QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by pd24:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
sounds like you weren't here for the season if you want to pretend he "broke down" and counting his attempts as being the lowest and comparing that to the other RBs

and when you want to use words like usually.. that is a clear sign of wanting things to happen

You understand what yards per attempt means? Has nothing to do with attempts.

So he didn't break down in preseason from the calf injury the season before? He tried to come back and it got worse. He even aggravated his other calf.

i do and it still doesn't help that you don't know what happened in or watched the season.

CMC over trained in a short offseason when he should have rested. He got the rest and came back cold turkey in week 9. The last game he was in, he was avg 7.6 a carry

now he's had more time to rest and fully healthy

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by pd24:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
sounds like you weren't here for the season if you want to pretend he "broke down" and counting his attempts as being the lowest and comparing that to the other RBs

and when you want to use words like usually.. that is a clear sign of wanting things to happen

You understand what yards per attempt means? Has nothing to do with attempts.

So he didn't break down in preseason from the calf injury the season before? He tried to come back and it got worse. He even aggravated his other calf.

i do and it still doesn't help that you don't know what happened in or watched the season.

CMC over trained in a short offseason when he should have rested. He got the rest and came back cold turkey in week 9. The last game he was in, he was avg 7.6 a carry

now he's had more time to rest and fully healthy

That describes breaking down for athletes.

He should be fully healthy as you say, let's see how he does and his body responds.

Originally posted by pd24:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by pd24:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
sounds like you weren't here for the season if you want to pretend he "broke down" and counting his attempts as being the lowest and comparing that to the other RBs

and when you want to use words like usually.. that is a clear sign of wanting things to happen

+ Show all quotes
You understand what yards per attempt means? Has nothing to do with attempts.

So he didn't break down in preseason from the calf injury the season before? He tried to come back and it got worse. He even aggravated his other calf.

i do and it still doesn't help that you don't know what happened in or watched the season.

CMC over trained in a short offseason when he should have rested. He got the rest and came back cold turkey in week 9. The last game he was in, he was avg 7.6 a carry

now he's had more time to rest and fully healthy

That describes breaking down for athletes.

He should be fully healthy as you say, let's see how he does and his body responds.

he responded well last year when got back.. took some games but he didn't have any issues with his tendons

I don't think Jed wants to pay him.

Originally posted by socalfan21:
I don't think Jed wants to pay him.

I wouldn't want to pay him either.

Thats a ton of cash!

Originally posted by pd24:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
sounds like you weren't here for the season if you want to pretend he "broke down" and counting his attempts as being the lowest and comparing that to the other RBs

and when you want to use words like usually.. that is a clear sign of wanting things to happen

You understand what yards per attempt means? Has nothing to do with attempts.

So he didn't break down in preseason from the calf injury the season before? He tried to come back and it got worse. He even aggravated his other calf.

I think it's fair to say there are questions around what CMC we'll get but also unfair to say he's close to the end of his career. The guy takes training incredibly serious and if anything the missed games help the whole wear and tear thing not be a thing.

I think that Buffalo game he was finally starting to get over the achilles issues that kept him out most of the year. Very unfortunate that the shoestring tackle that led to his knee injury closed out his year.

However by all accounts he's healthy right now. We'll see how he looks but I expect a matchup nightmare that he's always been. Derrick Henry put up nearly 2k yards himself at age 30. He had nearly 2200 career touches going into that season. CMC has almost 1900 career touches so far. And it's only that close cuz of the receptions CMC has. Rushing touches only Henry has almost 1k rushes more.

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by pd24:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
sounds like you weren't here for the season if you want to pretend he "broke down" and counting his attempts as being the lowest and comparing that to the other RBs

and when you want to use words like usually.. that is a clear sign of wanting things to happen

You understand what yards per attempt means? Has nothing to do with attempts.

So he didn't break down in preseason from the calf injury the season before? He tried to come back and it got worse. He even aggravated his other calf.

