QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by TheWooLick:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
what is indisputable? i'm not even an alex guy. i got tired of alex. but i do understand the situation he walked into, vs the situation brock walked into. they were not the same. brock i am sure struggles in 2005, and alex no doubt is better set up in 2022. alex won like 100 games, it's way too early to be doing brock purdy career comps with guys who played a long time.

Purdy was better in 2023 than Alex Smith was at any time in his career.

just hard to say that with all the variables around the QB being different. QB is very much a game of what is around you to work with, who is your playcaller, etc. we just saw that with brock. brock's situation changed, and the bottom fell out. we finished in last place.

i would say something like the 2023 49ers had a better O than any Smith O perhaps. that sounds correct. brock plays a role in 2023 so does kyle, trent, cmc, BA, kittle, deebo, those are not bad players and coaches. my theory is a ton of QBs like alex once he became functional, could thrive in that situation, like brock did.

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by TheWooLick:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

what is indisputable? i'm not even an alex guy. i got tired of alex. but i do understand the situation he walked into, vs the situation brock walked into. they were not the same. brock i am sure struggles in 2005, and alex no doubt is better set up in 2022. alex won like 100 games, it's way too early to be doing brock purdy career comps with guys who played a long time.

Purdy was better in 2023 than Alex Smith was at any time in his career.

just hard to say that with all the variables around the QB being different. QB is very much a game of what is around you to work with, who is your playcaller, etc. we just saw that with brock. brock's situation changed, and the bottom fell out. we finished in last place.

i would say something like the 2023 49ers had a better O than any Smith O perhaps. that sounds correct. brock plays a role in 2023 so does kyle, trent, cmc, BA, kittle, deebo, those are not bad players and coaches. my theory is a ton of QBs like alex once he became functional, could thrive in that situation, like brock did.

Alex threw to Hill Maclin and Kelce and ended up with like 15 tds lol. He had Hill Kelce and the NFL rush leader in 2017 along with a good line. That's a better #1, a better receiving TE, the nfls top rusher, better OL, and he still couldn't do better as a 12 year vet than second year Brock

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by TheWooLick:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

what is indisputable? i'm not even an alex guy. i got tired of alex. but i do understand the situation he walked into, vs the situation brock walked into. they were not the same. brock i am sure struggles in 2005, and alex no doubt is better set up in 2022. alex won like 100 games, it's way too early to be doing brock purdy career comps with guys who played a long time.

Purdy was better in 2023 than Alex Smith was at any time in his career.

just hard to say that with all the variables around the QB being different. QB is very much a game of what is around you to work with, who is your playcaller, etc. we just saw that with brock. brock's situation changed, and the bottom fell out. we finished in last place.

i would say something like the 2023 49ers had a better O than any Smith O perhaps. that sounds correct. brock plays a role in 2023 so does kyle, trent, cmc, BA, kittle, deebo, those are not bad players and coaches. my theory is a ton of QBs like alex once he became functional, could thrive in that situation, like brock did.

Seems like you struggle to compare QBs.

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:
Alex threw to Hill Maclin and Kelce and ended up with like 15 tds lol. He had Hill Kelce and the NFL rush leader in 2017 along with a good line. That's a better #1, a better receiving TE, the nfls top rusher, better OL, and he still couldn't do better as a 12 year vet than second year Brock

talk about 3rd year brock. what happened? those KC teams were in the playoffs in that era. we just won 6 games, last place. i saw passes hanging in the air and crucial INTs at the worst moments. late season we could hardly score. score 6 points at home vs our rival. big money deals it's time to ask hard questions. not just pontificate all day about best in 40 years. that's terrible. and notice we always do this, jimmy was the best in 2017, colin in 2012, alex in 2011 and on it goes..

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Alex threw to Hill Maclin and Kelce and ended up with like 15 tds lol. He had Hill Kelce and the NFL rush leader in 2017 along with a good line. That's a better #1, a better receiving TE, the nfls top rusher, better OL, and he still couldn't do better as a 12 year vet than second year Brock

talk about 3rd year brock. what happened? those KC teams were in the playoffs in that era. we just won 6 games, last place. i saw passes hanging in the air and crucial INTs at the worst moments. late season we could hardly score. score 6 points at home vs our rival. big money deals it's time to ask hard questions. not just pontificate all day about best in 40 years. that's terrible. and notice we always do this, jimmy was the best in 2017, colin in 2012, alex in 2011 and on it goes..

