QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by DRCHOWDER:

An area where I don't believe Brock Purdy gets enough credit for is how many quality throws he makes while getting drilled pic.twitter.com/ndVtrSEXxF

— Brad (@Graham_SFN) March 18, 2025

Create a custom 49ers jersey ⇨
Nice throw by Purdy under duress.......also fuken brendel!!

Lol drilled

Originally posted by jcs:
How about that Buffalo Game and the 94 yards he managed to pass for.

How about it? Allen passed for 148 yards in that game and was facing a defense without Bosa and Lenoir after the Bills had a bye week.

Did you watch the game? Brock's first game back after his shoulder injury and he's out there running a timing based offense where our guys couldn't stay on their feet. That game had a lot more to do with poor footing than Brock's arm.

Several passes dropped. Pearsall falling down on a play where Brock avoids pressure and throws a nice pass down the field that is more than likely a big time connection if Pearsall can stay on his feet. Even the TD run by Guerendo was a pass from Brock, just slightly behind the line.

I urge you to go back and watch that game and really see if Brock's arm was the reason for the poor stats(I just did)

Originally posted by genus49:
How about it? Allen passed for 148 yards in that game and was facing a defense without Bosa and Lenoir after the Bills had a bye week.

Did you watch the game? Brock's first game back after his shoulder injury and he's out there running a timing based offense where our guys couldn't stay on their feet. That game had a lot more to do with poor footing than Brock's arm.

Several passes dropped. Pearsall falling down on a play where Brock avoids pressure and throws a nice pass down the field that is more than likely a big time connection if Pearsall can stay on his feet. Even the TD run by Guerendo was a pass from Brock, just slightly behind the line.

I urge you to go back and watch that game and really see if Brock's arm was the reason for the poor stats(I just did)

Yeah I did. Kittle was open basically every play and Brock just ... Didn't throw it?

Josh Allen was a force in that game and showed why he & purdy are a galaxy apart as QBs. I don't care too much about looking at a box score, I watched the game. The biggest difference were the QBs: one can't play in bad weather, the other is an elite QB any time, anywhere.

Originally posted by genus49:
Have you ever tried not being condescending when posting here?

You're not exactly a choir boy in your posting style as well,...believe it or not? But focus on the post and the 49ers....not me.

Originally posted by frenchmov:

Originally posted by genus49:
How about it? Allen passed for 148 yards in that game and was facing a defense without Bosa and Lenoir after the Bills had a bye week.

Did you watch the game? Brock's first game back after his shoulder injury and he's out there running a timing based offense where our guys couldn't stay on their feet. That game had a lot more to do with poor footing than Brock's arm.

Several passes dropped. Pearsall falling down on a play where Brock avoids pressure and throws a nice pass down the field that is more than likely a big time connection if Pearsall can stay on his feet. Even the TD run by Guerendo was a pass from Brock, just slightly behind the line.

I urge you to go back and watch that game and really see if Brock's arm was the reason for the poor stats(I just did)

Yeah I did. Kittle was open basically every play and Brock just ... Didn't throw it?

Josh Allen was a force in that game and showed why he & purdy are a galaxy apart as QBs. I don't care too much about looking at a box score, I watched the game. The biggest difference were the QBs: one can't play in bad weather, the other is an elite QB any time, anywhere.

The other still hasn't been to a Super Bowl. I don't care too much about being elite. I watch games not just one and base a QB on that.

Originally posted by Alfienator:

Originally posted by frenchmov:

Originally posted by genus49:
How about it? Allen passed for 148 yards in that game and was facing a defense without Bosa and Lenoir after the Bills had a bye week.

Did you watch the game? Brock's first game back after his shoulder injury and he's out there running a timing based offense where our guys couldn't stay on their feet. That game had a lot more to do with poor footing than Brock's arm.

Several passes dropped. Pearsall falling down on a play where Brock avoids pressure and throws a nice pass down the field that is more than likely a big time connection if Pearsall can stay on his feet. Even the TD run by Guerendo was a pass from Brock, just slightly behind the line.

I urge you to go back and watch that game and really see if Brock's arm was the reason for the poor stats(I just did)

Yeah I did. Kittle was open basically every play and Brock just ... Didn't throw it?

Josh Allen was a force in that game and showed why he & purdy are a galaxy apart as QBs. I don't care too much about looking at a box score, I watched the game. The biggest difference were the QBs: one can't play in bad weather, the other is an elite QB any time, anywhere.

The other still hasn't been to a Super Bowl. I don't care too much about being elite. I watch games not just one and base a QB on that.

And Jimmy G has
Brock and Jimmy greater than Josh

Originally posted by 9erson3:

Originally posted by Alfienator:

Originally posted by frenchmov:

Originally posted by genus49:
How about it? Allen passed for 148 yards in that game and was facing a defense without Bosa and Lenoir after the Bills had a bye week.

Did you watch the game? Brock's first game back after his shoulder injury and he's out there running a timing based offense where our guys couldn't stay on their feet. That game had a lot more to do with poor footing than Brock's arm.

