QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by pd24:

Originally posted by captveg:
Eh, looks like Aiyuk was looking for the pass a little early instead of running to the spot. I'd say shared disconnect there.

Yeha, on both.

But that was a messy game for Brock. Missed some easy throws he made before that season to keep the chains moving

Originally posted by pd24:
Back what up? There stats and video from that game?

It is self explanatory.

Quit trolling and find someone else to spew your BS takes on. Tell the what Kurt Warner thinks also.

Show the easy throws he missed in that game.

How is that self explanatory? You're coming in here and making those types of statements then tell me at least what down and time in the game they happened and I'll go and watch them. But it's your opinion he missed them, it's not up to me to find out which ones you think were easy throws he missed.

Nobody is trolling. I'm asking you to backup a post you made. If you can't do that then why make the post in the first place?

Didn't Kawakami say yesterday that this probably isn't getting done until May? At this point it's not worth the energy to even think about this right now.

Originally posted by pd24:
One of the weirdest Mods on Web zone of all time. Calm down, you don't need to defend and respond to everything, especially when the conversation wasn't directed at you.

I liked Phoenix, wonder if he got fed up with the negativity on here or something idk. I think the Zone has changed some over the years, less quality posts and a whole lot more whining. Idk. Genus is good for keeping the convos going, that is for sure lol

But about BCB/QB talk..qbs are so overpaid, I still can't believe what Dak was paid, I knew that was going to be a disaster..and Lawrence, he was even surprised about how much he got lol. Just for a whole lot of suck. I do love that the Cowboys caused themselves some self inflicted wounds that will bleed for some time lol

The market is what it is, BP is way better than Lawrence and ya I think better than Dak, he will get paid accordingly. Hopefully, the deal gets done quickly as reports are suggesting.

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by pd24:

Originally posted by captveg:
Eh, looks like Aiyuk was looking for the pass a little early instead of running to the spot. I'd say shared disconnect there.

Yeha, on both.

But that was a messy game for Brock. Missed some easy throws he made before that season to keep the chains moving

Originally posted by pd24:
Back what up? There stats and video from that game?

It is self explanatory.

Quit trolling and find someone else to spew your BS takes on. Tell the what Kurt Warner thinks also.

Show the easy throws he missed in that game.

How is that self explanatory? You're coming in here and making those types of statements then tell me at least what down and time in the game they happened and I'll go and watch them. But it's your opinion he missed them, it's not up to me to find out which ones you think were easy throws he missed.

Nobody is trolling. I'm asking you to backup a post you made. If you can't do that then why make the post in the first place?

There is tape of the game. The stats also tell the story.

There are examples in this very thread around some time after the game.

The fact is, since the Baltimore game the year before last until the end of last season, he has been a pretty average QB.

Originally posted by Montana:
I liked Phoenix, wonder if he got fed up with the negativity on here or something idk. I think the Zone has changed some over the years, less quality posts and a whole lot more whining. Idk. Genus is good for keeping the convos going, that is for sure lol

But about BCB/QB talk..qbs are so overpaid, I still can't believe what Dak was paid, I knew that was going to be a disaster..and Lawrence, he was even surprised about how much he got lol. Just for a whole lot of suck. I do love that the Cowboys caused themselves some self inflicted wounds that will bleed for some time lol

The market is what it is, BP is way better than Lawrence and ya I think better than Dak, he will get paid accordingly. Hopefully, the deal gets done quickly as reports are suggesting.

He will get paid. The 49ers are setting him up to kinda fail though or prove he is a really good QB because he won't have much help on offense and the defense is starting to look like it is going to be giving up some points.

I'm sure they will have some sort of out after 2 years. We won't be good until then anyways.

Let's see what Brock looks like next season. I would bet he is close to what he looked like last season.

The thing is I like Brock, but some of the fans have a crazy opinion of him. Lol

He is a good QB, he isn't an elite QB

Originally posted by pd24:
There is tape of the game. The stats also tell the story.

There are examples in this very thread around some time after the game.

The fact is, since the Baltimore game the year before last until the end of last season, he has been a pretty average QB.

I've seen the tape of the game many times unfortunately. I asked you specifically to provide the specific plays. You may actually be right and I'm not remembering it correctly but because I've rewatched that game many times I know there have been a bunch of posts(not you specifically you) that make certain statements like they are factual when they actually aren't and then people just run with it.

People keep complaining about my "warnings" when I've actually warned 3 people so far and one agrees with me. All I'm trying to do is keeping a conversation going but asking people to provide facts when they post.

We've all been guilty of making statements with hyperbole. I've been called out on it before, sometimes I prove what I'm talking about and other time I realize I was talking nonsense and own it.

And how Brock played in the 2nd half of the Lions game in the NFCCG was not average. How he played in a couple of games last year also wasn't average.

I get people being worried that he's not an Allen, Mahomes, Lamar type but our offense if executed properly doesn't need magic acts to win games. And Brock has some so called magic plays of his own and in big moments so he can sprinkle those plays in just not at the level of those guys.

