QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by jcs:

Patrick Mahomes will get the headlines.

But Chris Jones:

1) Game saving pressure vs Josh Allen and the Bills

2) Should have had a safety vs the Ravens on a no-call

3) Saved Brock Purdy OT TD to Jennings (unblocked)

Super Bowl hero vs 49ers pic.twitter.com/1X0ugCSMbg

— Carter B 🕺🏽 (@CarterthePower) February 12, 2024

Great 49ers gift ideas ⇨
Purdy also had Aiyuk wide open.
Take the hit and place the ball where it needs to go...he missed them both and we kicked what was the fg that sealed our fate.

Imagine if joe let the pressure get to him as he threw the "catch" to Dwight clark. Purdy is good but he's not the game changer his supposed contract demands are pressing. Over paying him will hurt the long term cap health of this team and potentially close our current championship window.

Lol

First off the best dt in the nfl didn't come through unblocked on the catch. In fact, nobody came through unblocked on that play

Another difference is FG was an option (even though it shouldn't have been, but that's on Kyle) whereas Joe had to throw it up due to score. Brock threw it away because he couldn't see the cb and wanted to preserve the points. Ridiculous spot to be in when we won the coin toss

Also Sprint right option put Joe on the move immediately at the snap and gave him time. Kyle called another stupid straight dropback off play action. Montana woulda been screwed too in that spot

Watch Hardmans game winning TD to see how a great play caller makes it easy for his qb

Thing was Brock didn't even throw it away. He threw it to a spot where either JJ or nobody could get it. The only issue on that play was Burford not even attempting to block Jones. He could've been beaten cleanly but just getting in his way would've given that route time to open and Brock to get Jennings the ball.

As far as the playcall it was perfectly fine. It was a run fake, which is why Burford not blocking Jones gave him even less time to try to salvage the play, maybe if there was no run fake he could've seen the bust and gotten out of the pocket himself but just a bad time to "go with your gut" for Burford.

Originally posted by genus49:

Thing was Brock didn't even throw it away. He threw it to a spot where either JJ or nobody could get it. The only issue on that play was Burford not even attempting to block Jones. He could've been beaten cleanly but just getting in his way would've given that route time to open and Brock to get Jennings the ball.

As far as the playcall it was perfectly fine. It was a run fake, which is why Burford not blocking Jones gave him even less time to try to salvage the play, maybe if there was no run fake he could've seen the bust and gotten out of the pocket himself but just a bad time to "go with your gut" for Burford.

Pretty sure that's a throw away. There was an interview after the sb where Brock said he couldn't see the cb so he just wanted to be safe with it and get the points

I don't know why everyone is obsessing over the 3rd and 4 in OT. That's not the play that keeps me up at night. Unless we get 8 there (which we apparently weren't going for anyway) it doesn't really matter anyway because the defense couldn't stop a single drive anymore.

The play that keeps me up is the 3rd and 5 at the 2-minute warning. Barring a complete Moody meltdown, we win if we convert that one.

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by genus49:
Thing was Brock didn't even throw it away. He threw it to a spot where either JJ or nobody could get it. The only issue on that play was Burford not even attempting to block Jones. He could've been beaten cleanly but just getting in his way would've given that route time to open and Brock to get Jennings the ball.

As far as the playcall it was perfectly fine. It was a run fake, which is why Burford not blocking Jones gave him even less time to try to salvage the play, maybe if there was no run fake he could've seen the bust and gotten out of the pocket himself but just a bad time to "go with your gut" for Burford.

Pretty sure that's a throw away. There was an interview after the sb where Brock said he couldn't see the cb so he just wanted to be safe with it and get the points

It's a throw away in a sense of "it's out to a spot where either my guy gets it or nobody does" which is 100% the right decision in that moment.

Had he tried to throw it to JJ when Jones was right on him it likely gets picked and we know how that would've gone over. People acting like it was a throw top tier QBs make clearly ignored the top guys failing in the same situation.

