QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by random49er:
Pointing out a clear paradox here that I hope you guys sort out. You don't even know the terms each party is asking for, but you've already "Predetermined" who's at fault.

I think if we're being real all of us going back and forth about the contract here is silly. Both sides seem to be amicable. The only report of money offered so far has been debunked and the guy who broke the original offer details has consistently been wrong year after year on things he tries to break.

In the end either a new deal is done and we learn that the 49ers believe Brock is their guy(regardless of how much he gets) or it's not done and we find out he's not.

Everything they've said and shown so far says they believe Brock is that guy so it's just a matter of time before they iron out a deal and when it happens I hope everyone waits for the details.

Also as far as Brock sitting, I don't see him doing that. Maybe I'm naive but I believe from what we've seen and heard from HIM, he's not going to hurt his teammates by sitting out. I don't think he's that type of person.

Originally posted by random49er:

Originally posted by TheWooLick:

LOL

Purdy is easily the best QB this team has drafted in the past 45 years and the best QB since Young.

lol....you laying it on thick. "45 years" with the "but I said drafted tho" thing is kinda a lame way to seek attention. How bout a 1-liner that is more relevant?

It is just a simple fact. This team hasn't been able to find a QB as good as Broxk since Young and hasn't drafted someone as good as Purdy in 45 years.
The team has used high draft picks on Druckenmiller, Smith and Lance. Odds are they would draft a QB of thst quality before finding another good one if they chose to move on.

Why are you making this personal by trying to tell me what my motivation is?

Originally posted by random49er:

Originally posted by NONAME:

No chance he plans on the old contract. I would be upset at ownership and not him. . . . .

Even if he is asking for $65M+ per year?

Is proposing the idea that he is asking for $65 million per year a way of seeking attention?

Originally posted by TheWooLick:

Originally posted by random49er:

Originally posted by NONAME:
No chance he plans on the old contract. I would be upset at ownership and not him. . . . .

Even if he is asking for $65M+ per year?

Is proposing the idea that he is asking for $65 million per year a way of seeking attention?

This thread has pretty much become us arguing about hypothetical cases that may never be a thing.

Hell why not discuss Brock asking for a 3 year $500 million dollar fully guaranteed contract and a 20% stake in the franchise while we're at it?

Originally posted by TheWooLick:

Originally posted by random49er:

Originally posted by NONAME:
No chance he plans on the old contract. I would be upset at ownership and not him. . . . .

Even if he is asking for $65M+ per year?

Is proposing the idea that he is asking for $65 million per year a way of seeking attention?

Let's see how long we plug away at that best "drafted" QB of 40+ years line. Maybe it will stick? Dunno yet. Good luck either way.

I think 45M will be the number.

Good arguments on both sides

I'm seeing the start of a new mentality in the Niner approach.

They won't cave like they did in the past and have the 5th year option + 2 years on the Tag.

I think it's a rebuild mentality.

Very good short article w/video - The Bills did the same thing and The Rams did the same thing and quickly got back on top.

https://www.49erswebzone.com/articles/189338-albert-reassures-panicking-offseason-exodus/

Originally posted by LasVegasWally:
I think 45M will be the number.

Good arguments on both sides

I'm seeing the start of a new mentality in the Niner approach.

They won't cave like they did in the past and have the 5th year option + 2 years on the Tag.

I think it's a rebuild mentality.

Very good short article w/video - The Bills did the same thing and The Rams did the same thing and quickly got back on top.

https://www.49erswebzone.com/articles/189338-albert-reassures-panicking-offseason-exodus/

it is what it is.. B-Rock Steady Purdy is being treated this way because he's Mr. Irrelevant.. Had he been Baby Face Lance, there will be no 45M table offer.. it'll be more and more and more..

It's very hard to believe they will sign Purdy to a huge contract. After all these cuts. It's a moderate deal by QB standards. Or no deal and play out contract. Franchise tag later on if necessary. I would be very surprised. The 49ers are unpredictable. But it doesn't fit the current offseason pattern at all.

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
It's very hard to believe they will sign Purdy to a huge contract. After all these cuts. It's a moderate deal by QB standards. Or no deal and play out contract. Franchise tag later on if necessary. I would be very surprised. The 49ers are unpredictable. But it doesn't fit the current offseason pattern at all.

How does it not? What do you think the current offseason pattern is? Cuz it looks eerily similar to what the Rams did after a big letdown season after their SB win.

They signed almost 0 big name free agents.
They traded/cut/lost a bunch of their big name guys.
Drafted a TON of players and then bounced back when most of us expected them to compete for the #1 overall pick and even had people thinking they were the most dangerous NFC team going into those playoffs.

49ers let walk guys who were overpaid and underperforming or guys who priced themselves well beyond what we were willing to pay with replacements already on the roster.

We then cut guys who weren't good at stopping the run and brought in during Sorensen/Staley tenure.

Brock per everything the team has said is the guy they're going to build around. You pay your QB if you believe in him. So IF that's the case then he's 100% in their offseason pattern.

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:

It's very hard to believe they will sign Purdy to a huge contract. After all these cuts. It's a moderate deal by QB standards. Or no deal and play out contract. Franchise tag later on if necessary. I would be very surprised. The 49ers are unpredictable. But it doesn't fit the current offseason pattern at all.

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
It's very hard to believe they will sign Purdy to a huge contract. After all these cuts. It's a moderate deal by QB standards. Or no deal and play out contract. Franchise tag later on if necessary. I would be very surprised. The 49ers are unpredictable. But it doesn't fit the current offseason pattern at all.

They will absolutely sign Purdy this year, because being able to roll this year's $5m contract into the long term deal will be so far better looking than what they'll be facing next year if they don't. At that point, he'd be a stop gap quarterback, whether they would entertain franchising him or not.

Originally posted by genus49:
This thread has pretty much become us arguing about hypothetical cases that may never be a thing.

Hell why not discuss Brock asking for a 3 year $500 million dollar fully guaranteed contract and a 20% stake in the franchise while we're at it?

Rumor is he only wants 10% stake

Realistically what would we get in trade value for Brock? Just curious. Multiple 1sts? No?

Originally posted by ScoutingBall:
Realistically what would we get in trade value for Brock? Just curious. Multiple 1sts? No?

A 2nd and change. Maybe 2 2nds. Don't think anybody is offering a 1st let alone multiple.

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:

Originally posted by ScoutingBall:
Realistically what would we get in trade value for Brock? Just curious. Multiple 1sts? No?

A 2nd and change. Maybe 2 2nds. Don't think anybody is offering a 1st let alone multiple.

We'll probably never know since the 49ers aren't going to trade him with nobody else even on the roster, let alone good enough to fill in for Brock but I think you're underselling the worth of a young proven NFL QB with playoff and SB experience even if there are limitations to his game.

Let's not forget Alex Smith was traded for two 2nd round picks. Guys like Carson Wenz, Sam Bradford even fielded 1st round picks.