QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by TheWooLick:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
i was just doing an either or. meaning it's one or the other. i'm talking about the club also. so lynch and kyle think he's as good as mahomes, in which case they are deluded. or they think he's not as good in which case they are accepting that this is the best we can do.

How do they find the GOAT?

No one is as good as Mahomes. The last two that are in the convo were drafted in the last century.

Didn't you hear QB's grow on trees now. You can pay a QB that has guided a team to the Superbowl a paltry sum of money and they will take it.

Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:

Originally posted by 49ers9797:
What would Purdy have done with that sorry group of Bills receivers in Arrowhead? Certainly not barely lose. He would get blown out.

Chiefs don't have great receivers. Yet, Mahomes uplifts them.

Brady made Edelman, Amendola good players.

You want 60 million per year? Do what the guys above do/did. Start making others around you better. You shouldn't need stud receivers and RB's.

Otherwise...he shouldn't get 60 million per year.

This front office has a history of paying elite money to good players. It needs to stop.

Just because you don't know the players names doesn't make them "sorry."

Quick someone show Jauan Jennings' numbers before Brock. Apparently he's way better than anything the Bills had.

Amari Cooper wasn't even getting a ton of playing time behind those guys…maybe they weren't as crappy as casuals want us to believe?

As I mentioned before it's not always about the top tier talent but just having consistency at the position helps QBs.

Also laughing at the idea Mahomes' receivers are bad. Hopkins, Hollywood Brown, Worthy and Kelce…poor dude. Not sure how he's doing it.

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
if kyle is getting brock and jimmy and trying to go toe to toe with mahomes we probably deserve Ls. that's the result you are gonna get. this is why i have maybe a pessimistic view. i think we've accepted it. we have given up. we aren't searching for the elite QB play. we got burned on lance, so we say this is the best we can do folks. and now we will pay richly for good play at the position. while other teams have the elite HOF type QBs.

Put your job on the line that the next QB we draft is an elite franchise QB or at least as good as Purdy on the rookie deal. You doing that?

Or do you get to make these wild statements cuz you know it means nothing to you as a fan on the couch?

Kyle and John have jobs on the line. They're not able to sit in lah lah land and just "let's go find the next Mahomes!"

How many Mahomes' walking around these days?

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:
We deserved the L because we fumbled twice and didn't know the ot rules. And our receivers aren't as good as they think they are. And our OL sucks which included Trent sucking that game. That's why we deserved the L

Can we please stop spreading this nonsense?

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by 49ers9797:
What would Purdy have done with that sorry group of Bills receivers in Arrowhead? Certainly not barely lose. He would get blown out.

Chiefs don't have great receivers. Yet, Mahomes uplifts them.

Brady made Edelman, Amendola good players.

You want 60 million per year? Do what the guys above do/did. Start making others around you better. You shouldn't need stud receivers and RB's.

Otherwise...he shouldn't get 60 million per year.

This front office has a history of paying elite money to good players. It needs to stop.

that is correct. i think you gotta land a elite FQB. that's the only type of QB to win rings here. so if you don't have 1, ok try try and try again. don't just try 1 time and quit. you can have a jeff garcia era where the QB is good and the team maybe is competitive but you'll probably watch the brady's and manning's win the rings. the 49ers used to be the gold standard for nfl QB play.

His whole post was wrong though. Our whole team got shutdown against kc and still went to ot

i think we've accepted it. we have given up. we aren't searching for the elite QB play. we got burned on lance, so we say this is the best we can do folks. and now we will pay richly for good play at the position. while other teams have the elite HOF type QBs.

lol, these fkn takes are the worse

what's wrong with that?

I see you have found your crystal ball for this take

i just observe and report reality from my corner of the internet here. in SF history, only montana and young won the rings. in NFL history, we see brady, manning and now mahomes winning. it is very rare to see some cousins type win the ring. i think most even 49er fans would say jimmy and brock are probably more on the cousins wavelength, than the mahomes wavelength. so that is our dilemma.

what you just said has nothing to do your take...

Nothing about how "we accepted it"
Nothing about how "not searching for elite play"
Nothing about how "49ers think this is the best we can do"
Nothing about how "49ers paying richly"
Nothing about how "how all teams have elite HOF QBs"

no fkn reality, just more BS that your afraid to stand on when called on it

i'll boil this down to simple statements

1. we are keeping and paying brock
2. he'll make good money
3. we won't entertain QB1 options or search for QB1 cuz point 1 above.

do you disagree with any of this? i think this is widely accepted or known stuff. only point of contention, is if you think brock is in fact, patrick mahomes or equal skill level or in that ballpark.

Where does your simple statements show that were are headed to a jeff garcia era and not being able to compete ?

again... you don't know how to back your own takes cause they are far from reality

i said we accepted it, meaning we aren't searching for mahomes or some FQB. we think brock is as good as mahomes, in which case we are deluded. or we think he's not as good, but we accept it. this is the best we can do. that's what i am saying. garcia is an example of a guy who can get you to postseason and maybe win a playoff game here or there. probably not gonna be holding up the trophy and didn't. you need montana or steve for that.

where has John or Kyle said they have accepted it or think Brock is good as mahomes or any of the crap are you saying lol

Joe needed his defense and steve needed a super team to get theirs. Brock Put us in the lead in OT, Does he need to play defense too ? lol

Originally posted by TheWooLick:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
i was just doing an either or. meaning it's one or the other. i'm talking about the club also. so lynch and kyle think he's as good as mahomes, in which case they are deluded. or they think he's not as good in which case they are accepting that this is the best we can do.

How do they find the GOAT?

