QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by 49ersRing:

Originally posted by boast:

Originally posted by 49ersRing:
The idea that Brock doesn't have a lot of talent was the consensus opinion of all 32 teams in the NFL or he wouldn't have lasted until the very last pick of the draft.

his draft position means f**k all.

I'm just trying to understand why you're giving random s**t for an opinion that was shared by at least 31/32 teams in the league and most of this forum until about 5 weeks ago.

because the kid has now played in 5.90 games and has proven that he is indeed talented and was obviously underdrafted.

redo the 2022 Draft today and Purdy is picked much much much higher.

Originally posted by 49ersRing:

Originally posted by boast:

Originally posted by 49ersRing:
The idea that Brock doesn't have a lot of talent was the consensus opinion of all 32 teams in the NFL or he wouldn't have lasted until the very last pick of the draft.

his draft position means f**k all.

I'm just trying to understand why you're giving random s**t for an opinion that was shared by at least 31/32 teams in the league and most of this forum until about 5 weeks ago.

LoL....if we thought he had loads of talent he wouldn'tve made it passed the 4th round with us.

I do think he has talent, though. Does that count for something, at least?

I just dont understand why I have to agree with boast that he is an extreme talent. Maybe someone can fill me in on why I have to?

I'm sure the guy was recently mad @ me for dispelling the outlandish comments that JimmyG's a better QB than Josh Allen.

With all the receipts everywhere, it really does get entertaining.

Originally posted by random49er:

Originally posted by boast:
#neverforget

Given our history on QBs, you dont have any credibility.

this comment is full of s**t too. youre trying to take some win that doesn't exist.

lol...receipts about your JimmyG bullying are everywhere.



If unchecked,...history only repeats itself.

Like I said a few posts before, dynamic vision is not something you learn. It's something you have or don't have. That's why on the second touchdown to Kittle versus Seattle, EVERY ONE OF US knows Jimmy is throwing that ball to McCaffrey, because that's where it was designed to go, and Jimmy will not see what the defense is doing away from where he initially plans to go with the ball. But Brock has excellent vision and awareness, and he DOES see when the defense completely busts a coverage even if the play is clearly designed to go somewhere else.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5vm9xkJvJxg&ab_channel=NotNBAgamingboy

Originally posted by random49er:

Originally posted by boast:
#neverforget

Given our history on QBs, you dont have any credibility.

this comment is full of s**t too. youre trying to take some win that doesn't exist.

lol...receipts about your JimmyG bullying are everywhere.



If unchecked,...history only repeats itself.

hahahahahahah what does this have to do with me?

5GR was the poster who got mad at me because he claimed Jimmy couldn't improve because of his brain plasticity. i made fun of him and he lost his s**t.

5GR is a tutor not a doctor. where did he get Jimmy's brain scans? how did he learn to interpret them?

hahahaha again these kinds of comebacks show your posts are full of s**t. thanks for tripling down.

Originally posted by Chance:

Originally posted by 49ersRing:

Originally posted by boast:

Originally posted by 49ersRing:
The idea that Brock doesn't have a lot of talent was the consensus opinion of all 32 teams in the NFL or he wouldn't have lasted until the very last pick of the draft.

his draft position means f**k all.

I'm just trying to understand why you're giving random s**t for an opinion that was shared by at least 31/32 teams in the league and most of this forum until about 5 weeks ago.

You can't make up the stupidity of these comments. Let's rewind the the clock before Brock took a snap to gauge current sentiment. If Brock entered the draft today he'd be the first pick.

No, he probably wouldn't be because: 1. Teams have seen a lot of QBs fall off after small sample sizes. I mean, halfway through this season the top rated QBs were Tua and Geno Smith, but I don't think teams would be ready to trade the house for those guys. 2. This team is the most talented offense in the league and has a top 2-3 offensive mind at head coach. It is reasonable for other teams to wonder what the drop off would be if Purdy was on their team with whatever crappy situation they have.

Also, isn't the comment that is being quoted from weeks ago, which makes it more understandable? For the record, I do think Purdy is talented. I was impressed with him back during the preseason. I thought he looked more talented than Jimmy ever did (and it turns out he's way better than Jimmy and it isn't close).

Originally posted by boast:

Originally posted by 49ersRing:

Originally posted by boast:

Originally posted by 49ersRing:
The idea that Brock doesn't have a lot of talent was the consensus opinion of all 32 teams in the NFL or he wouldn't have lasted until the very last pick of the draft.

his draft position means f**k all.

I'm just trying to understand why you're giving random s**t for an opinion that was shared by at least 31/32 teams in the league and most of this forum until about 5 weeks ago.

because the kid has now played in 5.90 games and has proven that he is indeed talented and was obviously underdrafted.

redo the 2022 Draft today and Purdy is picked much much much higher.

