QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by 49ersRing:

Pay me if you want me to do the legwork on your ridiculous and arbitrary standard to prove a mild critique (mentioned amongst praise in the context of trying to understand where the author of an article was coming from). Not to mention it also appearing on his scouting report and being mentioned by other 49ers analysts. Just a ridiculous attempt to censor all criticism and discussion like you used to do with Jimmy. Only a matter of time before you start accusing people of being in the Purdy Haters Club (if you haven't already).

Originally posted by 49ersRing:


Pay me if you want me to do the legwork on your ridiculous and arbitrary standard to prove a mild critique (mentioned amongst praise in the context of trying to understand where the author of an article was coming from). Not to mention it also appearing on his scouting report and being mentioned by other 49ers analysts. Just a ridiculous attempt to censor all criticism and discussion like you used to do with Jimmy. Only a matter of time before you start accusing people of being in the Purdy Haters Club (if you haven't already).

Originally posted by 49ersRing:

Originally posted by VinculumJuris:

Originally posted by 49ersRing:
They're both subjective and I am under no obligation to provide any data points whatsoever, especially when it has been routinely demonstrated that no matter how clear cut the example is, it'll be dismissed.

As for overstating my points: "That said, I'm not sure what the dude is talking about in terms of Purdy's mechanics or happy feet. They seem at worst fine, and actually seem pretty good. He has a very natural throwing motion and seems comfortable throwing from different arm angles. He does have a tendency to break the pocket too soon" Wow, what a searing and strongly worded criticism of something that was basically just reiterating something from his scouting report and observed by others.

Just trying to help you, bud. Stating your subjective opinion as fact is... Overstating.

I didn't state whether it was an opinion or a fact, because the nature of the observation implies that it is subjective in the same way that any scouting report or analysis that isn't purely based on metrics or measurables would be. It is ridiculous to expect people to qualify everything they post as their opinion when in almost every case it is obvious.

Originally posted by TheWooLick:

Originally posted by 49ersRing:


Pay me if you want me to do the legwork on your ridiculous and arbitrary standard to prove a mild critique (mentioned amongst praise in the context of trying to understand where the author of an article was coming from). Not to mention it also appearing on his scouting report and being mentioned by other 49ers analysts. Just a ridiculous attempt to censor all criticism and discussion like you used to do with Jimmy. Only a matter of time before you start accusing people of being in the Purdy Haters Club (if you haven't already).

How are you being "censored"?

Originally posted by 49ersRing:

Originally posted by qnnhan7:

It feels like Arizona was kind of daring Brock Purdy to make a throw outside the numbers from the far hash here

The corner at the bottom of the screen is playing way off with inside leverage with what I imagine was the intention of taking away anything breaking inside from CMC pic.twitter.com/Fbp9X7K1TL

— Jordan Elliott (@splash_cousin) January 10, 2023

Brock has an NFL arm. You can't tell me Brock has a weak arm with that throw from the far hash mark.

IMO, it's a good throw, but a better example of timing, anticipation, and accuracy rather than arm strength. He begins his windup before CMC begins his break and the corner has no chance on the ball due to where it's placed.

Originally posted by boast:

Originally posted by 49ersRing:


Pay me if you want me to do the legwork on your ridiculous and arbitrary standard to prove a mild critique (mentioned amongst praise in the context of trying to understand where the author of an article was coming from). Not to mention it also appearing on his scouting report and being mentioned by other 49ers analysts. Just a ridiculous attempt to censor all criticism and discussion like you used to do with Jimmy. Only a matter of time before you start accusing people of being in the Purdy Haters Club (if you haven't already).

if you're equating people responding to and criticizing your criticisms to "attempts to censor", posting your opinions on a public discussion forum is probably not the place for you. that's just playing a victim card.

Originally posted by TheWooLick:

Originally posted by 49ersRing:


Pay me if you want me to do the legwork on your ridiculous and arbitrary standard to prove a mild critique (mentioned amongst praise in the context of trying to understand where the author of an article was coming from). Not to mention it also appearing on his scouting report and being mentioned by other 49ers analysts. Just a ridiculous attempt to censor all criticism and discussion like you used to do with Jimmy. Only a matter of time before you start accusing people of being in the Purdy Haters Club (if you haven't already).

How are you being "censored"?

Originally posted by NinerBuff:
I believe I'm correct. Purdy has 0 wasted TOs, no delay penalties, and no procedure penalties. As a rookie. Just outstanding.

Originally posted by 49ersRing:

Originally posted by TheWooLick:

Originally posted by 49ersRing:


Pay me if you want me to do the legwork on your ridiculous and arbitrary standard to prove a mild critique (mentioned amongst praise in the context of trying to understand where the author of an article was coming from). Not to mention it also appearing on his scouting report and being mentioned by other 49ers analysts. Just a ridiculous attempt to censor all criticism and discussion like you used to do with Jimmy. Only a matter of time before you start accusing people of being in the Purdy Haters Club (if you haven't already).

How are you being "censored"?

Did I say I was? I pointed out what Furlow does and he's openly called for a number of posters to be banned when they've argued with him (and haven't been because they didn't do anything wrong).

It's disingenuous to pull one word out of context and then intentionally use it to misrepresent what someone has said.

Originally posted by 49ersRing:
Just a ridiculous attempt to CENSOR all criticism and discussion like you used to do with Jimmy.

Originally posted by Furlow:


It's as if Purdy was gesturing to Kyle, Ring, Random, and all of the others pillorying Purdy in here.

Originally posted by Furlow:

Originally posted by 49ersRing:

Originally posted by TheWooLick:

Originally posted by 49ersRing:


Pay me if you want me to do the legwork on your ridiculous and arbitrary standard to prove a mild critique (mentioned amongst praise in the context of trying to understand where the author of an article was coming from). Not to mention it also appearing on his scouting report and being mentioned by other 49ers analysts. Just a ridiculous attempt to censor all criticism and discussion like you used to do with Jimmy. Only a matter of time before you start accusing people of being in the Purdy Haters Club (if you haven't already).

How are you being "censored"?

Did I say I was? I pointed out what Furlow does and he's openly called for a number of posters to be banned when they've argued with him (and haven't been because they didn't do anything wrong).

It's disingenuous to pull one word out of context and then intentionally use it to misrepresent what someone has said.

Yes:

Originally posted by 49ersRing:
Just a ridiculous attempt to CENSOR all criticism and discussion like you used to do with Jimmy.

In bold and caps for you.