Originally posted by tankle104:
Originally posted by Furlow:
That's a strong statement! A couple weeks ago I said I'd take Mahomes, Burrow, Allen, and Herbert over him and that's it. After watching more of Allen and Herbert the past few weeks, I'm crossing them off that list. Disclaimer so people don't lose their minds lol - I'm talking about with this team, Kyle, etc. Purdy just FITS.
Hahahaha looks like I got you 😏. I was just one upping NFN.
i definitely think burrow and Mahomes are better than Purdy, at least right now. Herbert has a great skill set but there is something about his game I'm not a big fan of (maybes it the coaching/scheme?) but I really don't like his throwing motion - it's a super weird angle
the Josh allen one is interesting because Allen is obviously a really good quarterback. He isn't playing as clean and precise as he was under Daboll (now the giants HC). So it's interesting to see him regress some.
Also, I know this isn't exactly accurate to what would of happened, but it's the best data we have. Purdy was on track to have a 39 TD & 9 INT (excluding the KC pick in garbage time). So that's nothing to sneeze at.
Purdy is going to come out playing out of his mind next season after a full off season of training and reviewing his film. I'm not saying Purdy is better than Allen right now, just don't know if I'd trade them at this point.
Oh okay lol. I think Mahomes is special and works in any system. Same as Burrow. Why I put them over Purdy. But the rest have flaws that we just haven't seen from Purdy nor do I think we will see. There's enough tape on him that DC's have thrown it all at him and he still finds the open WR and makes the smart play.