I think it's fair to say there are questions around what CMC we'll get but also unfair to say he's close to the end of his career. The guy takes training incredibly serious and if anything the missed games help the whole wear and tear thing not be a thing.

I think that Buffalo game he was finally starting to get over the achilles issues that kept him out most of the year. Very unfortunate that the shoestring tackle that led to his knee injury closed out his year.

However by all accounts he's healthy right now. We'll see how he looks but I expect a matchup nightmare that he's always been. Derrick Henry put up nearly 2k yards himself at age 30. He had nearly 2200 career touches going into that season. CMC has almost 1900 career touches so far. And it's only that close cuz of the receptions CMC has. Rushing touches only Henry has almost 1k rushes more.

His injury history dates back to when he was with the Panthers, and he isn't getting any younger.

Originally posted by glorydayz:

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by pd24:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
sounds like you weren't here for the season if you want to pretend he "broke down" and counting his attempts as being the lowest and comparing that to the other RBs

and when you want to use words like usually.. that is a clear sign of wanting things to happen

+ Show all quotes
You understand what yards per attempt means? Has nothing to do with attempts.

So he didn't break down in preseason from the calf injury the season before? He tried to come back and it got worse. He even aggravated his other calf.

I think it's fair to say there are questions around what CMC we'll get but also unfair to say he's close to the end of his career. The guy takes training incredibly serious and if anything the missed games help the whole wear and tear thing not be a thing.

I think that Buffalo game he was finally starting to get over the achilles issues that kept him out most of the year. Very unfortunate that the shoestring tackle that led to his knee injury closed out his year.

However by all accounts he's healthy right now. We'll see how he looks but I expect a matchup nightmare that he's always been. Derrick Henry put up nearly 2k yards himself at age 30. He had nearly 2200 career touches going into that season. CMC has almost 1900 career touches so far. And it's only that close cuz of the receptions CMC has. Rushing touches only Henry has almost 1k rushes more.

His injury history dates back to when he was with the Panthers, and he isn't getting any younger.

Not all injuries are created equal. His injuries have been kind of all over the place and per his dad the achilles issue was from overtraining.

He just has to monitor not going overboard and he should be fine. Either way injuries are a b*tch. They can happen to anyone at any point. We've been snakebit for so long but all it takes is one year of avoiding key ones and you have a chance to make a run if you have enough good players around.

Originally posted by genus49:
I think it's fair to say there are questions around what CMC we'll get but also unfair to say he's close to the end of his career. The guy takes training incredibly serious and if anything the missed games help the whole wear and tear thing not be a thing.

I think that Buffalo game he was finally starting to get over the achilles issues that kept him out most of the year. Very unfortunate that the shoestring tackle that led to his knee injury closed out his year.

However by all accounts he's healthy right now. We'll see how he looks but I expect a matchup nightmare that he's always been. Derrick Henry put up nearly 2k yards himself at age 30. He had nearly 2200 career touches going into that season. CMC has almost 1900 career touches so far. And it's only that close cuz of the receptions CMC has. Rushing touches only Henry has almost 1k rushes more.

Henry had Lamar Jackson under center with him in the backfield. Running read option with him can lead to wide open running lanes due to the threat that LMJ poses when he keeps the ball. Slightly easier to rush the ball when you have the MVP under center

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by glorydayz:

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by pd24:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
sounds like you weren't here for the season if you want to pretend he "broke down" and counting his attempts as being the lowest and comparing that to the other RBs

and when you want to use words like usually.. that is a clear sign of wanting things to happen

You understand what yards per attempt means? Has nothing to do with attempts.

So he didn't break down in preseason from the calf injury the season before? He tried to come back and it got worse. He even aggravated his other calf.

+ Show all quotes
I think it's fair to say there are questions around what CMC we'll get but also unfair to say he's close to the end of his career. The guy takes training incredibly serious and if anything the missed games help the whole wear and tear thing not be a thing.