No one is as good as Mahomes. The last two that are in the convo were drafted in the last century.

You just keep looking. How did we find Joe and Steve? I guess Bill had an eye for QBs.

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
if kyle is getting brock and jimmy and trying to go toe to toe with mahomes we probably deserve Ls. that's the result you are gonna get. this is why i have maybe a pessimistic view. i think we've accepted it. we have given up. we aren't searching for the elite QB play. we got burned on lance, so we say this is the best we can do folks. and now we will pay richly for good play at the position. while other teams have the elite HOF type QBs.

Put your job on the line that the next QB we draft is an elite franchise QB or at least as good as Purdy on the rookie deal. You doing that?

Or do you get to make these wild statements cuz you know it means nothing to you as a fan on the couch?

Kyle and John have jobs on the line. They're not able to sit in lah lah land and just "let's go find the next Mahomes!"

How many Mahomes' walking around these days?

that dude doesn't live in reality..

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

We deserved the L because we fumbled twice and didn't know the ot rules. And our receivers aren't as good as they think they are. And our OL sucks which included Trent sucking that game. That's why we deserved the L

Can we please stop spreading this nonsense?

I'm sure he had to have heard it at some point, but it was clearly in one ear and out the other. If he put any kind of thought into it he'd know to kick first. Our players also had no clue of what was going on

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by TheWooLick:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
i was just doing an either or. meaning it's one or the other. i'm talking about the club also. so lynch and kyle think he's as good as mahomes, in which case they are deluded. or they think he's not as good in which case they are accepting that this is the best we can do.

How do they find the GOAT?

No one is as good as Mahomes. The last two that are in the convo were drafted in the last century.

You just keep looking. How did we find Joe and Steve? I guess Bill had an eye for QBs.

Bill also didn't have a salary cap and basically kept Steve around even when he was pissed he wasn't playing.

Like I said above Kyle and John don't get to sit back and try and try again.

You listed all those "elite QBs" and outside of Mahomes only one of them has a SB ring and guess what happened?

1. he didn't have to play Mahomes but got to play a flawed Bengals team and had refs help them out to get a 3 point lead late…and get this. His defense got a stop!

2. They had a damn super team that year and still should've gotten knocked out by us had Tartt caught the damn pass that hit his chest or we managed to convert a 2nd/3rd and short or if Jimmy plays just a bit better.

As someone has said, Brock has come as close to beating Mahomes and the Chiefs more than anyone not named Burrow or Brady and it's not like the guys around him absolutely carried him either. Tons of mistakes in that game that had nothing to do with him.

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:
We deserved the L because we fumbled twice and didn't know the ot rules. And our receivers aren't as good as they think they are. And our OL sucks which included Trent sucking that game. That's why we deserved the L

Can we please stop spreading this nonsense?

I'm sure he had to have heard it at some point, but it was clearly in one ear and out the other. If he put any kind of thought into it he'd know to kick first. Our players also had no clue of what was going on

you're still missing the point. Our Defense was gassed and Burks couldn't do s**t in replacement for Greenlaw. The best option was to give the defense a rest and pray and it almost worked until Wilks said hold my beer

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:
We deserved the L because we fumbled twice and didn't know the ot rules. And our receivers aren't as good as they think they are. And our OL sucks which included Trent sucking that game. That's why we deserved the L

Can we please stop spreading this nonsense?

I'm sure he had to have heard it at some point, but it was clearly in one ear and out the other. If he put any kind of thought into it he'd know to kick first. Our players also had no clue of what was going on

Dude please stop with this nonsense. He knew the f**king rules. He simply didn't go over it a whole bunch with the team and I don't blame him.

Unlike Reid, Kyle had to worry about a lot more going into that game. From the trash practice field to how the defense was playing in the playoffs. Reid doesn't worry about the defense at all.

Kyle had a clear reason why he took the ball first and analytics wasn't against his decision either.

Also the rules being known by the players don't change anything. If anything it should've been more reason for the offense to want to score a TD.

The ot thing is another example of bad coaching imo. Just no attention to detail (unless it's his plays). I won't get into this too deep in the Brock thread. You guys know my stance on Kyle. I'm not in his thread calling for his head everyday, but I also don't run from his choking. I know what he will be known for if we can't get it done

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:
The ot thing is another example of bad coaching imo. Just no attention to detail (unless it's his plays). I won't get into this too deep in the Brock thread. You guys know my stance on Kyle. I'm not in his thread calling for his head everyday, but I also don't run from his choking. I know what he will be known for if we can't get it done

Wait until discover Andy Reids choking for 10+ years in philly......

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:
The ot thing is another example of bad coaching imo. Just no attention to detail (unless it's his plays). I won't get into this too deep in the Brock thread. You guys know my stance on Kyle. I'm not in his thread calling for his head everyday, but I also don't run from his choking. I know what he will be known for if we can't get it done

You can make the argument that he should have discussed with his team, but it doesn't actually change any goal on the field and it's also not an automatic choice to defer. That's outside of the fact that our D had just been on the field and could have used a rest.

Analytics people across the league were surveyed by multiple media outlets/personalities. It's not a one sided decision at all.

Originally posted by Crown:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

The ot thing is another example of bad coaching imo. Just no attention to detail (unless it's his plays). I won't get into this too deep in the Brock thread. You guys know my stance on Kyle. I'm not in his thread calling for his head everyday, but I also don't run from his choking. I know what he will be known for if we can't get it done

Wait until discover Andy Reids choking for 10+ years in philly......

Majority of coaches never got it done, but not even Reid came out of Philly with the choking resume of Kyle