QB Brock Purdy Thread

I don't know why we have to extend a mid-tier QB that is as good as the roster when we aren't even trying to win the SB this season.

Make him play his rookie contract. If he doesn't come to practice just give McCorkle practice time with the starters. If the starters are healthy McCorkle can do 90% what Brock can do and he can do it for 3.5 millions.

WTH if Sanders is available at #11 draft him and trade Brock that same night for a 2nd rounder or two.

Again: we aren't trying to win a ring this season so I don't give a s**t who starts at QB.

Originally posted by Monsterniner:
I don't know why we have to extend a mid-tier QB that is as good as the roster when we aren't even trying to win the SB this season.

Make him play his rookie contract. If he doesn't come to practice just give McCorkle practice time with the starters. If the starters are healthy McCorkle can do 90% what Brock can do and he can do it for 3.5 millions.

WTH if Sanders is available at #11 draft him and trade Brock that same night for a 2nd rounder or two.

Again: we aren't trying to win a ring this season so I don't give a s**t who starts at QB.

lol, who says we aren't trying to win a ring? Go tell Trent or Fred or CMC or George they aren't trying to win a ring. see what happens.

Originally posted by BP13:
lol, who says we aren't trying to win a ring? Go tell Trent or Fred or CMC or George they aren't trying to win a ring. see what happens.

Do you people seriously think this team is still in Contention for a Super Bowl?

be real………

Originally posted by BP13:
lol, who says we aren't trying to win a ring? Go tell Trent or Fred or CMC or George they aren't trying to win a ring. see what happens.

The mass exodus of players and our front office having their spending taken away because they by were so careless might say so.

Of course the players want to win. But management might be trying to save money and get the cap in order as first priority.

Originally posted by Monsterniner:
I don't know why we have to extend a mid-tier QB that is as good as the roster when we aren't even trying to win the SB this season.

Make him play his rookie contract. If he doesn't come to practice just give McCorkle practice time with the starters. If the starters are healthy McCorkle can do 90% what Brock can do and he can do it for 3.5 millions.

WTH if Sanders is available at #11 draft him and trade Brock that same night for a 2nd rounder or two.

Again: we aren't trying to win a ring this season so I don't give a s**t who starts at QB.

I'm kindof down for this and I'm a huge Brock supporter for the simple fact that any QB who is getting 50 mil a year means the team is decimated around him.

Im not sure Brock is on the level of Mahomes, Allen, Lamar or Burrow where he can throw for 400 a game and take games over.

Brock is a deadly accurate QB. He will probably average 250 yards per game and 20-25 TDs. Is what worth 50 mil?

Or do we stack the roster again and have a cheap QB?

Originally posted by Monsterniner:
I don't know why we have to extend a mid-tier QB that is as good as the roster when we aren't even trying to win the SB this season.

Make him play his rookie contract. If he doesn't come to practice just give McCorkle practice time with the starters. If the starters are healthy McCorkle can do 90% what Brock can do and he can do it for 3.5 millions.

WTH if Sanders is available at #11 draft him and trade Brock that same night for a 2nd rounder or two.

Again: we aren't trying to win a ring this season so I don't give a s**t who starts at QB.

You are acting like Brock is in his mid 30's. Brock is 25 and is part of the team's future. And I don't want a statue as our starting QB. 90% of the starting QB's in this league have some kind of mobility. Heck it's probally more than 90%. And if you have no mobility you better have elite arm talent like Stafford or can process like Burrow. Mac Jones can't move and has a below average arm. And his decision making is pretty poor. Mac Jones does one thing well and that is throw with anticipation. But Brock is just as good at that and does everything else much better including using his legs.

Originally posted by maximusdecimus:

Originally posted by BP13:
lol, who says we aren't trying to win a ring? Go tell Trent or Fred or CMC or George they aren't trying to win a ring. see what happens.

