There are 397 users in the forums
Originally posted by mayo49:
Everyone complains about Brocks arm. Well, there was a guy here with an average arm that delivered us 3 Super Bowls, by the name of Joe Montana. So, this criticism of him doesn't fly with me.
Originally posted by CharlieSheen:
I didnt want to see him play anymore. I knew he was garbage
Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
he came in balling, then the book is out on how to defend. that happens to all QBs, and they need to find ways to be successful when the D knows what they do well and how to stop it. understand, this contract negotiation is taking place and he's kinda been figured out. he hasn't yet made that next step to avoid the middle of the field and make teams pay outside the numbers or downfield. i see us forcing throws over the middle all the time, and the D sits on it. it's a red flag.
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by mayo49:
Everyone complains about Brocks arm. Well, there was a guy here with an average arm that delivered us 3 Super Bowls, by the name of Joe Montana. So, this criticism of him doesn't fly with me.
Acting like every weak armed QB is Joe Montana is dumb. Joe had a better arm, bigger hands was taller and more accurate.
it's not criticism it's facts of the situation. Also not all cannon armed 6-4 230 b QBs are Dan Marino either
Originally posted by NYniner85:Originally posted by CharlieSheen:I didnt want to see him play anymore. I knew he was garbage
And that's fine. Brock made him expendable. I admit that.
Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:since you don't watch football... that's the very reason why i said you shouldn't hang any hat on 2024 as a measuring stick.
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
i wouldn't hang any hat on 2024 as some measuring stick for Purdy and a lot of other 49ers
Purdy was making a lot of tight window throws in 2022 and 2023 and it's why everyone was loving this kid. Not sure how accurate that opinion is
he came in balling, then the book is out on how to defend. that happens to all QBs, and they need to find ways to be successful when the D knows what they do well and how to stop it. understand, this contract negotiation is taking place and he's kinda been figured out. he hasn't yet made that next step to avoid the middle of the field and make teams pay outside the numbers or downfield. i see us forcing throws over the middle all the time, and the D sits on it. it's a red flag.
Originally posted by mayo49:
Quarterbacks are the point guards of the team. I don't care if your Mugsy Boggs or Magic Johnson, the job of the quarterback is to get the ball to his playmakers. Hand the ball off to his runningback or deliver a ball to his receivers and TE's. I don't give a s**t if you blow the ball to them and are a midget. You get paid to make plays, whatever shape you happen to be. Those who can get it done, get the bags.
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by mayo49:
Quarterbacks are the point guards of the team. I don't care if your Mugsy Boggs or Magic Johnson, the job of the quarterback is to get the ball to his playmakers. Hand the ball off to his runningback or deliver a ball to his receivers and TE's. I don't give a s**t if you blow the ball to them and are a midget. You get paid to make plays, whatever shape you happen to be. Those who can get it done, get the bags.
So where was that point guard this yr?
no s**t you get paid to make plays. In a league where you're playing against the biggest and fastest athletes in the world, more often than not you have to be big and fast all the same. It's not rocket science man. There's a reason there's thresholds for position groups and why there isn't many 5-10 NBA players. That's the reality of professional sports
Originally posted by CharlieSheen:
It was clear as day for some of us. I have to question the ones who couldn't tell. Trey really showed who only sees the qb position at surface level. Physical attributes do not guarantee you a future in the nfl
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by CharlieSheen:
It was clear as day for some of us. I have to question the ones who couldn't tell. Trey really showed who only sees the qb position at surface level. Physical attributes do not guarantee you a future in the nfl
So what…should we draft a 200lb OT who's got 31" arms because he can process fast? Maybe a 180lb LBer who 5-10 that can process quickly?
why are the majority of early picks at QB strong armed bigger people? Oh I don't know because it's the freaking NFL. People are big and fast. Shocking on know.
lance's biggest problem was he simply didn't play enough football and still hasn't. Brock played a f**k ton of football and showed he could come in and play right away. The way our team was setup Brock fit the bill at that pt and time. Good on him to take advantage of everything. Awesome story for sure.
How much more can he improve? That's the debate. How much does he need around him to be successful? That's the debate.
Originally posted by mayo49:
He was throwing passes and handing off to his backups, while his OL was whiffing on blocks.
Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
200m is a lot of coin. he would be wise to get set for life.
if push comes to shove, tell brock and his agent to find the 60m aav deal they are seeking. i doubt they find that from any team. i view this as more about what is the league willing to pay this man. not so much about his peers. most of his peers are round 1 guys with those high end tools GMs like. we can say those tools don't matter, but we know that's what GMs are looking for and prize. teams would rather draft a QB on the rook contract than give up a pick then pay brock $60m. no team wants to do that.
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by mayo49:
He was throwing passes and handing off to his backups, while his OL was whiffing on blocks.
Yet other QBs who had s**t OLs (worse than ours) or didn't have pro-bowl play makers around him did more. Again the question isn't does Brock suck. We know he doesn't. The question is how much MORE does he need compared to other highly paid QBs to have a successful season?
Originally posted by NYniner85:Originally posted by CharlieSheen:It was clear as day for some of us. I have to question the ones who couldn't tell. Trey really showed who only sees the qb position at surface level. Physical attributes do not guarantee you a future in the nfl
So what…should we draft a 200lb OT who's got 31" arms because he can process fast? Maybe a 180lb LBer who 5-10 that can process quickly?
why are the majority of early picks at QB strong armed bigger people? Oh I don't know because it's the freaking NFL. People are big and fast. Shocking on know.
lance's biggest problem was he simply didn't play enough football and still hasn't. Brock played a f**k ton of football and showed he could come in and play right away. The way our team was setup Brock fit the bill at that pt and time. Good on him to take advantage of everything. Awesome story for sure.
How much more can he improve? That's the debate. How much does he need around him to be successful? That's the debate.