Several passes dropped. Pearsall falling down on a play where Brock avoids pressure and throws a nice pass down the field that is more than likely a big time connection if Pearsall can stay on his feet. Even the TD run by Guerendo was a pass from Brock, just slightly behind the line.

I urge you to go back and watch that game and really see if Brock's arm was the reason for the poor stats(I just did)

+ Show all quotes
Yeah I did. Kittle was open basically every play and Brock just ... Didn't throw it?

Josh Allen was a force in that game and showed why he & purdy are a galaxy apart as QBs. I don't care too much about looking at a box score, I watched the game. The biggest difference were the QBs: one can't play in bad weather, the other is an elite QB any time, anywhere.

The other still hasn't been to a Super Bowl. I don't care too much about being elite. I watch games not just one and base a QB on that.

And Jimmy G has
Brock and Jimmy greater than Josh

You can't even compare Jimmy G to Brock. Jimmy relied too much on the running game.

Originally posted by Alfienator:

Originally posted by frenchmov:

Originally posted by genus49:
How about it? Allen passed for 148 yards in that game and was facing a defense without Bosa and Lenoir after the Bills had a bye week.

Did you watch the game? Brock's first game back after his shoulder injury and he's out there running a timing based offense where our guys couldn't stay on their feet. That game had a lot more to do with poor footing than Brock's arm.

Several passes dropped. Pearsall falling down on a play where Brock avoids pressure and throws a nice pass down the field that is more than likely a big time connection if Pearsall can stay on his feet. Even the TD run by Guerendo was a pass from Brock, just slightly behind the line.

I urge you to go back and watch that game and really see if Brock's arm was the reason for the poor stats(I just did)

Yeah I did. Kittle was open basically every play and Brock just ... Didn't throw it?

Josh Allen was a force in that game and showed why he & purdy are a galaxy apart as QBs. I don't care too much about looking at a box score, I watched the game. The biggest difference were the QBs: one can't play in bad weather, the other is an elite QB any time, anywhere.

The other still hasn't been to a Super Bowl. I don't care too much about being elite. I watch games not just one and base a QB on that.

Same. It's just that I think the current back and forth has been how much money should our favorite team invest in him to the detriment of the other contracts they'll be allowed to give out for other players.

Me not caring about whether my team's QB is elite or not....is disconnected from my thoughts on how much they should pay the guy.

Originally posted by Alfienator:

Originally posted by 9erson3:

Originally posted by Alfienator:

Originally posted by frenchmov:

Originally posted by genus49:
How about it? Allen passed for 148 yards in that game and was facing a defense without Bosa and Lenoir after the Bills had a bye week.

Did you watch the game? Brock's first game back after his shoulder injury and he's out there running a timing based offense where our guys couldn't stay on their feet. That game had a lot more to do with poor footing than Brock's arm.

Several passes dropped. Pearsall falling down on a play where Brock avoids pressure and throws a nice pass down the field that is more than likely a big time connection if Pearsall can stay on his feet. Even the TD run by Guerendo was a pass from Brock, just slightly behind the line.

I urge you to go back and watch that game and really see if Brock's arm was the reason for the poor stats(I just did)

Yeah I did. Kittle was open basically every play and Brock just ... Didn't throw it?

Josh Allen was a force in that game and showed why he & purdy are a galaxy apart as QBs. I don't care too much about looking at a box score, I watched the game. The biggest difference were the QBs: one can't play in bad weather, the other is an elite QB any time, anywhere.

+ Show all quotes The other still hasn't been to a Super Bowl. I don't care too much about being elite. I watch games not just one and base a QB on that.

And Jimmy G has
Brock and Jimmy greater than Josh

You can't even compare Jimmy G to Brock. Jimmy relied too much on the running game.

You can't say one went to SB and purposely ignore Jimmy. It doesn't work that way in your sell that Brock went to a SB and Allen hasn't.

Originally posted by Alfienator:
The other still hasn't been to a Super Bowl. I don't care too much about being elite. I watch games not just one and base a QB on that.

Who cares about being to a Superbowl if you didn't win it? By your logic Trent Dilfer is better/had a better career than Dan marino

Originally posted by random49er:

Originally posted by genus49:
Have you ever tried not being condescending when posting here?

You're not exactly a choir boy in your posting style as well,...believe it or not? But focus on the post and the 49ers....not me.

Amazing what happens when you cut out 95% of my post huh?

And you making condescending POSTS is talking about your posts. Now if you care to address what I wrote in the rest of that post that you decided to delete in your quote then have at it.

Originally posted by frenchmov:

Originally posted by Alfienator:
The other still hasn't been to a Super Bowl. I don't care too much about being elite. I watch games not just one and base a QB on that.

Who cares about being to a Superbowl if you didn't win it? By your logic Trent Dilfer is better/had a better career than Dan marino

Ok, I guess I see it like that. Brock is Trent and Allen is Marino. In the end, it doesn't really matter until one of them wins the Super Bowl.

Originally posted by frenchmov:

Originally posted by genus49:
How about it? Allen passed for 148 yards in that game and was facing a defense without Bosa and Lenoir after the Bills had a bye week.

