There are 156 users in the forums

QB Brock Purdy Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online

QB Brock Purdy Thread

Mar 24, 2025 at 7:37 PM
I get negotiating, but when every time it drags out and you get a rusty player something has to change.
Mar 24, 2025 at 8:03 PM
  • jcs
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 39,050
Originally posted by genus49:
Originally posted by jcs:
Originally posted by BP13:
+ Show all quotes
The team lost that game, how did Purdy lose it? He played well enough to win, and walked off the field with the lead?
You don't get credit for getting close imo.

7 points vs 3. He had Jennings wide open on that final drive and missed him. He also did the same thing Jimmy did in the 4th...blowing a double digit lead and letting KC dig their way back.

His Super Bowl performance shouldn't earn him 50+ million a year

You're not serious with this are you?

You think having Chris Jones unblocked in his face had something to do with the missed throw to Jennings? Like did you watch the game again or just saw missed throw and decided to blame Purdy regardless of what actually happened?

Same thing as Jimmy did? Jimmy couldn't get us a first down most of that 4th quarter. Brock got us a lead EVERY time in the 4th quarter. They couldn't be more different. And Brock never even had a double digit lead in that game, let alone in the 4th quarter. We went up 10-0 in the 2nd quarter and literally the next drive KC made it a one score game. An offense can't blow a double digit lead if they're not on the field WITH the double digit lead.

Some of you guys clearly don't remember what happened and yet you post with such conviction. It's crazy.

Great 49ers gift ideas ⇨
Purdy also had Aiyuk wide open.
Take the hit and place the ball where it needs to go...he missed them both and we kicked what was the fg that sealed our fate.

Imagine if joe let the pressure get to him as he threw the "catch" to Dwight clark. Purdy is good but he's not the game changer his supposed contract demands are pressing. Over paying him will hurt the long term cap health of this team and potentially close our current championship window.
Mar 24, 2025 at 9:23 PM
Originally posted by jcs:

Purdy also had Aiyuk wide open.
Take the hit and place the ball where it needs to go...he missed them both and we kicked what was the fg that sealed our fate.

Imagine if joe let the pressure get to him as he threw the "catch" to Dwight clark. Purdy is good but he's not the game changer his supposed contract demands are pressing. Over paying him will hurt the long term cap health of this team and potentially close our current championship window
Posting the video doesnt help your argument. He doesnt even get to his back foot cleanly before Chris Jones gets there. The only thing this shows is how important it is for all 11 players to do tgeir job in order to have success. 8f that is your argument then no QB should account for over 20% of the salary cap. Otherwise, the argument that Brock is at fault on that play or any other QB could have avoided an All Pro unblocked is ridiculous.

It's okay to admit that Brock Purdy is good. It's also okay to admit that he has shown things that are great. He will get paid and good for him.
Mar 24, 2025 at 10:19 PM

Our True QB1 already working on his craft during the off season, unlike our QB2 who is just thinking about money $$....... makes me sick
Mar 24, 2025 at 11:54 PM
Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
Originally posted by tankle104:
Hmm sorta but not really. I hate these long drawn out situations as much as everyone. I really hope Brocks is done before the draft.

Bosa had ALL the leverage. They had to pay him a record deal and he held out for great structure. They caved on him but I don't think they really had much of a choice (if they wanted to keep him). The other option was to trade him. They also had no one to replace him. They didn't have any DE that could come close to him, especially when the team was hoping for a Super Bowl.

Trent - Trent had all the leverage too. The teams o line is complete ass outside of him. They didn't even have a respectable option to replace him if he continued to hold out or get traded. Guys like Trent and Bosa had all the negotiation leverage (if you're looking at it from the context of keeping both top tier players).

Aiyuk - Aiyuk is coming off a third consecutive really good and healthy season, all pro. He was a great fit for what we do. We didn't really overpay him, we just paid what he had shown to be worth - Aiyuk is the one who decided to hold out in hopes for more and didn't get anything. He held out for 5-6 weeks for literally no reason and came into the season as ass.

teams don't usually win when you're dealing with players who are the best at what they do, or one of the best. The other option is to just trade them. Which we actually were willing to do but Aiyuk said he wouldnt sign extensions there.

trent we should have hung up the phone on and told him report or don't

BA we should have dealt to steelers when he acted stupid.

bosa you get him done but in time for TC. if he doesn't sign by TC he can play on what he's got.

I mean that's easier said than done. Trent is at a point in his life where he's filthy rich and accomplished. We were tryin to run it back for a chip and not having arguably thr best tackle in football isn't good. Especially with what our backup options were.

we couldn't deal BA to the Steelers cause they weren't making good offers, unless we were cutting loss.

We didn't know we would have an injury riddled season, players get shot, and just play terrible all year.

don't get me wrong - I hate that all this happened and In hindsight, it sucked. I'm just saying that the front office was trying to win a chip and forked up for it - it hasn't worked out. I don't really fault them for that. Our salary cap situation is actually solid. We aren't in "trouble". We are just recalibrating it.
Mar 24, 2025 at 11:56 PM
Originally posted by DRCHOWDER:

Our True QB1 already working on his craft during the off season, unlike our QB2 who is just thinking about money $$....... makes me sick

I think Mac would do well here - JG style. I don't want him in but I think it's a great match for him and our 2nd option. Dude is built to play in Kyle's offense. He's just been ruined by terrible coaching/org.

