QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by Cisco0623:

Originally posted by CatchMaster80:

Originally posted by Cisco0623:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by Cisco0623:

I hear you, but the whole is greater than the sum of the parts etc. Herbert and Love have bigger arms but smaller brains which come playoff time...is kinda obvious and important lol

I think he's not elite, but who is? Like 4 qb each generation. He is a tier below that imo. Top 10 QB. He will get paid. No matter how, much someone will b***h.

Outside of that playoff game Herbert had 3 INTs all yr. He's regarded as a super smart QB who can process well. So no I don't buy he has a "small brain"

FWIW Brock had a 2.6 INT% while Herbert had a 0.6 INT %

I'm not talking about generational, I'm talking about an elite compared to your peers.

Yes. So Brock is at least as good as Herbert if not better imo. I would say the elite/generational are Mahomes, Allen, Lamar, Burrow. After I would say Brock is in the conversation with anyone else.

If Herbert has played for the 49ers in Kyle's system he would be much better than he is now. His physical tools have never rbeen in doubt and he's really smart so I'm sure he could learn Kyle's system. We've seen QBs on the Niners that suffered because of bad coaches. Alex Smith might have had a decent career with a good coach from the start.

While I don't disagree, we can't deal in fantasy. Some argue Kyle limits QB's and they regress etc. I think everyone has a point but for me Brock has been very good. He is a top 10 starter since he took over and he's getting paid. How much? Who knows? I really don't care. That's Lynch's job.

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by TheWooLick:

Without 3 of his 4 best offensive teammates he led the 49ers to the 4th best total offense in the NFL after posting elite numbers in 2023.

Purdy is better than Love or Herbert.

Not a single rational football mind would say brock is better than Herbert. I mean you're never gonna have an objective take regarding the 49ers so I'm not gonna go back and forth with you. That's a waste of time.

Jimmy avg the same yards per game on injury riddled team in 2020. He avg more pt per game that yr as well. And we all KNOW Jimmy ain't it.

What's the common denominator? Kyle.

look I like Brock, I think he's a good QB (better than Jimmy for sure). IMO 2023 could have very well been his best season ever though. He should get paid and be the starter going forward. Acting like he's some elite level QB that you could just input anywhere and make that team much better is fantasy talk.

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:
You never gave Trey a pass? Never excuses for the weather or anything? You're so full of s**t dude

Originally posted by TheWooLick:
How about at the end of 2023, would most have taken Brock or Herbert?
I am acting like he put elie numbers in 2023. It could be his best season or his 5th best.

Originally posted by Cisco0623:
Yes. So Brock is at least as good as Herbert if not better imo. I would say the elite/generational are Mahomes, Allen, Lamar, Burrow. After I would say Brock is in the conversation with anyone else.

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:
We're comparing how ny treats QBs he likes and how he treats QBs he doesnt like

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:
I just don't buy anything you're selling lol. Your posts tell me everything I need to know

Originally posted by NYniner85:
My posts are being objective and that bothers you. There's more than two options outside of being in love with or hating a player. Sorry if that's hard for you to grasp.

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

I just don't buy anything you're selling lol. Your posts tell me everything I need to know

My posts are being objective and that bothers you. There's more than two options outside of being in love with or hating a player. Sorry if that's hard for you to grasp.

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
i am coming to realize a lot of ppl probably just watch 49er football. so when you get into takes about lamar jackson they say stuff like, 'oh him.. he sucks, never done anything in playoffs'. and so forth. so they go around thinking brock is better than lamar.

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:

My point is the same as it was yesterday. If you think this was a top 5 offense, you're nuts. Yards mean very little, especially when you are one of the worst teams in the NFL at converting those yards into points (like we were).

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
i am coming to realize a lot of ppl probably just watch 49er football. so when you get into takes about lamar jackson they say stuff like, 'oh him.. he sucks, never done anything in playoffs'. and so forth. so they go around thinking brock is better than lamar.