LISTEN: Are The 49ers Done? →

There are 207 users in the forums

QB Brock Purdy Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Originally posted by Goatie:
Originally posted by SLCNiner:
Originally posted by Goatie:
Originally posted by SLCNiner:
Originally posted by Ezekiel38:
Originally posted by Pillbusta:
Originally posted by Crown:
We absolutely need to keep both, I think it would be foolish to trade Trey.

While I respect Jimmy's contributions, it's not worth resigning him if you keep Trey

Good thing we have a front office that knows this. We keep both and we don't worry about a QB injury for two or three seasons while we focus our efforts elsewhere while continuing to develop both guys cheaply. We are talking about guys that are both 22 and 23 years old!

Seriously. Thank God the front office isn't stupid enough to trade Trey Lance. It's like people forget we are on our 3rd string QB this year due to injuries.

The "Trade Trey" group dont want him traded for any reason that would benefit the team. It's just personal problems they have with him.

Trey will ask for a trade himself when he realized he has no chance of being QB1 for years to come. He will want to be QB1 on another team rather than be 2nd or 3rd stringer to Purdy. You wait and see.

He may ask for a trade. Deebo asked for a trade. Gould asked for a trade. I still clown the idiots that wanted them traded, being such a knee jerk reaction that would have obviously resulted the team being worse off. Do you think this now because of the report about his insta tweet response to the Carthon hiring? Seems like before that you saw him as a bust based off of the 3 games he started. I grew up watching Joe own the league and during the Montana/Young debates I wanted Steve gone just because Joe was my dude. So I do understand it a bit, but Jimmy gone regardless. Additionally, since those years we haven't even sniffed a FQB. Couple that with the injuries we've suffered at the position the last few years, and that is why I want to keep both as long as we possibly can. I have no doubt that you have reasons as to why you want Trey off our team, I just don't see how they could be related to football, since nobody knows what Trey will be yet. Kyle has the best idea, and I'll honestly be cool with whatever decision he makes.

I started following NFL when Joe Nameth was playing. I have seen footballers come and go in various versions of football incl NFL, Rugby, Rugby League, Soccer etc.

When a key play has got it, it is obvious. Purdy has it. Lance does not. Lance only had one season in college and the lack of experience shows, He did alright in college because of his athleticism and size. Now he is in the big legal and his size matters little to his experience and football IQ, He was a bad pick and will be moving on sooner or later. His contract won't be renewed and he wont be getting another chance at starting on merit as Purdy is way above his ceiling.

😂 This is so sad. You saw maybe one or two games that got televised in Australia back then. A quick Google search shows that it wasn't available for consistent broadcast until the 2010s. When you came on this forum you were clueless about most of the game. I can easily go back and show your posts from the Aussie thread you guys had when you came over and became a fan after Hayne got signed.

And there's nothing wrong with new fans, but don't act like you've been following football for 5 decades. Even without all the receipts I can pull up years ago from you, you have clearly shown by your posts that you don't know what you are talking about most of the time. You didn't even know what a dead cap was up until a month ago...
[ Edited by GoreGoreGore on Jan 22, 2023 at 7:11 AM ]
  • Furlow
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 21,941
Originally posted by 9ers4eva:
Originally posted by Furlow:
I like Trey a lot. But if we can get a first for him, and use that to draft a RT who we pay $8-$9m/year rather than pay McGlinchey $18-$20m/year, and use the rest to help re-sign Bosa and Aiyuk, it's a win. Plus it gives Trey a chance to develop rather than sit, which is better for him, so it's win/win. If you're truly a fan of Trey then you don't want him sitting the bench for the Niners.

If they were to do that they'd be better off getting a corner.

That's fine too. It's about efficient deployment of capital.
Gameday!!!! LFG Brock!!!!
Originally posted by Goatie:
Originally posted by SLCNiner:
Originally posted by Ezekiel38:
Originally posted by Pillbusta:
Originally posted by Crown:
We absolutely need to keep both, I think it would be foolish to trade Trey.

While I respect Jimmy's contributions, it's not worth resigning him if you keep Trey

Good thing we have a front office that knows this. We keep both and we don't worry about a QB injury for two or three seasons while we focus our efforts elsewhere while continuing to develop both guys cheaply. We are talking about guys that are both 22 and 23 years old!

Seriously. Thank God the front office isn't stupid enough to trade Trey Lance. It's like people forget we are on our 3rd string QB this year due to injuries.

The "Trade Trey" group dont want him traded for any reason that would benefit the team. It's just personal problems they have with him.

