QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by TheWooLick:

Originally posted by RonnieLott:
Yes Brock has had one "elite" year out of 3 atm.

Are we going to sign our future to that?

That is how it usually works. What do you think the team should do?

Offer him a fair deal and if he sticks his nose up to it wanting what Dak and Burrow got, say go see if anyone will pay you that kind of cash (no one will) or play out the contract and show everyone 2023 wasn't you peak yr in the league.

You don't think he deserves what Dak Prescott got or Joe Burrow?

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Again I didn't say don't pay him. Baker mayfield might have done a lot of that same s**t in TB and he's not getting Dak cash?

where was that passer rating in the 4th QR this yr when we really needed him to step up and win some games?

Baker has bounced around some and played 8 years in the league. He is what he is. Brock has 2 full seasons. Hes young. Young QBs that have earned an extension with their franchise do not get Baker deals dude

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by TheWooLick:

I dont think he will be paid like Mahomes.
More like with Hebert or Love.

I never said I thought he should be the top paid QB. I am just not really worried about the contract, it will work out to be cap friendly enough.

Mahomes' contract is so unique, no one signs a 10 yr deal. KC f**ked Mahomes and his agent. KC will just continue to restructure his contract and they will have cap space over and over because he's a generational QB. It's not like they plan to cut him anytime soon because of poor play.

Herbert has practical GTD cash of around $218M. There is absolutely no way Brock should be getting that kind of money after one very good yr of football.

How about Goff, Tua, Love or Lawrence money?

Originally posted by Furlow:
Game manager

Decent pic.twitter.com/LOraf9F9iJ

— Brad (@Graham_SFN) January 14, 2025

Every QB in the NFL can do this

Originally posted by Kolohe:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by TheWooLick:

Originally posted by RonnieLott:
Yes Brock has had one "elite" year out of 3 atm.

Are we going to sign our future to that?

That is how it usually works. What do you think the team should do?

Offer him a fair deal and if he sticks his nose up to it wanting what Dak and Burrow got, say go see if anyone will pay you that kind of cash (no one will) or play out the contract and show everyone 2023 wasn't you peak yr in the league.

You don't think he deserves what Dak Prescott got or Joe Burrow?

Just because some team was foolish enough to overpay a player doesn't mean the next team has to match it or exeed it. I don't know much about Purdy's agent so I have no idea how tough he is in negotiations. Players should be paid based on how valuable their team feels he is and not onwhat some other guy got paid. I know that that's not how they're doing it now. I'm saying the current way is wrong.

Originally posted by CatchMaster80:

Originally posted by Kolohe:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by TheWooLick:

Originally posted by RonnieLott:
Yes Brock has had one "elite" year out of 3 atm.

Are we going to sign our future to that?

That is how it usually works. What do you think the team should do?

Offer him a fair deal and if he sticks his nose up to it wanting what Dak and Burrow got, say go see if anyone will pay you that kind of cash (no one will) or play out the contract and show everyone 2023 wasn't you peak yr in the league.

You don't think he deserves what Dak Prescott got or Joe Burrow?

Just because some team was foolish enough to overpay a player doesn't mean the next team has to match it or exeed it. I don't know much about Purdy's agent so I have no idea how tough he is in negotiations. Players should be paid based on how valuable their team feels he is and not onwhat some other guy got paid. I know that that's not how they're doing it now. I'm saying the current way is wrong.

Then every owner in sports are fools, because all athletes are overpaid. Don't hate the player, hate the game to all you haters.

Originally posted by Furlow:

Originally posted by Furlow:
Game manager

Decent pic.twitter.com/LOraf9F9iJ

— Brad (@Graham_SFN) January 14, 2025

Every QB in the NFL can do this

🪤 pic.twitter.com/jQTa0SKMDD

— Brad (@Graham_SFN) January 15, 2025

But he's not tall so

Not a difference maker. He's Jared Goff if everything is perfect

Originally posted by mayo49:

Originally posted by CatchMaster80:

Originally posted by Kolohe:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by TheWooLick:

Originally posted by RonnieLott:
Yes Brock has had one "elite" year out of 3 atm.

Are we going to sign our future to that?

That is how it usually works. What do you think the team should do?

Offer him a fair deal and if he sticks his nose up to it wanting what Dak and Burrow got, say go see if anyone will pay you that kind of cash (no one will) or play out the contract and show everyone 2023 wasn't you peak yr in the league.

You don't think he deserves what Dak Prescott got or Joe Burrow?