Alex sucked compared to Brock. What happened this year is OL sucks and our best receiver was a 4.8 guy. Still top 10 in qbr and epa per play, so he was much better than you try to convince people

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:
Alex threw to Hill Maclin and Kelce and ended up with like 15 tds lol. He had Hill Kelce and the NFL rush leader in 2017 along with a good line. That's a better #1, a better receiving TE, the nfls top rusher, better OL, and he still couldn't do better as a 12 year vet than second year Brock

talk about 3rd year brock. what happened? those KC teams were in the playoffs in that era. we just won 6 games, last place. i saw passes hanging in the air and crucial INTs at the worst moments. late season we could hardly score. score 6 points at home vs our rival. big money deals it's time to ask hard questions. not just pontificate all day about best in 40 years. that's terrible. and notice we always do this, jimmy was the best in 2017, colin in 2012, alex in 2011 and on it goes..

Alex sucked compared to Brock. What happened this year is OL sucks and our best receiver was a 4.8 guy. Still top 10 in qbr and epa per play, so he was much better than you try to convince people

well lets do PB or comeback POY Alex vs 2024 brock who wins that? do we just get to cherry pick our years? you tell me how this works.

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

talk about 3rd year brock. what happened? those KC teams were in the playoffs in that era. we just won 6 games, last place. i saw passes hanging in the air and crucial INTs at the worst moments. late season we could hardly score. score 6 points at home vs our rival. big money deals it's time to ask hard questions. not just pontificate all day about best in 40 years. that's terrible. and notice we always do this, jimmy was the best in 2017, colin in 2012, alex in 2011 and on it goes..

Alex missed the playoffs in 2014, on a team that allowed the 2nd fewest points in the NFL.

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Alex threw to Hill Maclin and Kelce and ended up with like 15 tds lol. He had Hill Kelce and the NFL rush leader in 2017 along with a good line. That's a better #1, a better receiving TE, the nfls top rusher, better OL, and he still couldn't do better as a 12 year vet than second year Brock

talk about 3rd year brock. what happened? those KC teams were in the playoffs in that era. we just won 6 games, last place. i saw passes hanging in the air and crucial INTs at the worst moments. late season we could hardly score. score 6 points at home vs our rival. big money deals it's time to ask hard questions. not just pontificate all day about best in 40 years. that's terrible. and notice we always do this, jimmy was the best in 2017, colin in 2012, alex in 2011 and on it goes..

Alex sucked compared to Brock. What happened this year is OL sucks and our best receiver was a 4.8 guy. Still top 10 in qbr and epa per play, so he was much better than you try to convince people

well lets do PB or comeback POY Alex vs 2024 brock who wins that? do we just get to cherry pick our years? you tell me how this works.

Let's do bad situation to bad situation. Brock top 10 epa and qbr. Alex constantly benched

Now good situations. Brock blows him out there too

Brock has already had a better season than Alex ever had and he's doubled his playoff wins. He's only 3 years in lmao

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

well lets do PB or comeback POY Alex vs 2024 brock who wins that? do we just get to cherry pick our years? you tell me how this works.

Compare their best and worst seasons.

Originally posted by TheWooLick:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

talk about 3rd year brock. what happened? those KC teams were in the playoffs in that era. we just won 6 games, last place. i saw passes hanging in the air and crucial INTs at the worst moments. late season we could hardly score. score 6 points at home vs our rival. big money deals it's time to ask hard questions. not just pontificate all day about best in 40 years. that's terrible. and notice we always do this, jimmy was the best in 2017, colin in 2012, alex in 2011 and on it goes..

Alex missed the playoffs in 2014, on a team that allowed the 2nd fewest points in the NFL.

And didn't throw one TD to a receiver, still one of the craziest stats I've ever seen. Alex wasn't close to Brock

Purdy so good Brian Griese decided to stay.