QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by Montana:
When Kyle elected to receive, I knew we were toast. And you better be sure to get a TD if you are gunna do that against KC. We needed to go for it on 4th down. Settling for a field goal was just bad. Yes, I know the D was gassed, no Greenlaw, yes, CMC had the dumbest ass fumble- cause in the biggest moment of his life- decides not to protect the ball. How lame was that? I mean, really lol. But yeah, that play was frustrating, it looks so bad, that it almost looks like we purposely lost lol. BA was wide open. The whole game just was a lot of suck.
I bet Kyle wins one on another team cause it ain't happening here I don't think..who knows but doesn't look promising.

why would he win with another team but not here in SF? Brock Purdy?

Originally posted by boast:

Originally posted by Montana:
When Kyle elected to receive, I knew we were toast. And you better be sure to get a TD if you are gunna do that against KC. We needed to go for it on 4th down. Settling for a field goal was just bad. Yes, I know the D was gassed, no Greenlaw, yes, CMC had the dumbest ass fumble- cause in the biggest moment of his life- decides not to protect the ball. How lame was that? I mean, really lol. But yeah, that play was frustrating, it looks so bad, that it almost looks like we purposely lost lol. BA was wide open. The whole game just was a lot of suck.
I bet Kyle wins one on another team cause it ain't happening here I don't think..who knows but doesn't look promising.

why would he win with another team but not here in SF? Brock Purdy?

the prophecy of St Andy

Originally posted by frenchmov:
This is what a good deal of QBs would do: not make the play. So purdy isn't unique in that regard. But also the reason I don't want to pay him $55m/yr. That should be reserved for guys who make that throw and don't need the "my protection wasn't perfect!!!" excuse

Which QB makes that throw?

Would love to know which QB has the ability to teleport his receiver.

Originally posted by Montana:
When Kyle elected to receive, I knew we were toast. And you better be sure to get a TD if you are gunna do that against KC. We needed to go for it on 4th down. Settling for a field goal was just bad. Yes, I know the D was gassed, no Greenlaw, yes, CMC had the dumbest ass fumble- cause in the biggest moment of his life- decides not to protect the ball. How lame was that? I mean, really lol. But yeah, that play was frustrating, it looks so bad, that it almost looks like we purposely lost lol. BA was wide open. The whole game just was a lot of suck.
I bet Kyle wins one on another team cause it ain't happening here I don't think..who knows but doesn't look promising.

Deja vu

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by Fanaticofnfl:
I don't know why everyone is obsessing over the 3rd and 4 in OT. That's not the play that keeps me up at night. Unless we get 8 there (which we apparently weren't going for anyway) it doesn't really matter anyway because the defense couldn't stop a single drive anymore.

The play that keeps me up is the 3rd and 5 at the 2-minute warning. Barring a complete Moody meltdown, we win if we convert that one.

I agree that's a play that Brock had to make and I believe if he wasn't a 2nd year player he makes it.

Hmmmm. In what areas do you think Brock Purdy improved at in year 3?

Originally posted by random49er:

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by Fanaticofnfl:
I don't know why everyone is obsessing over the 3rd and 4 in OT. That's not the play that keeps me up at night. Unless we get 8 there (which we apparently weren't going for anyway) it doesn't really matter anyway because the defense couldn't stop a single drive anymore.

The play that keeps me up is the 3rd and 5 at the 2-minute warning. Barring a complete Moody meltdown, we win if we convert that one.

I agree that's a play that Brock had to make and I believe if he wasn't a 2nd year player he makes it.

Hmmmm. In what areas do you think Brock Purdy improved at in year 3?

Hmmm. QBs learn with more experience. The more you see certain play, blitzes the more you're able to answer them in similar situations in the future.

The point was pretty clear if you're not choosing to find your own thing to take issue with.

A more experienced version of Brock on THAT play would've been able to make the proper read/throw on that play. When talking about Stafford being better than Brock his experience gives him a leg up a lot more than his arm does these days.

Stop chopping up quotes when responding to people and it will help you respond to the actual post.

Originally posted by genus49:
Stop chopping up quotes when responding to people and it will help you respond to the actual post.

There's no need to (i'm not chopping up quotes,...I'm quoting what I want to respond to).

The board has enough clutter and I'm clearly not altering anything being said. You commented on something, ...I asked a question,... and you responded (though you didn't cite anything you believed he improved on in year 3, although you pretty much guaranteed year 3 improvements from Purdy in a previous post ?! I'm as confused as you). Simple enough.

But if you're ever truly certain that year 3 Purdy improved in any facets of the game that we can perhaps find on tape, please let us know.

Constantly demanding that 10 extra paragraphs be re-posted again and again when someone wants to address a certain comment is a little absurd. Either your sentence(s) were word-for-word quoted, or you weren't and the quote is fake. But shortened quotes that gets responded to happens everywhere in anything related to journalism. Here is me including a snippet of the main writer on this site doing exactly the same to the person he's quoting:


The site does so virtually every day.
#Standard Protocol

If the web designers in charge of the site want a bunch of needless mile-long pages with full quotes,...they are free to disable, but they are in charge of that kinda stuff, so I wouldn't bet on it.

Originally posted by genus49:
Which QB makes that throw?

Would love to know which QB has the ability to teleport his receiver.

What? He threw to Jennings who was open, the ball was inaccurate/uncatchable (to speak nothing of aiyuk wide open). What do you mean teleport his receiver lol

Originally posted by frenchmov:

Originally posted by genus49:
Which QB makes that throw?

