QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by Monsterniner:
Mid-tier QB's shouldn't have so many fanboys.

"But but but Brock isn't a mid-tier QB"

Well....we all know he isn't a top-tier QB so..........

Originally posted by Monsterniner:
Mid-tier QB's shouldn't have so many fanboys.

"But but but Brock isn't a mid-tier QB"

Well....we all know he isn't a top-tier QB so..........

Low tier poster

Originally posted by 49erKing:

Originally posted by Typecast:

Originally posted by TheWooLick:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by Izyniner:
Fantastic then I see the best QB the niners have had since Steve Young! Pay the man!!

jeff garcia. we thought in 2012 we had the FQB and in 2017 also.

+ Show all quotes
Jeff Garcia was the best 49er QB since Young.

Now Purdy is the best 49er QB since Young.

1. Purdy
2. Jimmy
3. Garcia
4. AleX
5. Hill
6. Kaepernick/Gabbert
7. Mullens
8. Troy Smith
9. Rattay
10. Alex

Jimmy over Jeff?

Yea. Jeff was a much more inaccurate passer. Threw a bunch of dirt balls, but wasn't exactly on Shaun Hill's level. Had Jerry and TO to bail him out on those terrible jump throws and shoestring catches. His happy feet was a detriment to the pass protection. He actually had nice arm strength when he was throwing balls outside of games, but in games, his arm strength was just average. His biggest Ws are Carmella and the 2002 Wild Card game. Solid regular season quarterback that was ultra-competitive, tough guy mentality, and maxxed out his limitations, but at no point did I ever feel like Garcia could win a Super Bowl with any of his teams. So yea, Jimmy over Jeff, but it's not a huge gap. Purdy >>>> Jimmy/Jeff/AleX >>>> Hill/Kaep/Gabbert >>>>> the rest >>>>>>>>>>> Alex under Nolan > Others not named...

edit - Been awhile since I looked up the stats, but I believe Jimmy was slightly ahead of him there too.

Now we can finally settle the debate of Trey Lance vs Brock Purdy.

Lance>Purdy and its not even close.

Great 49ers gift ideas ⇨

Originally posted by Typecast:
Darnold's contract has 100.5M of total cash to be paid out over 3 years (33.5M total contract AAV). There is 5M in yearly incentives, maxxing Darnold out at 38.5M AAV. His 2025 compensation is fully guaranteed at signing (37.5M). 17.5M of his 27.5M 2026 compensation is guaranteed against injury at signing, vesting into a full guarantee 5 days after this years Super Bowl. That brings the "total guarantees" in the contract to 55M.

Geno had 31M and 1 year remaining on his old deal (edit - 16M of which was a roster bonus that became guaranteed, maybe already paid, on 3/16/2025). This extension adds 2 years and 75M in new cash bringing his total contract to 106M over 3 years (35.3M total AAV). The extension adds 3.5M in yearly incentives, maxxing Geno out at 116.5M (38.8M max AAV). The "total guarantees" in the contract is 66.5M, but we have no idea how much is guaranteed at signing at this point.

More details on Geno's deal.

• 116.5M over 3 years max. (38.8M max AAV)
  • 106M over 3 years. 58.5M fully guaranteed-at-signing. 66.5M total guaranteed. (35.3M total AAV)
    • 2025 compensation of 40.0M (up from 31M). 40M fully guaranteed-at-signing.
    • 2026 compensation of 26.5M. 18.5M fully guaranteed-at-signing. The remaining 8M is guaranteed for injury at signing and becomes fully guaranteed on the third day of the 2026 league year.
    • 2027 compensation of 39.5M. Not guaranteed.
  • 10.5M total in incentives.
    • 3.5M in incentives per year.

The extension added 75M in new cash and 2 years (37.5M extension AAV). If he hits all his incentives, his extension AAV hits 42.75M, giving him the opportunity to get the 40-45M he wanted from Seattle. Las Vegas has outs every year if they want to take it.

Originally posted by Monsterniner:
Mid-tier QB's shouldn't have so many fanboys.

"But but but Brock isn't a mid-tier QB"

Well....we all know he isn't a top-tier QB so..........

So to you it's simply top tier, mid tier and low tier then?

Let's see your QB tiers broken down since you're so eager to tell other fans what they should think.

Originally posted by genus49:
Aiyuk became an impact receiver once Purdy took over. Jennings looked like a WR1 with Brock throwing to him.

Are we sure he's not elevating the guys around him?

oh geeze...lol.

Originally posted by random49er:

Originally posted by genus49:
Aiyuk became an impact receiver once Purdy took over. Jennings looked like a WR1 with Brock throwing to him.

Are we sure he's not elevating the guys around him?

oh geeze...lol.

Don't expect you to understand how a WR who keeps getting open down the field only to have the QB take a shorter throw would improve with a QB actually more willing to throw down the field and take those shots vs the safe short stuff.

Originally posted by genus49:
So to you it's simply top tier, mid tier and low tier then?

Let's see your QB tiers broken down since you're so eager to tell other fans what they should think.

this is actually true.

Originally posted by random49er:

Originally posted by genus49:
Aiyuk became an impact receiver once Purdy took over. Jennings looked like a WR1 with Brock throwing to him.

Are we sure he's not elevating the guys around him?

oh geeze...lol.

?

Originally posted by Montana:

Originally posted by Monsterniner:
Mid-tier QB's shouldn't have so many fanboys.

"But but but Brock isn't a mid-tier QB"

Well....we all know he isn't a top-tier QB so..........

Low tier poster

Got em

Florio may never become even an average reporter, so why should anyone care what he thinks?

Originally posted by bvc49:
Florio may never become even an average reporter, so why should anyone care what he thinks?

What he says comes true…

Originally posted by 9erson3:

Originally posted by bvc49:
Florio may never become even an average reporter, so why should anyone care what he thinks?

What he says comes true…

Since when?

also what did I miss? Why are we talking about Florio?

Originally posted by Typecast:

Originally posted by TD49ers:

Originally posted by Fanaticofnfl:

Originally posted by braap49er:

Craig Carton is hearing Brock Purdy is close to signing an extension worth $300M:

"There's some debate as to how much of that deal would be guaranteed. They'd like it to be close to 250 guaranteed. There's some pushback on that from San Francisco, but I was told a deal was a lot… pic.twitter.com/hltK5aGcvq

— Coach Yac 🗣 (@Coach_Yac) April 4, 2025

+ Show all quotes
Five years or six years? Pretty massive difference between $50M and $60M.

I hope not. That will sink this team. Purdy is not elite.

No, it won't. The Bills just gave Allen a 330M/6 year contract (55M total AAV). The 49ers would need to give Purdy a 324.6M/5 extension to equal Allen. That's an extension AAV of 64.95M. This isn't 2023/2024. The cap has grown. The cap will continue to grow naturally year-to-year. The salary cap will get a boost when the league opts out of the current media deal in 2029. The salary cap will get a boost when the league and players renegotiate the splits on the revenue sharing in 2030. Purdy at 60M will be like 10th after the next wave of QB contracts getting QBs to 75M+ extension AAVs.

Allen is elite, purdy is not.