QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by ninerfaninnorcal:
But what is now coming out is what I have been posting on here. There is still uncertainty with Brock. He still needs to evaluated. Will probably get between 30-40 million/year.

How about we wait for the deal to be made and then worry about it?

if a deal is made they believe in him plenty.

They believed in CJ, Jimmy and Trey.

Originally posted by ninerfaninnorcal:
But what is now coming out is what I have been posting on here. There is still uncertainty with Brock. He still needs to evaluated. Will probably get between 30-40 million/year.

"what is coming out now" is speculation from one writer. Taking credit for being right is ridiculous at this point.

Originally posted by 9erson3:
They believed in CJ, Jimmy and Trey.

They gave a contract to Jimmy with timing being a major factor. They moved off Trey as fast as reasonably possible and CJ was a backup.

There's a lot of relevant lessons to be learned with the Trey saga. Seems like some people didn't pick them up though.

Originally posted by 9erson3:

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by ninerfaninnorcal:

But what is now coming out is what I have been posting on here. There is still uncertainty with Brock. He still needs to evaluated. Will probably get between 30-40 million/year.

How about we wait for the deal to be made and then worry about it?

if a deal is made they believe in him plenty.

They believed in CJ, Jimmy and Trey.

Jimmy situation was different because they only had 5 games before giving him his contract. When Kyle took the ball out of Jimmys hands in the playoffs it was obvious he didn't believe in him. Trey and cj did not get extensions. Brock been with him 3 years now. This is different than all the QBs you mentioned

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:
Jimmy situation was different because they only had 5 games before giving him his contract. When Kyle took the ball out of Jimmys hands in the playoffs it was obvious he didn't believe in him. Trey and cj did not get extensions. Brock been with him 3 years now. This is different than all the QBs you mentioned

Brock's situation is certainly different, but you see a lot of parallels in the arguments here. Like a large reliance on personal evaluation of the player using public statements from the team as support, for example.

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Jimmy situation was different because they only had 5 games before giving him his contract. When Kyle took the ball out of Jimmys hands in the playoffs it was obvious he didn't believe in him. Trey and cj did not get extensions. Brock been with him 3 years now. This is different than all the QBs you mentioned

Brock's situation is certainly different, but you see a lot of parallels in the arguments here. Like a large reliance on personal evaluation of the player using public statements from the team as support, for example.

You don't have to rely on anything they say. The film backs it up. That's why Kyle is still behind him after 3 years. That's why Kyle and Warner say things about him they never did about Jimmy

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:
You don't have to rely on anything they say. The film backs it up. That's why Kyle is still behind him after 3 years. That's why Kyle and Warner say things about him they never did about Jimmy

You're doing exactly what I said, lol.

For the record, I've never said the team isn't behind him… at least for now.

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

You don't have to rely on anything they say. The film backs it up. That's why Kyle is still behind him after 3 years. That's why Kyle and Warner say things about him they never did about Jimmy

You're doing exactly what I said, lol.

For the record, I've never said the team isn't behind him… at least for now.

It's worth mentioning they aren't just giving bullcrap Trey praise. There's a clear difference

Originally posted by genus49:
How about we wait for the deal to be made and then worry about it?

if a deal is made they believe in him plenty.

Not necessarily. If you have enough elite talent around you, you don't necessarily need to believe in your QB.

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:
It's worth mentioning they aren't just giving bullcrap Trey praise. There's a clear difference

I don't think they feel the same way about the two players but the statements they've given are equally worthless, especially in the context of a discussion around the details of a contract extension.

The big difference between this situation and Trey's is there isn't a mountain of evidence outside of the team's statements about the players to form an accurate opinion or prediction on how they will move forward. I'm pretty confident they are not looking at this situation like people who have extreme opinions on Brock, good or bad.

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
5 year 205 mil with the following

20m
28m
out here with a dead cap hit of 27m
55m
50m
52m

That looks good!

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

It's worth mentioning they aren't just giving bullcrap Trey praise. There's a clear difference

I don't think they feel the same way about the two players but the statements they've given are equally worthless, especially in the context of a discussion around the details of a contract extension.

The big difference between this situation and Trey's is there isn't a mountain of evidence outside of the team's statements about the players to form an accurate opinion or prediction on how they will move forward. I'm pretty confident they are not looking at this situation like people who have extreme opinions on Brock, good or bad.

They've said a lot that really doesn't need to be said. Things I've never heard them say, so I know they don't just do it for anybody

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:
They've said a lot that really doesn't need to be said. Things I've never heard them say, so I know they don't just do it for anybody

I don't think it means anything when it comes down to the details my man.

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

They've said a lot that really doesn't need to be said. Things I've never heard them say, so I know they don't just do it for anybody

I don't think it means anything when it comes down to the details my man.

Yes the whole team believing in him means nothing lol ok my man

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:
Yes the whole team believing in him means nothing lol ok my man

The public statements mean nothing when it comes down to the details of the contract. Try to understand what I'm saying. They can believe in him and still hedge their bets, and I think they probably will as much as they can.