Would love to know which QB has the ability to teleport his receiver.

What? He threw to Jennings who was open, the ball was inaccurate/uncatchable (to speak nothing of aiyuk wide open). What do you mean teleport his receiver lol

Why don't we focus on the real problem on that play… our guard didn't even attempt to block the best DT in ALL OF FOOTBALL (top 2 at worst). He was wide open to immediately pressure Brock. Dude barely got to take a step before having to get rid of the ball.

if it wasn't for our RG being horrendous - we would of scored. No doubt. Issue wasn't anything except the RG. Huge bonehead mistake that drastically dropped our chances to win it.

The team made a ton of mistakes that game. Tons. Especially the third quarter. We had a million chances to pull away and s**t the bed Everytime. Lots of blame to go around but that play… that's on Burford. All day. Every day.

Originally posted by tankle104:
Why don't we focus on the real problem on that play… our guard didn't even attempt to block the best DT in ALL OF FOOTBALL (top 2 at worst). He was wide open to immediately pressure Brock. Dude barely got to take a step before having to get rid of the ball.

if it wasn't for our RG being horrendous - we would of scored. No doubt. Issue wasn't anything except the RG. Huge bonehead mistake that drastically dropped our chances to win it.

The team made a ton of mistakes that game. Tons. Especially the third quarter. We had a million chances to pull away and s**t the bed Everytime. Lots of blame to go around but that play… that's on Burford. All day. Every day.

Yeah, f Burford man, so many things went wrong in that game..s**tshow. Kyle probably should have invested more in the OL, like fans had been saying forever, but..nope.

Originally posted by boast:
why would he win with another team but not here in SF? Brock Purdy?

Na, Kyle won't be here forever, time is ticking, maybe he will learn not s**t the bed in the SB maybe by the time he is 60 and on another team lol

Originally posted by Montana:

Originally posted by tankle104:

Why don't we focus on the real problem on that play… our guard didn't even attempt to block the best DT in ALL OF FOOTBALL (top 2 at worst). He was wide open to immediately pressure Brock. Dude barely got to take a step before having to get rid of the ball.

if it wasn't for our RG being horrendous - we would of scored. No doubt. Issue wasn't anything except the RG. Huge bonehead mistake that drastically dropped our chances to win it.

The team made a ton of mistakes that game. Tons. Especially the third quarter. We had a million chances to pull away and s**t the bed Everytime. Lots of blame to go around but that play… that's on Burford. All day. Every day.

Yeah, f Burford man, so many things went wrong in that game..s**tshow. Kyle probably should have invested more in the OL, like fans had been saying forever, but..nope.

Originally posted by boast:

why would he win with another team but not here in SF? Brock Purdy?

Na, Kyle won't be here forever, time is ticking, maybe he will learn not s**t the bed in the SB maybe by the time he is 60 and on another team lol

Originally posted by random49er:
There's no need to (i'm not chopping up quotes,...I'm quoting what I want to respond to).

The board has enough clutter and I'm clearly not altering anything being said. You commented on something, ...I asked a question,... and you responded (though you didn't cite anything you believed he improved on in year 3, although you pretty much guaranteed year 3 improvements from Purdy in a previous post ?! I'm as confused as you). Simple enough.

But if you're ever truly certain that year 3 Purdy improved in any facets of the game that we can perhaps find on tape, please let us know.

Constantly demanding that 10 extra paragraphs be re-posted again and again when someone wants to address a certain comment is a little absurd. Either your sentence(s) were word-for-word quoted, or you weren't and the quote is fake. But shortened quotes that gets responded to happens everywhere in anything related to journalism. Here is me including a snippet of the main writer on this site doing exactly the same to the person he's quoting:


The site does so virtually every day.
#Standard Protocol

If the web designers in charge of the site want a bunch of needless mile-long pages with full quotes,...they are free to disable, but they are in charge of that kinda stuff, so I wouldn't bet on it.

Considering you love to remove information from the post you're quoting which explains why your point isn't valid or misunderstood by you then I'd say chopping up the quote is a problem. Let me worry about the clutter on the board. You don't have to quote the whole thread and bold what you want to respond to. That's how most people do it here and we avoid confusion and this way you don't forget what else was actually said...

And if you included the rest of my post I clearly mentioned experience being a factor so your question of what did he improve on in his 3rd season - with a totally different set of players around him has 0 to do with my original point.

You're not a journalist. We're having a conversation on a forum and you enjoy taking a snipit of a whole point and turning it into something it wasn't.

Originally posted by frenchmov:

Originally posted by genus49:
Which QB makes that throw?

Would love to know which QB has the ability to teleport his receiver.

What? He threw to Jennings who was open, the ball was inaccurate/uncatchable (to speak nothing of aiyuk wide open). What do you mean teleport his receiver lol

Show me open Jennings....

Man I would have loved a BP to Kittle ftw

Originally posted by tankle104:
Why don't we focus on the real problem on that play… our guard didn't even attempt to block the best DT in ALL OF FOOTBALL (top 2 at worst). He was wide open to immediately pressure Brock. Dude barely got to take a step before having to get rid of the ball.

if it wasn't for our RG being horrendous - we would of scored. No doubt. Issue wasn't anything except the RG. Huge bonehead mistake that drastically dropped our chances to win it.

The team made a ton of mistakes that game. Tons. Especially the third quarter. We had a million chances to pull away and s**t the bed Everytime. Lots of blame to go around but that play… that's on Burford. All day. Every day.

Yes, Burford blew that protection no doubt but there were a dozen other critical mistakes in that game.