QB Brock Purdy Thread

Been watching all the day-time sports shows. They are 90% on Philly. But I don't get the sense it's football based. I honestly think the sports media don't want this Brok Purdy team to win. They all picking Philly, but then proceed to almost give advice to the Eagles on the best way to attach the 49ers defense, and what the Eagles defense needs to do to contain Purdy and force him into rookie mistakes. Several commentators flat-out say are going with Philly because Purdy will turn back into a pumpkin.

I am not only expecting a 49ers win, I'm hoping for a blowout.

Brock Purdy is tied for 6th in the NFL with a 2.6% TWP rate. He is tied with Tom Brady, Jimmy Garoppolo and Russell Wilson. When under pressure, Brock is 4th in the NFL with a 2.1% TWP rate.

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by JTB1974:

Originally posted by thl408:

I present to you, every Brock Purdy interceptable pass pic.twitter.com/l3kJXi6lUg

— Parker (@ParkerLewes) January 26, 2023

You can do that with every QB though. If you do that with Mahomes you can probally find 2 or 3 passes every game where you can say that ball could have been picked.

Just a week ago everyone was making fun of Dak and all his INTs (including me). You put the ball in harms way, regardless if it's picked off it's a bad throw imo.

Yeah, but a good percentage of those throws weren't in harm's way, which was the point of the poster to which you were responding. It's fine to critique Brock on some of the decisions he's made, but let's start the discussion with a series of clips that aren't trying to make him look bad for stuff that was pretty f**king innocuous.

Originally posted by YACBros85:
Brock Purdy is tied for 6th in the NFL with a 2.6% TWP rate. He is tied with Tom Brady, Jimmy Garoppolo and Russell Wilson. When under pressure, Brock is 4th in the NFL with a 2.1% TWP rate.

But did you see that tweet??

Originally posted by Bay2Bay9erAllday:

Originally posted by YACBros85:
Brock Purdy is tied for 6th in the NFL with a 2.6% TWP rate. He is tied with Tom Brady, Jimmy Garoppolo and Russell Wilson. When under pressure, Brock is 4th in the NFL with a 2.1% TWP rate.

But did you see that tweet??

Why do I need to see that tweet? I have already watched every single one of Brock's passes in the NFL.

Originally posted by Furlow:

Originally posted by 49ers808:

Originally posted by YACBros85:

Originally posted by 49ers808:

Originally posted by YACBros85:

Originally posted by 49ers808:

Originally posted by YACBros85:

Originally posted by 49ers808:

Originally posted by YACBros85:
Its cool. I haven't watched the all 22 either. But if the ball was tipped at the LOS than no, it wouldn't be considered a TWP.

What about when it's tipped by the same defender who proceeds to intercept the ball?

You could go on and on all day long with these scenarios but is it really going to help make any progress in this conversation?

Hence the reason some don't take what PFF says as the end all be all on everything.

To answer your question with a question. Can a defender make a great play without the offense being at fault?

Absolutely! My turn. Could the offense have made an even better play (or throw in this instance), not giving the defender a chance to make a great play?

In your made up scenario. A tipped pass can just be a great play by the defender. And anyway, you can start recording your own set of stats with your own set of definitions. You are free to do so. But picking a play here and there and saying, this is happening too often or at a high rate without any reference point to compare to is worse than relying on a reputable stat site that pays folks to do it for a living.

Why so salty? Where did I say those things? I said like two per game. I stated that I didn't watch the All-22 for clarity and could be wrong and change my mind. If you are finding what I'm saying offensive or something then we can simply end this conversation

Because you're going on and on about Purdy being lucky and having two dropped INT's per game, but then saying that Tartt dropping the easy INT against the Rams just part of the game and we don't know what would have happened had he caught it.

But you're not alone. There is a tendency for constant and unrelenting negativity by a few on this board.

Of course you would jump in and say something like this lol.

1. Going on and on about Purdy being lucky and having two dropped interceptions a game is called having conversation. You know, exactly what an internet message board is here for. I'm not going on and on by myself and for the sake of it. I stated in my "on and on" that I haven't seen the All-22 and that's where I make my true judgements and could change my mind. thl just posted that tweet proving what we all saw in the regular game and playoffs; my take seems accurate

2. The Tartt thing is a completely different conversation. That guy implied that the Tartt play is the reason we lost the game. Go read it all and tell me how we are supposed to interpret that. We still had about 10 minutes left in the game and the offense had multiple chances to score and didn't. How that correlates to the Purdy conversation is beyond me but doesn't suprise me with you. You just replaced your all out defense for Jimmy with Brock.

