QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by captveg:

Originally posted by RonnieLott:
How many times this season did We get to redzone, lose a LT, illegal formation penalty negating a big Deebo play. Then Purdy throws a ground ball to the FB 8 yards short of the line to gain. Miss the FG.

In all that was the reason you can't pay Purdy top dollar...between scheme/playcalling, line and QB limitations when the offense gets into 3rd and long its a train wreck.

Originally posted by eric_anthony:

Y'all can laugh all you want but he isn't wrong. Hopefully Brock will look better next year with CMC or no CMC

Originally posted by 9ers4eva:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
i'd take hurts over brock. he fits what we are trying to do a lot more. if the goal is be physical and dominate the point of attack. if the goal is throw in breaking routes over the middle all day take brock.

He's incapable of reading a defense. That doesn't fit a damn thing.

Yea I don't agree with faithful here. Hurts is garbage

Originally posted by Strwy2Hevn:

Originally posted by eric_anthony:
Y'all can laugh all you want but he isn't wrong. Hopefully Brock will look better next year with CMC or no CMC

Originally posted by elguapo:

Originally posted by Strwy2Hevn:

Originally posted by eric_anthony:
Y'all can laugh all you want but he isn't wrong. Hopefully Brock will look better next year with CMC or no CMC

Originally posted by Silky:
Yea I don't agree with faithful here. Hurts is garbage

Faithful isn't a fan of qbs who read defenses at a high level.

Lol still the argument of the ppl around him? So redundant and lame lol. It's painfully obvious that every qb "needs help", that is the point of having, oh idk... a team? They all work for the win? Or do ppl know what teams are? Lol.
Ppl can't cry for Darnold anymore cause he took a big, fat dump in the playoffs..now ppl wanna cry about the old bs again. Keep cryin..keep recyclin'...
Purdy about to get that phat check The horror!

Originally posted by RonnieLott:
This is a cross roads year for Brock Purdy.

We have seen a sample size of two years.

One year Purdy had CMC and Aiyuk and looked all-pro because those two players got Purdy out of trouble a lot.

The next year, without those two players, Purdy looked pedestrian.

Purdy needs All Pro players around him else he is just another game manager.

Originally posted by 9ers4eva:

Originally posted by Silky:
Yea I don't agree with faithful here. Hurts is garbage

Faithful isn't a fan of qbs who read defenses at a high level.

Originally posted by 9ers4eva:

Originally posted by Silky:

Yea I don't agree with faithful here. Hurts is garbage

Faithful isn't a fan of qbs who read defenses at a high level.

If faith were the gm you could just show him a picture like this and he'd cut Brock the next day for the guy

Originally posted by 9ers4eva:

Originally posted by Silky:
Yea I don't agree with faithful here. Hurts is garbage

Faithful isn't a fan of qbs who read defenses at a high level.

i see faith turned troll now.. his evaluation though is still pretty consistently incorrect..

Pop gun arm.

Originally posted by RonnieLott:

Pop gun arm.

Originally posted by RonnieLott:

How many times this season did We get to redzone, lose a LT, illegal formation penalty negating a big Deebo play. Then Purdy throws a ground ball to the FB 8 yards short of the line to gain. Miss the FG.

In all that was the reason you can't pay Purdy top dollar...between scheme/playcalling, line and QB limitations when the offense gets into 3rd and long its a train wreck.

He was arguably the best deep ball passer in 2023.

Originally posted by RonnieLott:
How many times this season did We get to redzone, lose a LT, illegal formation penalty negating a big Deebo play. Then Purdy throws a ground ball to the FB 8 yards short of the line to gain. Miss the FG.

In all that was the reason you can't pay Purdy top dollar...between scheme/playcalling, line and QB limitations when the offense gets into 3rd and long its a train wreck.

I don't know you tell me but with all that nonsense you wrote I'm pretty sure it didn't happen very often since we only had so many LTs to lose and Juice had 31 targets all year long.

Here's a thought. Pay the first QB who has been playing consistent football in the regular season and playoffs and actually didn't hurt you during the playoffs, when you don't have a real option to replace him.

Pay him and then you know...look to improve the OL you're putting out there with him? Learn from the mistakes you saw happen this season and go into next year better prepared for what you're likely going to see?

That's what smart teams do. This desire by fans to swap QBs because "you can't pay him elite money when he's not elite" is nonsensical.

49ers are picking 11th in a draft that doesn't appear to be very strong at the position. You gain nothing by letting Brock play next year because if you're expecting the price to go DOWN, you're basically rooting against your own best interests which while you as fans have 0 skin in the game...Kyle and John most certainly don't want his price tag to go down next year.

And this is what some of you simply need to get through your heads - you're not making the decision. Kyle and John are.

He saved their ass from the Trey Lane disaster and for all the talk about his regression he put up a season that wasn't anything terrible. It was bad for HIS standards but when the whole team save like 3-4 players regress from the year prior, good luck having great numbers. Kyle didn't exactly help Brock much either for the majority of the year. We saved the easy button until injuries really killed the OL and we were almost out of contention. Why...good question.

Either way the solution forward is simple. Pay the guy who has won you a lot of games and clearly knows how to run this offense at a high level and make sure you set him up for success by building up the team around him and making the key changes coaching wise to give him that easy button all year.