Originally posted by glorydayz:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by glorydayz:

We could save a lot of $ by moving on from Purdy or just franchising him next year. What's the rush on signing him, oh there is no rush.

Extending players that have outperformed their rookie contract once they're eligible is what good orgs do

Jed and Paraag are running the show now though so who knows what they'll do. Redskins had to get rid of their owner that thought it was smart to play those games before finally seeing success

I hear you, but it looks like we are changing our strategy.

You are correct, Buckner wasn't rewarded and we never recovered from it.

It's a complete overreaction to the Aiyuk signing. I think Paraag was adamant about not paying him and he was right. Doesn't mean he's always right and it doesn't mean you close your checkbook on future players. That will just send us to the dark ages

Originally posted by glorydayz:

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by glorydayz:
We could save a lot of $ by moving on from Purdy or just franchising him next year. What's the rush on signing him, oh there is no rush.

Every team can save a lot of money by getting rid of their franchise QB but it's probably not a great idea.

Franchising him next year is not a real option unless we want another exodus of talent. I think the QB tag is projected to be like $48 million next year. This year Brock is playing for like $5 mil. A new deal allows us to move the cap hits however we want and odds are they wouldn't want to give him the big cap hits early due to some of the other big $ deals we have on the books now and would likely push it out where hopefully it's when the young guys are still under rookie deals so you have room to add more.

If you franchise him that's $48 right on the books you have to deal with. It's in the best interest of both parties to avoid that.

I think it's pretty simple - if the 49ers think Brock is their guy. You get this deal done and sooner gives you clarity and lets Brock know he's secured and can go out there and do whatever he needs to do to get ready for the season.

We have more than $48 million sitting in the dead cap space bucket, so we aren't using that $ anyway. We can build around Brock in these drafts while not being stuck with a crazy QB contract. We can also cut ties if he can't do it without a superstar cast around him. We can always sign him to a FQB deal later.

I'm not 100% on it but I'm pretty sure dead cap counts towards the cap space.

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by glorydayz:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by glorydayz:
We could save a lot of $ by moving on from Purdy or just franchising him next year. What's the rush on signing him, oh there is no rush.

Extending players that have outperformed their rookie contract once they're eligible is what good orgs do

Jed and Paraag are running the show now though so who knows what they'll do. Redskins had to get rid of their owner that thought it was smart to play those games before finally seeing success

I hear you, but it looks like we are changing our strategy.

You are correct, Buckner wasn't rewarded and we never recovered from it.

It's a complete overreaction to the Aiyuk signing. I think Paraag was adamant about not paying him and he was right. Doesn't mean he's always right and it doesn't mean you close your checkbook on future players. That will just send us to the dark ages

It seems to be a good strategy though. Pay Brock and develop a younger team through the draft.

Team needs to hit on the draft these next 2 seasons, if they do we should be really good again with the ability to add some big name players in Free Agency to make a run

Originally posted by pd24:
The thing is I like Brock, but some of the fans have a crazy opinion of him. Lol

He is a good QB, he isn't an elite QB

https://x.com/NFL/status/1899475264620404899
Even Goat Jones getting a contract.

-Daniel Jones expected to sign with Colts

Originally posted by pd24:
The thing is I like Brock, but some of the fans have a crazy opinion of him. Lol

He is a good QB, he isn't an elite QB

i'm here most of the time and i don't see anyone saying he's elite

it's pretty much the opposite

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by glorydayz:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by glorydayz:
We could save a lot of $ by moving on from Purdy or just franchising him next year. What's the rush on signing him, oh there is no rush.

Extending players that have outperformed their rookie contract once they're eligible is what good orgs do

Jed and Paraag are running the show now though so who knows what they'll do. Redskins had to get rid of their owner that thought it was smart to play those games before finally seeing success

I hear you, but it looks like we are changing our strategy.

You are correct, Buckner wasn't rewarded and we never recovered from it.

It's a complete overreaction to the Aiyuk signing. I think Paraag was adamant about not paying him and he was right. Doesn't mean he's always right and it doesn't mean you close your checkbook on future players. That will just send us to the dark ages

I understand them being frustrated by the cash spend last year and poor performance from the guys who got the big $ AND we had a terrible season.

I also think they looked at the Rams and how quickly they rebuilt or the Eagles going from the collapse they had to end 2023 to a dominant SB win this past season.

If you look at the Eagles offseason last year it wasn't exactly super heavy. Barkley was a big signing but it wasn't a huge $ move as several big name RBs were eligible for FA. Baun was a huge move for them and that was a nobody type of move. Their biggest offseason acquisition was a healthy scratch for the SB actually in Bryce Huff.

Overall we still have some really good building blocks or players at every level of our team.

QB: Purdy
RB/WR/TE: CMC, Kittle and maybe Aiyuk
OL: Trent/Puni
DL: Bosa
LB: Warner
DB: Lenoir

Find some under the radar FA signings here in the second phase of free agency and then kill this draft.

We may not be SB level team on paper but we'll see how the draft plays out and see if our coaching can work some magic.