Originally posted by Fanaticofnfl:
I don't know why everyone is obsessing over the 3rd and 4 in OT. That's not the play that keeps me up at night. Unless we get 8 there (which we apparently weren't going for anyway) it doesn't really matter anyway because the defense couldn't stop a single drive anymore.

The play that keeps me up is the 3rd and 5 at the 2-minute warning. Barring a complete Moody meltdown, we win if we convert that one.

I agree that's a play that Brock had to make and I believe if he wasn't a 2nd year player he makes it. Spags has gotten many a great QB with more experience on those situations so it's hard to bash Brock too much BUT the throw should've gone to Aiyuk and like you said, it's pretty much a run 3 times and kick the game winner situation.

However it didn't happen so looking at that OT play is also pretty important. We don't know what happens if we score the TD, maybe Wilks calls things differently and protecting a 7 point lead vs 3 point lead produces a different outcome in OT.

Just goes to show you how many things went wrong for us in that game and any one of them going the other way could've given us the win.

Originally posted by Fanaticofnfl:
I don't know why everyone is obsessing over the 3rd and 4 in OT. That's not the play that keeps me up at night. Unless we get 8 there (which we apparently weren't going for anyway) it doesn't really matter anyway because the defense couldn't stop a single drive anymore.

The play that keeps me up is the 3rd and 5 at the 2-minute warning. Barring a complete Moody meltdown, we win if we convert that one.

The play(s) or sequence that keeps me up at night was....forgot his name...when Brown? intercepted Mahomes when we were up 10 I think. Then not getting a first down near midfield. My heart sank in that moment. And the muffed punt. And greenlaw injury is a close third. May be first with how impactful he was. Those hurt me more than anything in OT

Originally posted by Silky:

Originally posted by Fanaticofnfl:
I don't know why everyone is obsessing over the 3rd and 4 in OT. That's not the play that keeps me up at night. Unless we get 8 there (which we apparently weren't going for anyway) it doesn't really matter anyway because the defense couldn't stop a single drive anymore.

The play that keeps me up is the 3rd and 5 at the 2-minute warning. Barring a complete Moody meltdown, we win if we convert that one.

The play(s) or sequence that keeps me up at night was....forgot his name...when Brown? intercepted Mahomes when we were up 10 I think. Then not getting a first down near midfield. My heart sank in that moment. And the muffed punt. And greenlaw injury is a close third. May be first with how impactful he was. Those hurt me more than anything in OT

I'm not going to tell you what to think but to me the muffed punt is 100% the most critical play in the game.

First of all there were 2 mistakes on the play that if neither one happens we maintain possession and that likely guarantees the game.

If the ball doesn't hit Luter's leg. If McCloud just falls on it vs trying to "make a play"

10-6 lead we'd get the ball at our 16 with 2:30 left in the 3rd quarter and KC still struggling to find any rhythm on offense and not sniffing the endzone. That play completely changed the momentum of that game and gave KC life.

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by Silky:

Originally posted by Fanaticofnfl:
I don't know why everyone is obsessing over the 3rd and 4 in OT. That's not the play that keeps me up at night. Unless we get 8 there (which we apparently weren't going for anyway) it doesn't really matter anyway because the defense couldn't stop a single drive anymore.

The play that keeps me up is the 3rd and 5 at the 2-minute warning. Barring a complete Moody meltdown, we win if we convert that one.

The play(s) or sequence that keeps me up at night was....forgot his name...when Brown? intercepted Mahomes when we were up 10 I think. Then not getting a first down near midfield. My heart sank in that moment. And the muffed punt. And greenlaw injury is a close third. May be first with how impactful he was. Those hurt me more than anything in OT

I'm not going to tell you what to think but to me the muffed punt is 100% the most critical play in the game.

First of all there were 2 mistakes on the play that if neither one happens we maintain possession and that likely guarantees the game.

If the ball doesn't hit Luter's leg. If McCloud just falls on it vs trying to "make a play"

10-6 lead we'd get the ball at our 16 with 2:30 left in the 3rd quarter and KC still struggling to find any rhythm on offense and not sniffing the endzone. That play completely changed the momentum of that game and gave KC life.