I think that Buffalo game he was finally starting to get over the achilles issues that kept him out most of the year. Very unfortunate that the shoestring tackle that led to his knee injury closed out his year.

However by all accounts he's healthy right now. We'll see how he looks but I expect a matchup nightmare that he's always been. Derrick Henry put up nearly 2k yards himself at age 30. He had nearly 2200 career touches going into that season. CMC has almost 1900 career touches so far. And it's only that close cuz of the receptions CMC has. Rushing touches only Henry has almost 1k rushes more.

His injury history dates back to when he was with the Panthers, and he isn't getting any younger.

Not all injuries are created equal. His injuries have been kind of all over the place and per his dad the achilles issue was from overtraining.

He just has to monitor not going overboard and he should be fine. Either way injuries are a b*tch. They can happen to anyone at any point. We've been snakebit for so long but all it takes is one year of avoiding key ones and you have a chance to make a run if you have enough good players around.

He's also 29 this season...that's ancient for a RB that's constantly hurt throughout his career. His injury came after back to back seasons over 320+ touches a season(2022,2023). RB's tend to show decline after a single 300 touch season. He's a time bomb waiting to happen at this point...an overpaid one at that.

Originally posted by pd24:
The thing is I like Brock, but some of the fans have a crazy opinion of him. Lol

He is a good QB, he isn't an elite QB

Can you show me a post where people have claimed Purdy is an elite QB? Thanks.

Originally posted by jcs:

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by glorydayz:

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by pd24:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
sounds like you weren't here for the season if you want to pretend he "broke down" and counting his attempts as being the lowest and comparing that to the other RBs

and when you want to use words like usually.. that is a clear sign of wanting things to happen

You understand what yards per attempt means? Has nothing to do with attempts.

So he didn't break down in preseason from the calf injury the season before? He tried to come back and it got worse. He even aggravated his other calf.

I think it's fair to say there are questions around what CMC we'll get but also unfair to say he's close to the end of his career. The guy takes training incredibly serious and if anything the missed games help the whole wear and tear thing not be a thing.

I think that Buffalo game he was finally starting to get over the achilles issues that kept him out most of the year. Very unfortunate that the shoestring tackle that led to his knee injury closed out his year.

However by all accounts he's healthy right now. We'll see how he looks but I expect a matchup nightmare that he's always been. Derrick Henry put up nearly 2k yards himself at age 30. He had nearly 2200 career touches going into that season. CMC has almost 1900 career touches so far. And it's only that close cuz of the receptions CMC has. Rushing touches only Henry has almost 1k rushes more.

+ Show all quotes
His injury history dates back to when he was with the Panthers, and he isn't getting any younger.

Not all injuries are created equal. His injuries have been kind of all over the place and per his dad the achilles issue was from overtraining.

He just has to monitor not going overboard and he should be fine. Either way injuries are a b*tch. They can happen to anyone at any point. We've been snakebit for so long but all it takes is one year of avoiding key ones and you have a chance to make a run if you have enough good players around.

He's also 29 this season...that's ancient for a RB that's constantly hurt throughout his career. His injury came after back to back seasons over 320+ touches a season(2022,2023). RB's tend to show decline after a single 300 touch season. He's a time bomb waiting to happen at this point...an overpaid one at that.

Well he didn't get close to 300 touches last year, things are looking good

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:
Can you show me a post where people have claimed Purdy is an elite QB? Thanks.

Just scroll back to the 2023 season in this thread. You act like you just started reading this thread. There was some wild comparisons that season.

Does it really make any sense to break the bank on purdy if they're in rebuilding mode? At this point might as well sign some stop-gap journeyman.

Originally posted by D0PEMAN:
Does it really make any sense to break the bank on purdy if they're in rebuilding mode? At this point might as well sign some stop-gap journeyman.

It does, as long as there is no cap hit after year 2 or 3. It let's them see how good he is around and average to bad roster. He can come out of it great and get another contact.

They aren't spending anyways so signing him to big money isn't messing anything up except Jeds wallet