QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by random49er:
Brock doesn't have the arm strength Garcia had to get it out to TO like that

Lol

Not the best since Steve?

Originally posted by TD49ers:

Originally posted by Bringbackedjr:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by TD49ers:

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by 9erson3:

Originally posted by bvc49:
Florio may never become even an average reporter, so why should anyone care what he thinks?

What he says comes true…

Since when?

also what did I miss? Why are we talking about Florio?

Because he has a view that should be considered. He is not in a bubble.

+ Show all quotes
You can say this about any young qb. Nobody is guaranteed to become great

I would argue his "view" is based on one thing and one thing only. He makes inflammatory remarks to get attention. He does this to remain relevant. It's all about the clicks. Clicks=$. Why does Bonilla assist him and others like him by basically reposting trash?

Nothing was inflammatory unless you are overly biased.

Wrong. The basis for all these stupid ass revelations is the same faulty argument. If the team around him is less talented then he can't overcome that on his own. That is plain stupid. Every QB on this planet will be less effective if he has less talent on the field. What QB was capable of overcoming all the s**t of last year? Nobody could. Brock is an easy target because some can't get over the fact that he was the last pick of the draft. If bias is at play then point your finger at these stupid ass commentators who are want to be journalists. They can't accept him in the top 10 because of his draft position. They will continue to drag his name down at every opportunity. The argument on its face is indeed inflammatory.

Originally posted by Kolohe:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by random49er:
Brock doesn't have the arm strength Garcia had to get it out to TO like that

Lol

Originally posted by Kolohe:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by random49er:
Brock doesn't have the arm strength Garcia had to get it out to TO like that

Lol

Haha... these Jimmy guys never quit!

Originally posted by TD49ers:

Originally posted by Typecast:

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:
Why do you have Alex twice? Having Shaun Hill over Kaepernick is laughably absurd.

1. Purdy
2. Garcia
3. Kaepernick
4. Alex (I guess)
5. Hill
6. Mullens
6. I think we are done here

AleX (not the X) is for XTREME! That's Harbaugh Alex. The other Alex is pre-Harbaugh Alex.

Garcia was better than Purdy at this point relatively.

I cannot agree with this at all.

Originally posted by Typecast:

If you are dumb enough to argue about "leverage" and using the tag to punish ourselves, please stop citing the 2025 non-exclusive franchise tag value... Purdy cannot be franchise tagged this year. The non-exclusive franchise tag should be over 45M next year.

Hmmm. I guess this infers that smarter people like yourself know to ignore the learned, well-versed subject of "leverage" in areas like business, economics, financial management, et. al.?

Would be great for you to simply piece together why posters that consider this are dumb, and why your rationale of sidestepping it is linked to your higher IQ.

1. Montana
2. Young
3. Purdy
4. Garcia
5. Kap
6. Jimm---ok I like Alex here more. Plus, he taught Mahomes everything he knows
7. Jimmy
8. I think we are done here

Originally posted by Montana:

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:
Why do you have Alex twice? Having Shaun Hill over Kaepernick is laughably absurd.

1. Purdy
2. Garcia
3. Kaepernick
4. Alex (I guess)
5. Hill
6. Mullens
6. I think we are done here

No Jimmy?

My fault.

1. Purdy
2. Garcia
3. Kaepernick
4. Jimmy
5. Alex
6. Hill
7. Mullens
8. Who cares. LOL

Originally posted by Montana:
1. Montana
2. Young
3. Purdy
4. Garcia
5. Kap
6. Jimm---ok I like Alex here more. Plus, he taught Mahomes everything he knows
7. Jimmy
8. I think we are done here

In no universe was Alex better than Jimmy as a 49er. And I was far from a Jimmy fan.

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:
My fault.

1. Purdy
2. Garcia
3. Kaepernick
4. Jimmy
5. Alex
6. Hill
7. Mullens
8. Who cares. LOL

I kinda had a harder time between Alex and Jimmy

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:
In no universe was Alex better than Jimmy as a 49er. And I was far from a Jimmy fan.

If Jimmy had as much adversity as Alex..and if Jimmy didn't have Kyle..and Jim had H.....I mean. Idk..look at what happened when Jimmy left the 9ers? Idk I think Alex is probably the better qb..but as Niner..I mean, I guess Jimmy was better--as a Niner, under Kyle.

All this Jimmy G talk should go into his Goat thread so we can keep it alive forever!

Originally posted by Montana:
If Jimmy had as much adversity as Alex..and if Jimmy didn't have Kyle..and Jim had H.....I mean. Idk..look at what happened when Jimmy left the 9ers? Idk I think Alex is probably the better qb..but as Niner..I mean, I guess Jimmy was better--as a Niner, under Kyle.

Alex was a decent starter post 2011, Jimmy is a career backup with a couple of good starting years, a Ty Detmer or Case Keenum.

Originally posted by babarvaart:

Originally posted by Montana:
If Jimmy had as much adversity as Alex..and if Jimmy didn't have Kyle..and Jim had H.....I mean. Idk..look at what happened when Jimmy left the 9ers? Idk I think Alex is probably the better qb..but as Niner..I mean, I guess Jimmy was better--as a Niner, under Kyle.

Alex was a decent starter post 2011, Jimmy is a career backup with a couple of good starting years, a Ty Detmer or Case Keenum.

Some people would just love to forget supporting casts all together when speaking of a QB's success.

Only bring them up when there is an argument being made that maybe they arent all that.... lol. Almost never fails.

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:
In no universe was Alex better than Jimmy as a 49er. And I was far from a Jimmy fan.

Nearly all of Alex's best play, outside of 2011, wasn't as a 49er. Most of his time here was awful (not completely his fault, whole org was a sh!t show).

Jimmy played good ball here but was limited and held us back. Brock is awesome and put us in position to win Super Bowl. It didn't happen, boo hoo.

i never understand why these, usually subjective, lists matter anyways. Lol