QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:

Originally posted by jcs:
Issue is more Brock went from potential star with a loaded roster to avg QB with the losses that didn't include all the stars. Burrow is an example of a guy who couldn't get his team into the playoffs but he drove that team to nearly getting there carrying one of the worst defense in the league, Brock played alongside a top 10 D statically and cost us a few games with his poor decision making.

Comments are getting crazy.

Originally posted by jcs:

Originally posted by bud49:
That's what gets me when I listen to Colin Cowterd and Nick the "Shnoz" Wright, they talk about how Brock was so bad last year without the injured players and how he can't carry a team. Well how many QB's are there that can carry their team without the other star players? To me there is none. That's me other people may think different and that's ok, but just quit acting like Brock is the only QB in the league that cannot carry his team without star players.

Issue is more Brock went from potential star with a loaded roster to avg QB with the losses that didn't include all the stars. Burrow is an example of a guy who couldn't get his team into the playoffs but he drove that team to nearly getting there carrying one of the worst defense in the league, Brock played alongside a top 10 D statically and cost us a few games with his poor decision making.

Originally posted by jcs:
Statistically we were ranked 8th in the league last season in yards both passing and running.

Originally posted by bud49:

Originally posted by Silky:

Originally posted by jcs:

Originally posted by BYisGod:
Purdy looked rough last year without talent around him and a defense that struggled. What will he look like next year with even less talent on the roster?

+ Show all quotes
This is the argument when people talk about paying him $50+ million a season.

I've always stayed positive towards players and this team over the years, but I'm not a fan of paying Purdy. I think it will be a huge mistake. We haven't had a franchise QB since Tim Rattay. I need to be damn sure he is a FQB and he's just not imo. I feel like we're still guessing

WTH? I nearly choked to death on my iced tea.

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:

Originally posted by Silky:
I've always stayed positive towards players and this team over the years, but I'm not a fan of paying Purdy. I think it will be a huge mistake. We haven't had a franchise QB since Tim Rattay. I need to be damn sure he is a FQB and he's just not imo. I feel like we're still guessing

Um, wat?

Originally posted by BYisGod:
Purdy looked rough last year without talent around him and a defense that struggled. What will he look like next year with even less talent on the roster?

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:

Originally posted by jcs:
Statistically we were ranked 8th in the league last season in yards both passing and running.

We were top 5 I believe in passing yards allowed and middle of the pack in rushing… but here's the thing: yards is one statistical category of many.

We were 29th in points allowed for example. 25th in opponent 3rd down percentage. Bottom 3rd in epa per play.

Our D was not good.

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
Not good, but not bad as well.

With rotating injured DL and 1 one legged LB, the 2024 defense isn't going to carry a offense who couldn't score in the RZ

Originally posted by TD49ers:

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:

Originally posted by Silky:
I've always stayed positive towards players and this team over the years, but I'm not a fan of paying Purdy. I think it will be a huge mistake. We haven't had a franchise QB since Tim Rattay. I need to be damn sure he is a FQB and he's just not imo. I feel like we're still guessing

Um, wat?

Maybe he meant Giovanni Carmazzi.

Originally posted by Silky:
Lol I have a friend who is an eagles fan and for some reason he remembers Tim Rattay. Our inside joke is that he was out last franchise QB. I thought you'd get it

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
Not good, but not bad as well.

With rotating injured DL and 1 one legged LB, the 2024 defense isn't going to carry a offense who couldn't score in the RZ

No, our defense was bad.

That doesn't remove the validity of your second point.

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
The defense was lights out against the Rams during their peak run.. all because of one player.. if we were truly bad we should have been blown out that game and many others

All games our defense played well and most of them they couldn't finish cause we had guys injured or out.

Originally posted by Silky:

Originally posted by TD49ers:

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:

Originally posted by Silky:
I've always stayed positive towards players and this team over the years, but I'm not a fan of paying Purdy. I think it will be a huge mistake. We haven't had a franchise QB since Tim Rattay. I need to be damn sure he is a FQB and he's just not imo. I feel like we're still guessing

+ Show all quotes
Um, wat?

Maybe he meant Giovanni Carmazzi.

Lol I have a friend who is an eagles fan and for some reason he remembers Tim Rattay. Our inside joke is that he was our last franchise QB. I thought you'd get it

Originally posted by pd24:

Originally posted by Leathaface:

Originally posted by Bay2Bay9erAllday:

Originally posted by pd24:
I wouldn't pay for a playoff performance with an elite team. Purdy averaged 1 td per postseason game. He missed like 2 TDs in the Superbowl. He isn't some great QB like a lot of you are trying to make him out to be from the season before last.

It will be fun to see the excuses for his play because it will probably be closer to last season than his great season.

+ Show all quotes
Can you remind me of the 2 TD he missed in the SB?

I can't bring myself to watch the game again

He didn't miss 2 TDs. He made one big mistake in that game and that was not throwing the slant to the hot WR (Aiyuk) on 3rd and 4 at the 2 minute warning. He locked into Jennings and due to another unblocked blitzer, he had no time.

If they convert that first down they likely run the clock out and win the SB.

I don't really put that one on him. Just no time there.



He missed that, and I think there was some other just bad throws that didn't convert 3rd downs.