Stop telling me what to think

Originally posted by Silky:

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by Silky:

Originally posted by Fanaticofnfl:
I don't know why everyone is obsessing over the 3rd and 4 in OT. That's not the play that keeps me up at night. Unless we get 8 there (which we apparently weren't going for anyway) it doesn't really matter anyway because the defense couldn't stop a single drive anymore.

The play that keeps me up is the 3rd and 5 at the 2-minute warning. Barring a complete Moody meltdown, we win if we convert that one.

+ Show all quotes
The play(s) or sequence that keeps me up at night was....forgot his name...when Brown? intercepted Mahomes when we were up 10 I think. Then not getting a first down near midfield. My heart sank in that moment. And the muffed punt. And greenlaw injury is a close third. May be first with how impactful he was. Those hurt me more than anything in OT

I'm not going to tell you what to think but to me the muffed punt is 100% the most critical play in the game.

First of all there were 2 mistakes on the play that if neither one happens we maintain possession and that likely guarantees the game.

If the ball doesn't hit Luter's leg. If McCloud just falls on it vs trying to "make a play"

10-6 lead we'd get the ball at our 16 with 2:30 left in the 3rd quarter and KC still struggling to find any rhythm on offense and not sniffing the endzone. That play completely changed the momentum of that game and gave KC life.

Stop telling me what to think

Won't tell you what to think but I will tell you to read.

Dang Purdy should have ran out there as a LB after Greenlaw went down in the SB! How dare he lose the lead like that!

Many of y'all are silly.

Originally posted by OKC49erFan:
Dang Purdy should have ran out there as a LB after Greenlaw went down in the SB! How dare he lose the lead like that!

Many of y'all are silly.

Yep, I have never seen a QB in the NFL ever miss a wide open WR with a D linemen running free right at him. Terrible it's never happened until the Superbowl and only to Brock Purdy. wow

Originally posted by bud49:
Yep, I have never seen a QB in the NFL ever miss a wide open WR with a D linemen running free right at him. Terrible it's never happened until the Superbowl and only to Brock Purdy. wow

Yea, Brock shouldn't be crushed for missing that play as a second year starter. Especially when he was one of our best offensive players in the game. I thought he had a decent, certainly not his best, game. Not comparable to Himmy's performance in the first SB which was abysmal late.

Originally posted by bud49:
Yep, I have never seen a QB in the NFL ever miss a wide open WR with a D linemen running free right at him. Terrible it's never happened until the Superbowl and only to Brock Purdy. wow

This is what a good deal of QBs would do: not make the play. So purdy isn't unique in that regard. But also the reason I don't want to pay him $55m/yr. That should be reserved for guys who make that throw and don't need the "my protection wasn't perfect!!!" excuse

When Kyle elected to receive, I knew we were toast. And you better be sure to get a TD if you are gunna do that against KC. We needed to go for it on 4th down. Settling for a field goal was just bad. Yes, I know the D was gassed, no Greenlaw, yes, CMC had the dumbest ass fumble- cause in the biggest moment of his life- decides not to protect the ball. How lame was that? I mean, really lol. But yeah, that play was frustrating, it looks so bad, that it almost looks like we purposely lost lol. BA was wide open. The whole game just was a lot of suck.
I bet Kyle wins one on another team cause it ain't happening here I don't think..who knows but doesn't look promising.

Originally posted by Montana:
When Kyle elected to receive, I knew we were toast. And you better be sure to get a TD if you are gunna do that against KC. We needed to go for it on 4th down. Settling for a field goal was just bad. Yes, I know the D was gassed, no Greenlaw, yes, CMC had the dumbest ass fumble- cause in the biggest moment of his life- decides not to protect the ball. How lame was that? I mean, really lol. But yeah, that play was frustrating, it looks so bad, that it almost looks like we purposely lost lol. BA was wide open. The whole game just was a lot of suck.
I bet Kyle wins one on another team cause it ain't happening here I don't think..who knows but doesn't look promising.