QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by ninerfaninnorcal:
For me the next best thing to a Superbowl win was the Lions losing. And it happened. Misery craves misery and I feel so much better now that the Lions truly choked. I am so happy again! Hooray!

I'm with you, I'm feeling great!

Originally posted by DRCHOWDER:

Now that we've seen an *actual* game manager, Jared Goff, implode in the playoffs — safe to say Brock Purdy's perceived value has only again increased.

Playoff success is hard. It's been a remarkable 2 weeks of QB schooling for the casuals: https://t.co/iLnik07h5v

— David Lombardi (@LombardiHimself) January 19, 2025

:::::Brocks "Perceived Value" and Cap Hit Increases $15M/Yr While On the Sofa::::

Webzone 49er fans' reaction:

The 2 biggest plays in the Lions game were:
1. Goff fumbling in red zone already up 7-3 on 3rd and 1. They score and I bet Washington folds on the road and
(2) Too many men on 4th and 2. Detroit stopped them after half and Lions scored TD to go down just 3. I bet Wash doesn't make that 4th and 2 and Detroit goes on to win. Disastrous choke to have too many men on field for that play and then to not even call a timeout knowing it.

Winning the Super Bowl is an uphill battle for the NFC team in the next years.

The top 4 QB's are in the AFC and they all are under 30 and the best QB in the NFC is Stafford who is 36 so the gap in the QB position in the Super Bowl is gonna be too big to overcome fot the NFC team.

Mahomes/Allen/Burrow/Jackson vs Purdy/Goff/Hurts/Love

Those are probable matchups in the big game in the next years and all look very advantageous from the QB perspective for the AFC team.

Maybe Daniels is gonna be elite but we really don't know that yet because Stroud was amazing last season and this season he was mediocre.

Right now the power is in the AFC and I don't think that's gonna change soon.

Originally posted by Afrikan:

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:

Originally posted by Afrikan:

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:

Originally posted by Afrikan:
Luckily, the option of the franchise tag can buy you time. ????????‍?

But Kyle has always been about optics... for example he never likes the idea of the backup QB making more than the starting QB. Which is why he finally accepted Jimmy G back on the team if he took a contract paying him less than the 2nd year QB, Trey Lance.

So Kyle is gonna be all in for overpaying Brock on a long contract...instead of franchise tagging him (even though this would be the best option for the team). At least until Brock bounces back next season. Then it would be worth *overpaying* for him.

Dude, no it isnt. Why people keep saying this is beyond me. It is demonstrating you have no clue what you are talking about.

Like I said before, Brock will not hold out... he will not take the chance of another QB (with full OTA's + Training camp) running this QB friendly offense, with the playmakers we have. So yeah, let him play out 2025. Hell can use the excuse that the reason we have been successful for the past 4 years is because we have QBs on rookie deals.. and Brock is a continuation of that. Then decide to Tag or pay him next year.

Originally posted by ninerfaninnorcal:
Just read article that said 49'ers Insiders are saying 49'ers in no rush to give Brock a deal due to his inconsistent play.

there you go... we'll see.

now before some feel I'm some Brock hater.. I still believe in him, but I don't believe in him under Kyle anymore (enough to pay him $60+mill)... so for me to be convinced I would need to see if Kyle adjusts his offense next year and gives Brock more freedom at the line of scrimmage.

He will NEVER play out his contract without an extension. Nor will our team allow that. You arent living in reality if you think that is going to happen.

Also, saying "there you go" to a poster who just lied about 49ers insiders is just laughable. He didnt read any such article.

Why not? Are you looking at this from Brock Purdy's perspective or from the Organization's perspective? What's best for Brock or what's best for your 49ers?

We have seen on many occasions how the NFL is a business... how teams are a business. What makes Brock so special that the team shouldn't take all options into consideration? For what's best for the team? Especially if Brock's agent asks for $60+ Mill.

Because we see this with virtually every QB who signs a big deal. As soon as the guarantees are complete, QBs renegotiates and gets extended. Gives more guaranteed money, helps the team with the cap. Win win. Happens all the time. And if Purdy isnt living up to the money, we part ways. Its really that simple.

We are favored to win Super Bowl next year in Santa Clara with McCaffrey back. He was our leader and game changer and he will be back with a vengeance. Book it!

Originally posted by ninerfaninnorcal:
We are favored to win Super Bowl next year in Santa Clara with McCaffrey back. He was our leader and game changer and he will be back with a vengeance. Book it!

No we're not, lol.

Originally posted by ninerfaninnorcal:
The 2 biggest plays in the Lions game were:
1. Goff fumbling in red zone already up 7-3 on 3rd and 1. They score and I bet Washington folds on the road and
(2) Too many men on 4th and 2. Detroit stopped them after half and Lions scored TD to go down just 3. I bet Wash doesn't make that 4th and 2 and Detroit goes on to win. Disastrous choke to have too many men on field for that play and then to not even call a timeout knowing it.

This drive only happened cause of a horrible face mask call that didnt even happen.

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:
No we're not, lol.

We were favored last year and we have the same team returning for the most part. Our odds went down because of McCaffrey being out.

Originally posted by DRCHOWDER:
This drive only happened cause of a horrible face mask call that didnt even happen.

True. But it still happened.

Originally posted by ninerfaninnorcal:
We were favored last year and we have the same team returning for the most part. Our odds went down because of McCaffrey being out.

There are future odds available right now, fyi.

Originally posted by ninerfaninnorcal:

Originally posted by DRCHOWDER:
This drive only happened cause of a horrible face mask call that didnt even happen.

True. But it still happened.

Yes it did, I'm just pointing that out though.

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:
There are future odds available right now, fyi.

I'm giving you my odds and prediction. As long as we bring back the same team with McCaffrey healthy this next year, we should be one of the favorites again.

Originally posted by ninerfaninnorcal:
I'm giving you my odds and prediction. As long as we bring back the same team with McCaffrey healthy this next year, we should be one of the favorites again.

We'll be in the top 10 so I guess that would qualify. Probably best to see how the offseason plays out with the draft/FA. We have a lot of work to do.

Originally posted by DRCHOWDER:
Yes it did, I'm just pointing that out though.

Yes, and I remember thinking that the facemask was going to be a game changing bad call. But Detroit bailed out the refs and Washington with the 12 men on field. I bet Washington would not have converted and Detroit goes on to win. That play by Detroit will go down as one of the big ones in Detroit's agonizing NFL history, along with Dan's refusal against us last year to kick the field goal to go up 17 points midway through the 3rd to pretty much seal the game.