Trey will ask for a trade himself when he realized he has no chance of being QB1 for years to come. He will want to be QB1 on another team rather than be 2nd or 3rd stringer to Purdy. You wait and see.

So what. He's under contract. We have two more years at about $10m per year reasonable back up money while Brock is only drawing $1m, and can't be given a raise. Trade him before Trey's cap doubles on the 5th year option, and after he's had a chance to prove himself in some games.

What's his options? Retire, and have no football career? Lose the chance to learn under Kyle? No way.
[ Edited by BOI49er on Jan 22, 2023 at 6:17 AM ]
What more boxes can be checked today? How many has he already checked off?
Originally posted by NCommand:
What more boxes can be checked today? How many has he already checked off?

My only concern is that he really hasn't been tested in late game scenarios.
Originally posted by NCommand:
What more boxes can be checked today? How many has he already checked off?

Idk what else we need to see. I guess winning a SB lol. Kid is legit. Now the next step will be continuing to put in the work every offseason. Can't get complacent, can't let it get to your head. DCs will catch up and figure out what his weaknesses are and it's up to him to work on those so he's always one step ahead.
Originally posted by GoreGoreGore:
Idk what else we need to see. I guess winning a SB lol. Kid is legit. Now the next step will be continuing to put in the work every offseason. Can't get complacent, can't let it get to your head. DCs will catch up and figure out what his weaknesses are and it's up to him to work on those so he's always one step ahead.

We need to see him beat Dak and Hurts and Mahomes because that's who Trey was drafted to beat because Jimmy was deemed not capable by our front office. We want to see him put up a great showing win or lose and when that happens we have even more ammunition to unseat Trey as the starter.

PHI is winning with Hurts and we believe Trey can be better than Hurts. What we want Brock to show by winning is that he is better than all or most of them measurable by a W. We don't need height weight speed. We need wins

I believe Brock is gonna do it but we ain't trading Trey away for anything less than a fortune and last offseason proved that with Jimmy for the nonbelievers
[ Edited by Pillbusta on Jan 22, 2023 at 6:49 AM ]
Purdy and Mahomes pt2

https://www.youtube.com/shorts/KXxp7kij4no
Originally posted by NCommand:
What more boxes can be checked today? How many has he already checked off?

DVOA pass defense ranks he's faced:

13 commanders
15 bucs
17 seahawks x 3
21 cards
25 dolphins
31 raiders

Dallas has the #3 pass defense in the league. So he has some boxes to check.
  • mayo49
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 64,320
Originally posted by NCommand:
What more boxes can be checked today? How many has he already checked off?

I think he's going to check them all off. Super Bowl, Rookie of The Year and League MVP.
[ Edited by mayo49 on Jan 22, 2023 at 6:53 AM ]
Originally posted by Jcool:
DVOA pass defense ranks he's faced:

13 commanders
15 bucs
17 seahawks x 3
21 cards
25 dolphins
31 raiders

Dallas has the #3 pass defense in the league. So he has some boxes to check.

We're asking a lot for Mr Irrelevant but if my defensive players and my own eyes are telling me he's capable, I have no choice but to believe what I've been seeing and hearing
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
He's not going to be QB1 with anyone. Watch him play. Maybe he can be a backup fullback.

agreed, but I think he could be an NFL TE
Originally posted by Pillbusta:
Originally posted by GoreGoreGore:
Idk what else we need to see. I guess winning a SB lol. Kid is legit. Now the next step will be continuing to put in the work every offseason. Can't get complacent, can't let it get to your head. DCs will catch up and figure out what his weaknesses are and it's up to him to work on those so he's always one step ahead.

We need to see him beat Dak and Hurts and Mahomes because that's who Trey was drafted to beat because Jimmy was deemed not capable by our front office. We want to see him put up a great showing win or lose and when that happens we have even more ammunition to unseat Trey as the starter.

PHI is winning with Hurts and we believe Trey can be better than Hurts. What we want Brock to show by winning is that he is better than all or most of them measurable by a W. We don't need height weight speed. We need wins

I believe Brock is gonna do it but we ain't trading Trey away for anything less than a fortune and last offseason proved that with Jimmy for the nonbelievers

  • mayo49
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 64,320
Originally posted by riverrunzthruit:
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
He's not going to be QB1 with anyone. Watch him play. Maybe he can be a backup fullback.

agreed, but I think he could be an NFL TE

He'll be a QB1 with someone, just got to work on that accuracy.
Share 49ersWebzone