Do you people seriously think this team is still in Contention for a Super Bowl?

be real………

This time last year - did you think the eagles were going to dominate to a superbowl run after their massive collapse?

did you think we were a Super Bowl contender going into 2011? Did you think we were a Super Bowl contender going into 2019? What about 2023?

im optimistic until I'm not. Just cause we lost a bunch of average joes (besides Ward and Greenlaw) doesn't mean this team is going to suck. If we are just an average special teams and average defense in the fourth (instead of the absolute worst in the league) - then we would of made the playoffs.

Originally posted by Sask49erFan:

Originally posted by BP13:
lol, who says we aren't trying to win a ring? Go tell Trent or Fred or CMC or George they aren't trying to win a ring. see what happens.

The mass exodus of players and our front office having their spending taken away because they by were so careless might say so.

Of course the players want to win. But management might be trying to save money and get the cap in order as first priority.

Lots of fans are overreacting to losing guys like Collins and Floyd. Vegas still has 49ers favored to win the West. Maybe they are good, maybe not, but to say they are not trying to win is idiotic.

Originally posted by BP13:
Lots of fans are overreacting to losing guys like Collins and Floyd. Vegas still has 49ers favored to win the West. Maybe they are good, maybe not, but to say they are not trying to win is idiotic.

Yeah, i agree. We have holes to fill and some depth to pack in and develop but as a whole, it isn't like we are a terrible team.

Last year we had terrible effort, execution, and health. Stuff that can be fixed but whatever was hurting the teams locker room needs to be gone. I'm excited to have salehs energy back for the defense and a refresh on ST. If both of those improve, we will be a good team again.

and of course staying healthy

I think ultimately the decision will be Brock's. Does he want to stay in SF for 45 million or go to the Giants for 60 million.

Originally posted by tankle104:
This time last year - did you think the eagles were going to dominate to a superbowl run after their massive collapse?

Huh? When I revisit last year's preseason rankings,....I'm consistently seeing them Top 2/Top 3 in the NFC.

Originally posted by random49er:

Originally posted by Leathaface:

Originally posted by Typecast:
Purdy has 1 year and 5.3M remaining. A 300M/5yr extension would bring his total contract to 305.3M/6yr, or a total contract AAV of 50.9M. . . . . .

Thanks for showing this. All the more reason to get it done asap and move on with the offseason program.

Lol. "Overpay like crazy now so you don't have to overpay like crazy later" . . . said no businessman ever.

The offseason program's progressing with our without a deal.

That's what you don't get. It isn't an overpay. It's the market rate for a QB1 with this resume. Whether you like that he's going to get paid that amount is a different (and irrelevant) issue. He's going to get paid what he deserves and the 49ers are going to be the ones who pay him. The chances of him playing on the 5th year are infinitesimally low and the chances of him getting traded are lower than that. The team needs to accept their fate and pay him and move on.

Yeah, they ain't tradin BP

Rumours of 60 mil....thats alot for Purdy. He isnt elite and if thinks he should get paid more than Allen and Joe Burrow, he can sit. Just because the current market trend is next QB up gets top dollar shouldnt mean the 49ers should continue the stupidity.

Originally posted by Monsterniner:
I don't know why we have to extend a mid-tier QB that is as good as the roster when we aren't even trying to win the SB this season.

Make him play his rookie contract. If he doesn't come to practice just give McCorkle practice time with the starters. If the starters are healthy McCorkle can do 90% what Brock can do and he can do it for 3.5 millions.

WTH if Sanders is available at #11 draft him and trade Brock that same night for a 2nd rounder or two.

Again: we aren't trying to win a ring this season so I don't give a s**t who starts at QB.

Yeah we kinda got that from the rest of your post.

I've watched plenty of Mac Jones to know I don't want him starting for us. Some of you may not appreciate the leadership and intangibles that QBs bring into games…somewhat ironic cuz Montana was one of the best at those things but Jones isn't it.

And unless we turn the OL up a notch for this season Mac is not going to handle the rush the way Brock does.

Also calling Brock mid tier is a joke imo unless your evaluations are strictly on arm talent and running ability, then again given how you think Mac is just as good maybe that's exactly what you're doing.

Every QB relies on talent around him. This last season was a perfect reminder of that across the board. Brock is no different.