I don't disagree with that.

Originally posted by boast:

Originally posted by random49er:

Originally posted by boast:
#neverforget

Given our history on QBs, you dont have any credibility.

this comment is full of s**t too. youre trying to take some win that doesn't exist.

lol...receipts about your JimmyG bullying are everywhere.



If unchecked,...history only repeats itself.

hahahahahahah what does this have to do with me?

5GR was the poster who got mad at me because he claimed Jimmy couldn't improve because of his brain plasticity. i made fun of him and he lost his s**t.

5GR is a tutor not a doctor. where did he get Jimmy's brain scans? how did he learn to interpret them?

hahahaha again these kinds of comebacks show your posts are full of s**t. thanks for tripling down.

First of all, I'm not a tutor. I HAVE tutored (and for the record, tutoring college students in math, physics, computer science and chemistry is not something you are capable of doing, guaranteed).

Second, that's not what I said. Whatever you are, it can't be something that requires critical thinking. That was merely a hypothesis to explain why no one ever gets better at it. And I backed it up by PEER REVIEWED SCIENTIFIC STUDIES.

Third, I WAS RIGHT. I'm STILL right. Jimmy DID NOT improve his field vision, AND HE NEVER WILL. Purdy came right into the league doing it, doing what Jimmy has not improved in SIX YEARS. How, boast? How does a rookie magically come into the league better at something related to the brain that Jimmy never improved? I'll tell you how: because it's something you're born with, and it's not something most people can appreciably improve, because it is directly tied to how your brain operates.

.
.
.

Edit--you will conspicuously fail to mention the fact that Jimmy was still throwing balls to defenders over the middle that he should have seen but did not, and he was STILL failing to see wide open busted coverages (such as in the Broncos game), as I previously proved to you earlier in the year, and you predictably simply didn't reply, which is your modus operandi.

Since I am only @ risk continuing this boast, and you are not, I accept your apology for being wrong and will bow out.

I love the way this kid doesn't at all look like a rookie out there. Like....not AT ALL. Shanahan found a good one,...and this staff has proven over and over again that they can find guys late.

Originally posted by random49er:
LoL....if we thought he had loads of talent he wouldn'tve made it passed the 4th round with us.

This is a straw man argument. No one is claiming that teams thought he was this talented during last year's draft. He's shown to be immensely talented over the last 5 plus games. Stick to the argument and stop changing it so you can somehow be correct.

imagine questioning other posters' credibility.

Originally posted by Chance:

Originally posted by random49er:
LoL....if we thought he had loads of talent he wouldn'tve made it passed the 4th round with us.

This is a straw man argument. No one is claiming that teams thought he was this talented during last year's draft. He's shown to be immensely talented over the last 5 plus games. Stick to the argument and stop changing it so you can somehow be correct.

this

Originally posted by random49er:
Since I am only @ risk continuing this boast, and you are not, I accept your apology for being wrong and will bow out.

I love the way this kid doesn't at all look like a rookie out there. Like....not AT ALL. Shanahan found a good one,...and this staff has proven over and over again that they can find guys late.

no apology exists tho. i wasnt wrong.

this is you AGAIN making up something that never existed.

Originally posted by boast:
imagine questioning other posters' credibility.

Okay?? LoL

Originally posted by 49ersRing:

Originally posted by boast:

Originally posted by 49ersRing:

Originally posted by boast:

Originally posted by 49ersRing:
The idea that Brock doesn't have a lot of talent was the consensus opinion of all 32 teams in the NFL or he wouldn't have lasted until the very last pick of the draft.

his draft position means f**k all.

I'm just trying to understand why you're giving random s**t for an opinion that was shared by at least 31/32 teams in the league and most of this forum until about 5 weeks ago.

because the kid has now played in 5.90 games and has proven that he is indeed talented and was obviously underdrafted.

redo the 2022 Draft today and Purdy is picked much much much higher.

I don't disagree with that.

At least half the players would be drafted higher or lower. Nobody knows how these guys are going to work out until they see them play. I'm watching the Lions game and Amon Ra St. Brown has over 100 catches this season. He was decent in college but he's much better now. At least his performance is. You just never know what you've got until he plays in your system.

Originally posted by Chance:

Originally posted by random49er:
LoL....if we thought he had loads of talent he wouldn'tve made it passed the 4th round with us.

This is a straw man argument. No one is claiming that teams thought he was this talented during last year's draft. He's shown to be immensely talented over the last 5 plus games. Stick to the argument and stop changing it so you can somehow be correct.

Not a strawman argument @ all. He tried to force me to have the same opinion as him.

I don't. Is that okay?

Talent is defined in a number of different ways, btw, so context is everything.