QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:
Last year was only year 3. Top 10 as a 24 year old on a last place team. Sounds pretty good to me

top 10?

Yea

not close imo. why do we just do this at QB? why don't ppl go the jennings thread and say he's top 10? why can't jennings be good? why does everybody have to be top 10?

Well there's far more WRa

Originally posted by random49er:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Last year was only year 3. Top 10 as a 24 year old on a last place team. Sounds pretty good to me

top 10?

Yea

not close imo. why do we just do this at QB? why don't ppl go the jennings thread and say he's top 10? why can't jennings be good? why does everybody have to be top 10?

There were multiple metrics like qbr and epa that have him top 10. We don't do that for Jennings because he isn't a top 10 receiver

he's on the receiving end of those metrics tho

Yes a number 1 slow as molasses. Even more impressive from Brock

Loving 1 player on your "team" while aggressively attacking any of the other 10 players he plays with. I'll just never get the logic....lol.

Sorry I don't hate Brock enough to pretend he didn't have the slowest guy in the league posing as a #1. I know it's hard to understand somebody not hating Brock

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:
Sorry I don't hate Brock enough to pretend he didn't have the slowest guy in the league posing as a #1. I know it's hard to understand somebody not hating Brock

ah, so you knock jennings cuz he doesn't have the elite high end traits. interesting.

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Sorry I don't hate Brock enough to pretend he didn't have the slowest guy in the league posing as a #1. I know it's hard to understand somebody not hating Brock

ah, so you knock jennings cuz he doesn't have the elite high end traits. interesting.

He plays receiver. That's where you need those traits lmao. You grade Brock like he's a rb or receiver needing traits lol

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:
He plays receiver. That's where you need those traits lmao. You grade Brock like he's a rb or receiver needing traits lol

that's my opinion on how the game is going. steve young was talking on it. he said it's going towards more of a dual threat style of game.

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

He plays receiver. That's where you need those traits lmao. You grade Brock like he's a rb or receiver needing traits lol

that's my opinion on how the game is going. steve young was talking on it. he said it's going towards more of a dual threat style of game.

Good for him

Other than Mahomes it's Stafford and Brady that have won a championship recently. Only guys to beat Mahomes in playoffs are Burrow and Brady. Anybody telling you you need a hybrid qb/rb to win a championship is talking out their ass

looks like faith is now rooting against Purdy

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
looks like faith is now rooting against Purdy

it's rooting for the 49ers. if you think purdy is great, then it makes sense to pay him 500m perhaps. i'm a lil more critical after 2024. if we make him the top paid guy, we may be in for a decline as a franchise. that is my thought process. on a personal level i'm happy for this man to have success. i hope we get a deal that is friendly to the 49ers. he can still get his coin and we can get a deal also. what's wrong with that?

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
looks like faith is now rooting against Purdy

it's rooting for the 49ers. if you think purdy is great, then it makes sense to pay him 500m perhaps. i'm a lil more critical after 2024. if we make him the top paid guy, we may be in for a decline as a franchise. that is my thought process. on a personal level i'm happy for this man to have success. i hope we get a deal that is friendly to the 49ers. he can still get his coin and we can get a deal also. what's wrong with that?

haven't been paying attention at all.. the numbers change. like what johnny D told you..

What you should be worried about is future health of the team, like what happened in 2024

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
looks like faith is now rooting against Purdy

it's rooting for the 49ers. if you think purdy is great, then it makes sense to pay him 500m perhaps. i'm a lil more critical after 2024. if we make him the top paid guy, we may be in for a decline as a franchise. that is my thought process. on a personal level i'm happy for this man to have success. i hope we get a deal that is friendly to the 49ers. he can still get his coin and we can get a deal also. what's wrong with that?

haven't been paying attention at all.. the numbers change. like what johnny D told you..

What you sshould be worried about is future health of the team

i watched the JD vid and i saw his numbers also. i see that side of it, but at a certain price, it's a bridge too far. in my opinion. can't put an infinite value on 1 guy. give yourself some other options if the math isn't mathing. i'd say 5 years 205 m. i even offered to give him naming rights on the stadium

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
looks like faith is now rooting against Purdy

it's rooting for the 49ers. if you think purdy is great, then it makes sense to pay him 500m perhaps. i'm a lil more critical after 2024. if we make him the top paid guy, we may be in for a decline as a franchise. that is my thought process. on a personal level i'm happy for this man to have success. i hope we get a deal that is friendly to the 49ers. he can still get his coin and we can get a deal also. what's wrong with that?

haven't been paying attention at all.. the numbers change. like what johnny D told you..

What you sshould be worried about is future health of the team

i watched the JD vid and i saw his numbers also. i see that side of it, but at a certain price, it's a bridge too far. in my opinion. can't put an infinite value on 1 guy. give yourself some other options if the math isn't mathing. i'd say 5 years 205 m. i even offered to give him naming rights on the stadium

still not paying attention.. I said what JD directly to you (like here in this thread)

The numbers don't mean anything until the final details come out. So to stand on numbers about paying him is just a empty way of rooting against him or a bad troll attempt

Originally posted by ninerfaninnorcal:
Kaepernick and Garappolo also took us to championship games and super bowls as well.

Because of Brock's regression last year it makes sense to evaluate him this year to determine if he is franchise caliber material.

Garoppolo was dragged to the SB. Please don't be ridiculous and compare what Jimmy did in the playoffs to what Brock did, especially how we got to the SB last season and what happened in that SB.

Kap was actually a monster in the playoffs unlike Jimmy but his issues were once the team lost key players he wasn't able to overcome those losses and simply wasn't the level of player who could build on his physical tools and grow into a fully rounded player. Damn shame too cuz kid was very talented.

Btw Jimmy and Kap both got paid top QB money well short of the sample we've seen from Brock.

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:
Yes a number 1 slow as molasses. Even more impressive from Brock

not gonna put down jennings to prop up brock. i can name 10 guys ahead of brock maybe 20

You've said a lot of nonsense in this thread and others. Why stop now.

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:


it's rooting for the 49ers. if you think purdy is great, then it makes sense to pay him 500m perhaps. i'm a lil more critical after 2024. if we make him the top paid guy, we may be in for a decline as a franchise. that is my thought process. on a personal level i'm happy for this man to have success. i hope we get a deal that is friendly to the 49ers. he can still get his coin and we can get a deal also. what's wrong with that?

Gonna let you in a little secret here…

Nothing you post on this message board will influence what the 49ers will pay Brock.