BBs staffing decisions with him was so odd.
Mar 24, 2025 at 11:59 PM
Originally posted by tankle104:
Originally posted by DRCHOWDER:

Our True QB1 already working on his craft during the off season, unlike our QB2 who is just thinking about money $$....... makes me sick

I think Mac would do well here - JG style. I don't want him in but I think it's a great match for him and our 2nd option. Dude is built to play in Kyle's offense. He's just been ruined by terrible coaching/org.

BBs staffing decisions with him was so odd.

Jokes aside lol, I agree and think he'll do well as the back up and hopefully finish games in the 4th quarter when we blow out teams.
Mar 25, 2025 at 12:06 AM
Originally posted by DRCHOWDER:

Our True QB1 already working on his craft during the off season, unlike our QB2 who is just thinking about money $$....... makes me sick

What? Lol
Mar 25, 2025 at 1:09 AM
Originally posted by Montana:
Originally posted by DRCHOWDER:

Our True QB1 already working on his craft during the off season, unlike our QB2 who is just thinking about money $$....... makes me sick

What? Lol

Its been a slow news day.
Mar 25, 2025 at 1:14 AM

Two Gods amongst men debating our future, this should be epic!
Mar 25, 2025 at 1:54 AM
Originally posted by jcs:

Purdy also had Aiyuk wide open.
Take the hit and place the ball where it needs to go...he missed them both and we kicked what was the fg that sealed our fate.

Imagine if joe let the pressure get to him as he threw the "catch" to Dwight clark. Purdy is good but he's not the game changer his supposed contract demands are pressing. Over paying him will hurt the long term cap health of this team and potentially close our current championship window.

Lol

First off the best dt in the nfl didn't come through unblocked on the catch. In fact, nobody came through unblocked on that play

Another difference is FG was an option (even though it shouldn't have been, but that's on Kyle) whereas Joe had to throw it up due to score. Brock threw it away because he couldn't see the cb and wanted to preserve the points. Ridiculous spot to be in when we won the coin toss

Also Sprint right option put Joe on the move immediately at the snap and gave him time. Kyle called another stupid straight dropback off play action. Montana woulda been screwed too in that spot

Watch Hardmans game winning TD to see how a great play caller makes it easy for his qb
[ Edited by CharlieSheen on Mar 25, 2025 at 2:02 AM ]
Mar 25, 2025 at 4:25 AM
Originally posted by DRCHOWDER:
Its been a slow news day.

Chowder keeping it spicy
Mar 25, 2025 at 5:45 AM
His deal done yet?!
Mar 25, 2025 at 6:09 AM
Originally posted by frenchmov:
Originally posted by genus49:
You're not serious with this are you?

You think having Chris Jones unblocked in his face had something to do with the missed throw to Jennings? Like did you watch the game again or just saw missed throw and decided to blame Purdy regardless of what actually happened?

Same thing as Jimmy did? Jimmy couldn't get us a first down most of that 4th quarter. Brock got us a lead EVERY time in the 4th quarter. They couldn't be more different. And Brock never even had a double digit lead in that game, let alone in the 4th quarter. We went up 10-0 in the 2nd quarter and literally the next drive KC made it a one score game. An offense can't blow a double digit lead if they're not on the field WITH the double digit lead.

Some of you guys clearly don't remember what happened and yet you post with such conviction. It's crazy.

I expect someone making $55m a year to make that throw.

I expect an average or below to make the excuse that he was pressured

Like Josh Allen did when KC got to him?

Like Jalen Hurts did the one time KC got to him?

I don't even know what you're trying to say with the second sentence but I'm sure it's based on nothing but Madden.
Mar 25, 2025 at 6:15 AM
Originally posted by frenchmov:
I expect someone making $55m a year to make that throw.

I expect an average or below to make the excuse that he was pressured


Originally posted by jcs:

Purdy also had Aiyuk wide open.
Take the hit and place the ball where it needs to go...he missed them both and we kicked what was the fg that sealed our fate.

Imagine if joe let the pressure get to him as he threw the "catch" to Dwight clark. Purdy is good but he's not the game changer his supposed contract demands are pressing. Over paying him will hurt the long term cap health of this team and potentially close our current championship window.

Thanks for saving me the trouble and posting the video...I love that somehow you think that helps your point.

"A throw a $55 million dollar QB makes"
"Take the hit and place the ball where it needs to go"



Guess what...a play is designed a certain way. Jennings wasn't open there. If Burford had done his job it gives Brock enough time to make the throw and JJ enough time to get open.

This isn't a "get hit and make the throw" situation. It's a timing based route and Jennings isn't open enough here to take the hit and make the throw since there are two defenders sitting right there.

Anyone putting that on Purdy isn't living in reality.
Theme: Auto • Light • Dark
Search
YouTube
Flipboard
Bluesky
Threads
✕
Search Share 49ersWebzone