QB Brock Purdy Thread

We over pay Brock. We dead for a number of years.

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:

Originally posted by NYniner85:
I feel like I've been pretty transparent about all of it lol. I'm not even sure what everyone is so bent out of shape about?

I blame the schools, lol.

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
NY is.. and that's what i'm myth busting it

Except NY suggests it if and only if Brock wants a top tier deal, ie there's an impasse in negotiations.

He has flat out stated if Brock were to take Love like deal, he'd support it.

Not a single person has suggested to just let him test the market outright. The first thing any team would do is offer a contract favorable to the team. This goes without saying, or at least should*

I feel like I've been pretty transparent about all of it lol. I'm not even sure what everyone is so bent out of shape about?

are you ok with Brock at 55?

Hey Expert, go check out the post about Mahomes and Andy Reid in the Shanahan thread. Humor me, lol.

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
are you ok with Brock at 55?

no. that's far too old for nfl QB

Originally posted by RonnieLott:
We over pay Brock. We dead for a number of years.

Stop it.

We made Jimmy G the highest paid QB and did fine. And I don't want to hear how different the roster was or how the cap situation was different.

The rules are simple - draft well and make smart low money free agent signings and you get to keep putting a good team out there with Purdy.

Draft poorly and you're going to struggle regardless of who your QB is.

Everyone expected the Chiefs to crumble once Mahomes big money kicked in. How's that going? They rebuild their whole OL in one offseason. They turned their defense from mediocre to dominant in a couple of seasons.

This regime is tied with the Ravens for most first team all pros selected since 2017. People can try to pretend Adam Peters was critical in those decisions and maybe he was in some cases but all I know is we had what looks to be a hell of a draft without Adam here and if we make a quality hire on DC should continue to draft well overall.

Brock's deal is not going to handicap us. The only thing that would do that is poor drafting.

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:
And Tom lost a SB in his prime on one the best teams ever. Which means not winning with the best roster you played on does not mean you're screwed

you are doing pretzel logic. firstly, it was one of the best teams cuz of brady. didn't he put up 50 TDs? win MVP?

also he brought that city 6 rings. they were team of the decade for back to back decades. there was no question of oh he didn't win on the rook deal, can he win making the big bucks? that was never a tom brady conversation.

Originally posted by RonnieLott:
the fact is Purdy was worse this year than last year.

Without an All-Star backing group, Purdy struggled, and we didn't even make the play offs.

Is that the future, the destiny that you want for this franchise?

There were arguably 3 players this season on this team who improved on their play or played the same from last season.

One of them was Colton McKivitz…

You expecting Brock to work miracles?

meh

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by RonnieLott:
the fact is Purdy was worse this year than last year.

Without an All-Star backing group, Purdy struggled, and we didn't even make the play offs.

Is that the future, the destiny that you want for this franchise?

There were arguably 3 players this season on this team who improved on their play or played the same from last season.

One of them was Colton McKivitz…

You expecting Brock to work miracles?

that's right; great Quarterbacks work miracles.

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

And Tom lost a SB in his prime on one the best teams ever. Which means not winning with the best roster you played on does not mean you're screwed

you are doing pretzel logic. firstly, it was one of the best teams cuz of brady. didn't he put up 50 TDs? win MVP?

also he brought that city 6 rings. they were team of the decade for back to back decades. there was no question of oh he didn't win on the rook deal, can he win making the big bucks? that was never a tom brady conversation.

It's not a question for me either. He doesn't get injured he wins his first year. CMC doesn't fumble, or Kyle knows the OT rules and he wins back to back. It didn't happen, but that's just football. I don't question whether he could though

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:
It's not a question for me either. He doesn't get injured he wins his first year. CMC doesn't fumble, or Kyle knows the OT rules and he wins back to back. It didn't happen, but that's just football. I don't question whether he could though

I also think he could on that team. Good chance we don't have it again. He may never play as well as he* did either. Things change fast.

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

It's not a question for me either. He doesn't get injured he wins his first year. CMC doesn't fumble, or Kyle knows the OT rules and he wins back to back. It didn't happen, but that's just football. I don't question whether he could though

I also think he could on that team. Good chance we don't have it again. He may never play as well as he* did either. Things change fast.

Awesome

Things change fast and then things go slowly as well.

Imagine if Jake Moody were Toms kicker lol. I have a feeling he doesn't have all those rings on his rookie deal lmao