QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by genus49:
I'm very much against the thought that cuz Josh hasn't been to the SB that he's worse than Brock. He's very clearly an elite QB and can do things Brock will never be able to do and losing to Mahomes is the same thing Brock did.

However the idea that the Bills roster wasn't good simply isn't true. Yes Josh makes them a lot better than had Brock been their QB(or many other QBs for that matter) but just because you don't know much about their roster doesn't mean they're bad.

They just don't have the big name guys…and that can change in time. I mean we can even got to an extreme take mode and say look at Shakir, the one game he missed all year Josh completed 30% of his passes and threw for just 131 yards. Josh had 32 seconds in that game with a tie, threw 3 straight incompletions and managed to give the ball back to Houston with enough time so they could win on a game winning FG.

That's just one game without his top WR and that's the performance we saw from him.

Which brings me back to…EVERY QB needs help. Some are able to do more with less but none of them can do more with nothing.

Originally posted by pillageDatazz:

Originally posted by tankle104:

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:

Allen has been a beast in the playoffs. Of course Buffalo hasn't been to the SB, but that certainly isn't his fault. They lost a game where they scored 36 points, lol.

Yeah, Allen's team just isn't that good around him. They aren't terrible but when you're comparing the bills roster to Chiefs, Ravens, 49ers, Eagles etc - bills easily have the worst overall team (outside of our team this year).

Allen is a stud and Carry's that team weekly. I thought he should have won NFL MVP 2 years ago when Lamar got it. He carried the bills to the playoffs, it wasn't orettt but it was impressive.

Brock on Bills in playoffs with that defense and HC... good luck

Allen on Niners team in playoffs with all the weapons / Shanny / better D... we know the answer but some won't admit it

If he only had one chance legit chance like Brock there is no guarantee he wins. Theres no guarantee he even gets us to sb the way that Lions and Packers game went down

The guy has never won anything. What would he do with Aiyuk Deebo and CMC getting shutdown, Kittle unable to lift the arm, bad OL play, bad coaching, ST gaffes……we know the answer but won't admit. He would lose just like he does every year

Brock Year 3 > Josh Allen year 3. Fight me.

Only thing about Purdy that I'm not sure of yet is if he does get everything(a big contract), will he still have the fight in him to be his best? It is like a new territory for him.

I think he will, and hopefully it is getting the Super Bowl Championship that will drive him to continue to be the best he can be.

Originally posted by SlipAndSlideBosa:
Only thing about Purdy that I'm not sure of yet is if he does get everything(a big contract), will he still have the fight in him to be his best? It is like a new territory for him.

I think he will, and hopefully it is getting the Super Bowl Championship that will drive him to continue to be the best he can be.

I think he will be fine. Money isn't his object - he desires to be the best qb, husband, son etc that he can be. Im sure he will love being rich but id be shocked if he just stopped giving an eff.

Originally posted by 49ers808:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Brock Purdy on when he thought he was going to take over as the starting quarterback for the 49ers:

"Once Jimmy [Garoppolo] became the starter (in 2022) I was like 'I might get some playing time this year. I just don't know when'."

🎥: @Built4MorePod pic.twitter.com/uPHFrq2TYC

— Coach Yac 🗣 (@Coach_Yac) March 27, 2025

Create a custom 49ers jersey ⇨
that comment alone makes me like him even more

Yessssssssah!!!

dont think he was taking a shot @ Jimmy. But it sure came out that way,...lol.

Originally posted by krizay:

Our roster was nowhere near "nothing" last year, though. Injuries or not. I mean look around the league and compare,...there really were some QBs that never had much, whether on the field or from the booth.

Originally posted by random49er:

Originally posted by 49ers808:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Brock Purdy on when he thought he was going to take over as the starting quarterback for the 49ers:

"Once Jimmy [Garoppolo] became the starter (in 2022) I was like 'I might get some playing time this year. I just don't know when'."

🎥: @Built4MorePod pic.twitter.com/uPHFrq2TYC

— Coach Yac 🗣 (@Coach_Yac) March 27, 2025

that comment alone makes me like him even more

Yessssssssah!!!

dont think he was taking a shot @ Jimmy. But it sure came out that way,...lol.

He could be complimenting Jimmy by saying he could come in for Mop Up duty after blowing teams out.

Originally posted by BleedsRedNGold:
Brock Year 3 > Josh Allen year 3. Fight me.

LFG

Originally posted by pillageDatazz:

Originally posted by tankle104:

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:
Allen has been a beast in the playoffs. Of course Buffalo hasn't been to the SB, but that certainly isn't his fault. They lost a game where they scored 36 points, lol.

Yeah, Allen's team just isn't that good around him. They aren't terrible but when you're comparing the bills roster to Chiefs, Ravens, 49ers, Eagles etc - bills easily have the worst overall team (outside of our team this year).

Allen is a stud and Carry's that team weekly. I thought he should have won NFL MVP 2 years ago when Lamar got it. He carried the bills to the playoffs, it wasn't orettt but it was impressive.

Brock on Bills in playoffs with that defense and HC... good luck

Allen on Niners team in playoffs with all the weapons / Shanny / better D... we know the answer but some won't admit it

Playing with hypotheticals is stupid in whichever way you go. There is no proof in either direction.

I think it's pretty obvious that Josh Allen is a terrific QB and a better one than Brock but all we have to evaluate him is on the Bills.

However one thing some seem to forget is Josh has 4 extra seasons in the NFL to develop and improve. I still recall seeing a long Josh Allen lowlight video after his first two seasons when he was missing guys by a mile.

He took a huge step forward as soon as the Bills added a top WR onto their roster. He wasn't Mr don't need no help out of the gate.

Originally posted by BleedsRedNGold:
Brock Year 3 > Josh Allen year 3. Fight me.

Not year 3 but year 1-2 easily.

Josh had a lot of talent around him in year 3 and responded in a big way. It was his breakout season.

Originally posted by SlipAndSlideBosa:
Only thing about Purdy that I'm not sure of yet is if he does get everything(a big contract), will he still have the fight in him to be his best? It is like a new territory for him.

I think he will, and hopefully it is getting the Super Bowl Championship that will drive him to continue to be the best he can be.

If you listen to the podcast that Brock just did I would think any of your concerns would be eliminated. He's clearly not a guy who gets paid and then stops trying to be his best.

Originally posted by random49er:

Originally posted by krizay:

Our roster was nowhere near "nothing" last year, though. Injuries or not. I mean look around the league and compare,...there really were some QBs that never had much, whether on the field or from the booth.

Injuries across the offense.
Defense 3rd worst in the league in allowing points
Special teams that was an absolute nightmare

It may not have been "nothing" but it certainly wasn't a situation many QBs wish for like some have tried to paint it.

Originally posted by SlipAndSlideBosa:

Originally posted by random49er:

Originally posted by 49ers808:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Brock Purdy on when he thought he was going to take over as the starting quarterback for the 49ers:

"Once Jimmy [Garoppolo] became the starter (in 2022) I was like 'I might get some playing time this year. I just don't know when'."

🎥: @Built4MorePod pic.twitter.com/uPHFrq2TYC

— Coach Yac 🗣 (@Coach_Yac) March 27, 2025

that comment alone makes me like him even more

+ Show all quotes
Yessssssssah!!!

dont think he was taking a shot @ Jimmy. But it sure came out that way,...lol.

He could be complimenting Jimmy by saying he could come in for Mop Up duty after blowing teams out.

it's the simple fact that once trey went down, brock was dressing for games. gotta be active that's step 1 to see the field. went trey went down he was looking at an entire season of being active for gameday.

Hope we learned our lesson and get him extended before mini camp