QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by TheWooLick:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
we really need Strwy in here asap

No one knows what this means.

just think of his usual post that he is known for

Originally posted by TheWooLick:
OK, my bad. So, yiu are super upset because someone ranked him 1st in 2023 instead of 2nd or 3rd?

Im not upset. I disagree, and so does the bulk of the football watching world.

I'm not upset that fans can't see through team statistics. It's typical.

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:
Im not upset. I disagree, and so does the bulk of the football watching world.

I'm not upset that fans can't see through team statistics. It's typical.

All statistics are team statistics. Stop pretending you have anything valuable to say.

Originally posted by FootballExpert49ers:
They're not voting based on how they played in 2023. Maybe try learning some reading comprehension.

Haha. You have to be kidding.

Originally posted by FootballExpert49ers:
All statistics are team statistics. Stop pretending you have anything valuable to say.

Agreed.

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:
Haha. You have to be kidding.

Why would I be kidding? Nobody's voting based on how they played in 2023.

You think people were voting for the QB who was 29th in air yards per completion, led the 15th ranked scoring offense, and did so in the most QB friendly scheme in the history of professional football, because of how amazeballs he played last year? They don't change rankings much year to year because that's not how they think about the game.

It's like how the same guys make the Pro Bowl at offensive line year after year. You think anybody (other than PFF, but they're idiots) is paying close attention to how those guys play each year?

Newsflash, dips**t: They don't spend time reviewing the film each week of every team in football.

Quenton Nelson would get "best guard" every year.

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by TheWooLick:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
we really need Strwy in here asap

No one knows what this means.

just think of his usual post that he is known for

Got you.

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:

Originally posted by TheWooLick:
OK, my bad. So, yiu are super upset because someone ranked him 1st in 2023 instead of 2nd or 3rd?

Im not upset. I disagree, and so does the bulk of the football watching world.

I'm not upset that fans can't see through team statistics. It's typical.

Which QB statistic is only from the QB?

Originally posted by FootballExpert49ers:
He doesn't need to be eligible to be a free agent. He has all the leverage in that situation. The team would have to commit a s**tload of cap room to a guy who refuses to play.

Also, who cares if he wants to be the highest paid player in football? What difference does that make?

His cap hit next yr is $5M, he's not a FA. He has little leverage. There is no tag option.

yeah you're right we should have made BA the highest paid WR too. They should give Dre $100M and make him the highest paid LBer. Banks let's give him $80M. So on and so on. Who cares amirite?

folks b***hing about the OL, the defense and playmakers around Brock being the reason he had a down yr and how they need better players around him…AND want to take all that cash and give it to Brock

Originally posted by RonnieLott:
Purdy can only shine when he is surrounded by an All Pro supporting cast.

If he only has average players around him, he will lose.

Wow haven't heard that before how original.

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:
Agreed.

You'll use them selectively when you want to defend an argument.

You lied about the context for posting the Stat Paddy Mahomo numbers. I said Mahomo had bad PERFORMANCES in SUPER BOWLS, and you then posted his playoff numbers and called him one of the greatest players evarrrr.

Originally posted by FootballExpert49ers:
Why would I be kidding? Nobody's voting based on how they played in 2023.

You think people were voting for the QB who was 29th in air yards per completion, led the 15th ranked scoring offense, and did so in the most QB friendly scheme in the history of professional football, because of how amazeballs he played last year? They don't change rankings much year to year because that's not how they think about the game.

It's like how the same guys make the Pro Bowl at offensive line year after year. You think anybody (other than PFF, but they're idiots) is paying close attention to how those guys play each year?

Newsflash, dips**t: They don't spend time reviewing the film each week of every team in football.

Quenton Nelson would get "best guard" every year.

Those surveys, year by year player rankings, all pro voting, anybody actually watching the film.

Nobody agree with your position. Because it's laughably bad. You're free to hang onto it though.

Originally posted by FootballExpert49ers:
You'll use them selectively when you want to defend an argument.

You lied about the context for posting the Stat Paddy Mahomo numbers. I said Mahomo had bad PERFORMANCES in SUPER BOWLS, and you then posted his playoff numbers and called him one of the greatest players evarrrr.

I posted numbers that people commonly use to judge players… ie used your own argument against you. I fully understood you and Montana were isolating the SB. I expanded it to show how good he's been in the most important games by your own idiotic standards.

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by FootballExpert49ers:
He doesn't need to be eligible to be a free agent. He has all the leverage in that situation. The team would have to commit a s**tload of cap room to a guy who refuses to play.

Also, who cares if he wants to be the highest paid player in football? What difference does that make?

His cap hit next yr is $5M, he's not a FA. He has little leverage. There is no tag option.

yeah you're right we should have made BA the highest paid WR too. They should give Dre $100M and make him the highest paid LBer. Banks let's give him $80M. So on and so on. Who cares amirite?

folks b***hing about the OL, the defense and playmakers around Brock being the reason he had a down yr and how they need better players around him…AND want to take all that cash and give it to Brock

Why do you guys keep saying he has little leverage? What is the team going to do if he holds out? What is your plan for QB if not Purdy? Don't you think Lynch and Kyle are wondering the same thing? Lol

Originally posted by Furlow:
Why do you guys keep saying he has little leverage? What is the team going to do if he holds out? What is your plan for QB is not Purdy? Don't you think Lynch and Kyle are wondering the same thing? Lol

We don't want to let him hold out. You can try to sign a player that would indicate a willingness to do so, when you don't want it to happen. It's a gamble.