Originally posted by Sask49erFan:
Yes, he was a better QB in 2023 and it's not debatable. With an all star supporting cast.
Take away that support cast like what happened in 2024 and he was average.
So what does that tell you?? That's my whole point why I don't think he's worth 50 mil. Because he needs that elite group of weapons to be a top 5 QB.
Pay him 50 mil a year and we aren't able to afford those weapons and we know based on statistical evidence what will happen.
But again, facts and stats still aren't enough. You will still argue that because of your opinion.
I asked you a simple question. Who had the better QB, OL and overall defense in that SB after you made the claim we had the best roster in the league.
Instead of answering me honestly because you knew where I was going with that question, you claimed the 49ers had the better guys at all 3 spots.
You basically claimed Purdy is a better QB than Mahomes…and you want to talk about opinions?
Do you understand how rushing defense works sometimes and why powerhouse offenses tend to have better run defenses than not? It's because they put up so many points on the regular that most teams they're playing simply can't stick with the run.
Either way I'm over this. However you still can't acknowledge the simple thing that this past season is not simply not having elite guys around Brock cuz he's getting too much money. It's those players being on the roster and not being able to play. You have injuries across the board and guys in and out of the lineup, rookies having to step up after missing key training camp time to get on the same page.
This throws off the timing based offense in a big way. That's not even taking into account all the defensive and special teams failures personnel wise and coaching that caused us to lose games.
You may in fact be right and Brock won't be able to play at a high level if he gets paid and we lose guys in time BUT that is not something you can tell from last season.
And imo(this is an actual opinion so I don't expect people to agree) he showed me more this past season with all the BS we had that he absolutely CAN be the QB we pay and build around and I don't believe he needs 2023 type skill players around him to succeed…he just needs a solid OL and consistency with his receivers whether they be Brandon Aiyuk level or Jauan Jennings or CMC level or Mason/Guerendo level.