Just because some team was foolish enough to overpay a player doesn't mean the next team has to match it or exeed it. I don't know much about Purdy's agent so I have no idea how tough he is in negotiations. Players should be paid based on how valuable their team feels he is and not onwhat some other guy got paid. I know that that's not how they're doing it now. I'm saying the current way is wrong.

Then every owner in sports is foolish, because all athletes are overpaid. Don't hate the player, hate the game to all you haters.

I don't hate the players. I hate the current system. The NFL has a lot of ego driven owners now that will pay anything to land a big name. Many have no real idea on how to build a football team.

Originally posted by NYniner85:
Again I didn't say don't pay him.

Then why are you going on and on and on?

If you think Brock has earned the right to be this team's QB for at least the next few years, then you pay him. It's literally that simple. Just because you don't think he should be paid $50m+ a season is irrelevant. That's what the market for a very good young QB, who is ready for his first contract extension. "Who else would give him that type of money" is an irrelevant hypothetical, and not a reflection of what the QB market is.

Originally posted by CatchMaster80:
Just because some team was foolish enough to overpay a player doesn't mean the next team has to match it or exeed it.

Yeah we need to stop saying this. The 49ers aren't responsible for changing what the entire league does in regards to paying it's young QB. The Jags, Dolphins and Packers have young QBs that their franchise believes in. So do the 49ers. It's literally that simple.

Originally posted by CatchMaster80:

Originally posted by mayo49:

Originally posted by CatchMaster80:

Originally posted by Kolohe:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by TheWooLick:

Originally posted by RonnieLott:
Yes Brock has had one "elite" year out of 3 atm.

Are we going to sign our future to that?

That is how it usually works. What do you think the team should do?

Offer him a fair deal and if he sticks his nose up to it wanting what Dak and Burrow got, say go see if anyone will pay you that kind of cash (no one will) or play out the contract and show everyone 2023 wasn't you peak yr in the league.

You don't think he deserves what Dak Prescott got or Joe Burrow?

Just because some team was foolish enough to overpay a player doesn't mean the next team has to match it or exeed it. I don't know much about Purdy's agent so I have no idea how tough he is in negotiations. Players should be paid based on how valuable their team feels he is and not onwhat some other guy got paid. I know that that's not how they're doing it now. I'm saying the current way is wrong.

Then every owner in sports is foolish, because all athletes are overpaid. Don't hate the player, hate the game to all you haters.

I don't hate the players. I hate the current system. The NFL has a lot of ego driven owners now that will pay anything to land a big name. Many have no real idea on how to build a football team.

It all evens out, you overpay here only to make it up over there.

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:

Originally posted by CatchMaster80:

Just because some team was foolish enough to overpay a player doesn't mean the next team has to match it or exeed it.

Yeah we need to stop saying this. The 49ers aren't responsible for changing what the entire league does in regards to paying it's young QB. The Jags, Dolphins and Packers have young QBs that their franchise believes in. So do the 49ers. It's literally that simple.

And there's a reason things are the way they are. Jerry tried to fight it with his Trey trade, but the reality is it's hard as hell to find a competent qb

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:

Originally posted by CatchMaster80:
Just because some team was foolish enough to overpay a player doesn't mean the next team has to match it or exeed it.

Yeah we need to stop saying this. The 49ers aren't responsible for changing what the entire league does in regards to paying it's young QB. The Jags, Dolphins and Packers have young QBs that their franchise believes in. So do the 49ers. It's literally that simple.

Look I get it. I understand how the leqgue currently works. I'm just looking down the road and voicing my concerns about the direction the legue is heding. The NFL is riding high right now but success doesn't last forever. Other sports that once were popular have faded. We've seen major companies fold because they weren't run properly. It can happen to the NFL if they aren't careful. Many of the fans on this forum ar eprobably under 50 or even 40. For them the NFL has always ruled. I can remember when they didn't rule. College football was more popular and so was baseball.

Pete Roselle was largely responsible for the growth of the NFL. Now I see crazy rules being instituted and cash being thrown around like it's monopoly money. The league needs to take a step back and look at the future a little more instead of basking in the glow of today.

Originally posted by CatchMaster80:

Just because some team was foolish enough to overpay a player doesn't mean the next team has to match it or exeed it. I don't know much about Purdy's agent so I have no idea how tough he is in negotiations. Players should be paid based on how valuable their team feels he is and not onwhat some other guy got paid. I know that that's not how they're doing it now. I'm saying the current way is wrong.

The market is set based on what others have been paid.

That is how it works.