You don't have to say you hate him. It's been clear for years

I don't think he's elite, I think he's good. Why is that a bad thing.

It's the typical fan over valuing "their" QB. Then getting all butt hurt if someone doesn't agree…we did this with Alex Smith, Kap, Jimmy and now Brock. it's funny it's ALWAYS the same posters defending "their" QB and taking s**t too personal when not everyone agrees 100%

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:
You didn't think he'd be better than Trey Lance either. I knew you were wrong before, and I know you are wrong again

Cute fabrication, but Trey Lance really never played. I dont have preconceived notions about any player until I've seen enough of them.

He will average a $55M cap hit? Let's see what happens.