3. You perceive context as negativity all the time. All I said is that Brock got lucky with some dropped picks, like all QBs do, and all of this backlash happened. We should really be able to have separate threads where only positive things can be said and talked about and another thread for people who like to discuss all aspects, both good and bad are allowed and not considered haters in doing so.

Originally posted by YACBros85:

Originally posted by Bay2Bay9erAllday:

Originally posted by YACBros85:
Brock Purdy is tied for 6th in the NFL with a 2.6% TWP rate. He is tied with Tom Brady, Jimmy Garoppolo and Russell Wilson. When under pressure, Brock is 4th in the NFL with a 2.1% TWP rate.

But did you see that tweet??

Why do I need to see that tweet? I have already watched every single one of Brock's passes in the NFL.

I wasn't being serious. I thought the ( ) would give it away lol

Originally posted by Bay2Bay9erAllday:

Originally posted by YACBros85:

Originally posted by Bay2Bay9erAllday:

Originally posted by YACBros85:
Brock Purdy is tied for 6th in the NFL with a 2.6% TWP rate. He is tied with Tom Brady, Jimmy Garoppolo and Russell Wilson. When under pressure, Brock is 4th in the NFL with a 2.1% TWP rate.

But did you see that tweet??

Why do I need to see that tweet? I have already watched every single one of Brock's passes in the NFL.

I wasn't being serious. I thought the ( ) would give it away lol

Sorry.

Originally posted by 9ersLiferInChicago:
Been watching all the day-time sports shows. They are 90% on Philly. But I don't get the sense it's football based. I honestly think the sports media don't want this Brok Purdy team to win. They all picking Philly, but then proceed to almost give advice to the Eagles on the best way to attach the 49ers defense, and what the Eagles defense needs to do to contain Purdy and force him into rookie mistakes. Several commentators flat-out say are going with Philly because Purdy will turn back into a pumpkin.

I am not only expecting a 49ers win, I'm hoping for a blowout.

Yeah I saw that. Hilarious, they act as if he will all of a sudden forget how to play football or something when dude has shown nothing but poise in every single game.

Originally posted by Afrikan:

Originally posted by NYniner85:
How many angry fans last week when kyle called QB power for Brock? I was told that play was only for Lance because he can't run the offense

Wasn't it a QB draw?

Regardless, didn't work for either qb. Lol

Can't wait for the commentators to be shocked as we beat the brakes off of them and get turnovers.

honestly, if we do dominate them - I'd recommend fans not talking too much smack. I don't think the fans will do anything in a regular tight game situation but if we blow them out and talk smack, expect some ridiculous things to happen.

Originally posted by tankle104:

Originally posted by Afrikan:

Originally posted by NYniner85:
How many angry fans last week when kyle called QB power for Brock? I was told that play was only for Lance because he can't run the offense

Wasn't it a QB draw?

Regardless, didn't work for either qb. Lol

OMG! Stop the press. We saw 1 QB designed run with Brock Purdy? How does that even compare to the 12 designed QB runs we saw in Trey's 5 quarters of play this season?

Originally posted by YACBros85:

Originally posted by tankle104:

Originally posted by Afrikan:

Originally posted by NYniner85:
How many angry fans last week when kyle called QB power for Brock? I was told that play was only for Lance because he can't run the offense

Wasn't it a QB draw?

Regardless, didn't work for either qb. Lol

OMG! Stop the press. We saw 1 QB designed run with Brock Purdy? How does that even compare to the 12 designed QB runs we saw in Trey's 5 quarters of play this season?

It doesn't compare. Weird comment by NY lol

Originally posted by YACBros85:

Originally posted by random49er:

Originally posted by YACBros85:
Fans on here must have a completely different point of view of what is considered a turnover worthy play than a business who specializes in such stats. A pass break up is not considered a turnover worthy play, just an FYI. And happens every week to every QB in the NFL.

Hmmmm. What about where defender drops the ball? Can that be a TWP and a PBU?

Could the receiver have made a better play on the ball?

Yes. A dropped INT is recorded as a PBU.

It's a TWP as well I assume...yes?

Originally posted by YACBros85:

Originally posted by tankle104:

Originally posted by Afrikan:

Originally posted by NYniner85:
How many angry fans last week when kyle called QB power for Brock? I was told that play was only for Lance because he can't run the offense

Wasn't it a QB draw?

Regardless, didn't work for either qb. Lol

OMG! Stop the press. We saw 1 QB designed run with Brock Purdy? How does that even compare to the 12 designed QB runs we saw in Trey's 5 quarters of play this season?

was it confirmed that, that was the play called ? Brock does and has shown he does things that are not drawn up that way