Did you watch the game? Brock's first game back after his shoulder injury and he's out there running a timing based offense where our guys couldn't stay on their feet. That game had a lot more to do with poor footing than Brock's arm.

Several passes dropped. Pearsall falling down on a play where Brock avoids pressure and throws a nice pass down the field that is more than likely a big time connection if Pearsall can stay on his feet. Even the TD run by Guerendo was a pass from Brock, just slightly behind the line.

I urge you to go back and watch that game and really see if Brock's arm was the reason for the poor stats(I just did)

Yeah I did. Kittle was open basically every play and Brock just ... Didn't throw it?

Josh Allen was a force in that game and showed why he & purdy are a galaxy apart as QBs. I don't care too much about looking at a box score, I watched the game. The biggest difference were the QBs: one can't play in bad weather, the other is an elite QB any time, anywhere.

Which plays since you watched the game.

If you watched that game then you should've also noticed the difference in pressure each QB had. As mentioned Josh was also playing our defense missing our best DLman and our best corner with the Bills coming off a bye week. If you think that's not going to give a better QB an even easier go of it then I don't know what we're doing here.

Also the post was to jcs who specifically mentioned Brock struggling in that bad weather game by bringing up the box score stuff.

Allen is one of the elite QBs in this game, he should look better in any conditions but let's keep it fair. Allen doesn't play in a timing based offense and has a cannon. In a game like we saw that week he's a much better player in a backyard game type of environment...especially when Nick Bosa and Lenoir aren't on the field.

Brock is playing in a timing based offense - when guys can't get to a spot they're supposed to be it's going to impact the passing game. And yes Brock did hold back on some throws but the reasons could very well be due to where his guys were supposed to be on the play and weren't there as well as the coverage that Brock was seeing.

Either way the narrative that Brock is horrible in bad weather games is overblown and it's certainly not because of his lack of arm strength.

Originally posted by genus49:
Which plays since you watched the game.

If you watched that game then you should've also noticed the difference in pressure each QB had. As mentioned Josh was also playing our defense missing our best DLman and our best corner with the Bills coming off a bye week. If you think that's not going to give a better QB an even easier go of it then I don't know what we're doing here.

Also the post was to jcs who specifically mentioned Brock struggling in that bad weather game by bringing up the box score stuff.

Allen is one of the elite QBs in this game, he should look better in any conditions but let's keep it fair. Allen doesn't play in a timing based offense and has a cannon. In a game like we saw that week he's a much better player in a backyard game type of environment...especially when Nick Bosa and Lenoir aren't on the field.

Brock is playing in a timing based offense - when guys can't get to a spot they're supposed to be it's going to impact the passing game. And yes Brock did hold back on some throws but the reasons could very well be due to where his guys were supposed to be on the play and weren't there as well as the coverage that Brock was seeing.

Either way the narrative that Brock is horrible in bad weather games is overblown and it's certainly not because of his lack of arm strength.

Brock isn't good in bad weather games but I wouldn't call him horrendous. I don't think it's necessarily an arm issue but a grip issue. He's had unfortunate instances of not throwing a good ball or it slipping because of his hands/grip. I know his hand size is the same as mahomes and average so I don't know if it's a strength thing or what.

Regardless, he hasn't played well in bad weather

Originally posted by frenchmov:

Originally posted by genus49:
Which plays since you watched the game.

If you watched that game then you should've also noticed the difference in pressure each QB had. As mentioned Josh was also playing our defense missing our best DLman and our best corner with the Bills coming off a bye week. If you think that's not going to give a better QB an even easier go of it then I don't know what we're doing here.

Also the post was to jcs who specifically mentioned Brock struggling in that bad weather game by bringing up the box score stuff.

Allen is one of the elite QBs in this game, he should look better in any conditions but let's keep it fair. Allen doesn't play in a timing based offense and has a cannon. In a game like we saw that week he's a much better player in a backyard game type of environment...especially when Nick Bosa and Lenoir aren't on the field.

Brock is playing in a timing based offense - when guys can't get to a spot they're supposed to be it's going to impact the passing game. And yes Brock did hold back on some throws but the reasons could very well be due to where his guys were supposed to be on the play and weren't there as well as the coverage that Brock was seeing.

Either way the narrative that Brock is horrible in bad weather games is overblown and it's certainly not because of his lack of arm strength.

Brock isn't good in bad weather games but I wouldn't call him horrendous. I don't think it's necessarily an arm issue but a grip issue. He's had unfortunate instances of not throwing a good ball or it slipping because of his hands/grip. I know his hand size is the same as mahomes and average so I don't know if it's a strength thing or what.

Regardless, he hasn't played well in bad weather

He's not at his best in bad weather that's for sure but few QBs are. Stafford was awful in that rain game until Greenlaw got hurt, Campbell refused to go in the game and we had to play with injured linebackers and had a bunch of coverage busts he took advantage of.

Elway HATED rain games.

We've seen one snow game from Brock and it was following an injury to his throwing shoulder. I'd say it's overblown at minimum. He's 2-0 in the playoffs in rain games. There's guys out there whose play dips big time simply playing outdoors.

Either way it's not something that should make or break the deal with him.