There are 288 users in the forums

CMC, on IR, C Ya Next Season

Shop Find 49ers gear online

CMC, on IR, C Ya Next Season

Originally posted by glorydayz:
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
Originally posted by glorydayz:
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
Originally posted by glorydayz:
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
Originally posted by glorydayz:
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
Originally posted by glorydayz:
So how did B.A work himself into his current contract? By sitting on the couch???

B.A's dad didn't go on the radio to discuss his injury or offseason training so who knows what he did in the off season.

CMC, B.A, & Trent Williams all went about their contract business in the same manner and all ended the season on IR.

I see no difference in these players.
lol, BA and TW took the offseason off and it showed. CMC went through all of camp

that is not the same+

TW & BA were the best at their positions too, only they had to go to social media and hold out cause they didn't have the privlidge of having it handed to them. Luckily it worked out for them in the end, so they did what they had to do.
lying about what exactly?

and what privilege are we talking about, BA had one good year and TW just signed a major contract not too long ago.. then wanted more money

CMC wanted more money too, Jimmy G had 1 good year before getting a huge contract so what's your point?

CMC's privilidge, what do you mean what privilidge are we talking about???
i have no idea where you are going with this.. You are the one bringing up privilege and talking about lying, but can't say what the lie is about ?

Now you're comparing Jimmy g half season to BA's 4 seasons.

CMC did show up for a few days in June
BA/TW took the entire offseason off

not the same

Baby sitter, water boy, O.C's son, head coaches son...???

Why do you keep bringing up priviledge (strawman tactic)??? I know folks are triggered by terms, but holy smokes!

What the lie is about?

I said how do you know CMC's dad wasn't lying, what do you mean I can't say what the lie is about???
like i said i don't where you are going with this

No other person would question CMCs rigorous offseason workout training nor lie about it.

Why question any of our players work ethic?
you are, saying his dad lied
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
Originally posted by glorydayz:
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
Originally posted by glorydayz:
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
Originally posted by glorydayz:
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
Originally posted by glorydayz:
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
Originally posted by glorydayz:
So how did B.A work himself into his current contract? By sitting on the couch???

B.A's dad didn't go on the radio to discuss his injury or offseason training so who knows what he did in the off season.

CMC, B.A, & Trent Williams all went about their contract business in the same manner and all ended the season on IR.

I see no difference in these players.
lol, BA and TW took the offseason off and it showed. CMC went through all of camp

that is not the same+

TW & BA were the best at their positions too, only they had to go to social media and hold out cause they didn't have the privlidge of having it handed to them. Luckily it worked out for them in the end, so they did what they had to do.
lying about what exactly?

and what privilege are we talking about, BA had one good year and TW just signed a major contract not too long ago.. then wanted more money

CMC wanted more money too, Jimmy G had 1 good year before getting a huge contract so what's your point?

CMC's privilidge, what do you mean what privilidge are we talking about???
i have no idea where you are going with this.. You are the one bringing up privilege and talking about lying, but can't say what the lie is about ?

Now you're comparing Jimmy g half season to BA's 4 seasons.

CMC did show up for a few days in June
BA/TW took the entire offseason off

not the same

Baby sitter, water boy, O.C's son, head coaches son...???

Why do you keep bringing up priviledge (strawman tactic)??? I know folks are triggered by terms, but holy smokes!

What the lie is about?

I said how do you know CMC's dad wasn't lying, what do you mean I can't say what the lie is about???
like i said i don't where you are going with this

No other person would question CMCs rigorous offseason workout training nor lie about it.

Why question any of our players work ethic?
you are, saying his dad lied

I'm saying two things:

1. How do you know CMC's dad didn't lie? (wouldn't be the first dad to tell a lie in favor of his son)
2. How do you know what B.A & T.W did in the off season? (You are assuming they didn't work as hard as CMC/Their dad's didn't speak to the media)

Quoting a players dad as fact isn't a good move IMO.
[ Edited by glorydayz on Jan 4, 2025 at 1:57 PM ]
Originally posted by glorydayz:
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
Originally posted by glorydayz:
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
Originally posted by glorydayz:
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
Originally posted by glorydayz:
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
Originally posted by glorydayz:
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
Originally posted by glorydayz:
So how did B.A work himself into his current contract? By sitting on the couch???

B.A's dad didn't go on the radio to discuss his injury or offseason training so who knows what he did in the off season.

CMC, B.A, & Trent Williams all went about their contract business in the same manner and all ended the season on IR.

I see no difference in these players.
lol, BA and TW took the offseason off and it showed. CMC went through all of camp

that is not the same+

TW & BA were the best at their positions too, only they had to go to social media and hold out cause they didn't have the privlidge of having it handed to them. Luckily it worked out for them in the end, so they did what they had to do.
lying about what exactly?

and what privilege are we talking about, BA had one good year and TW just signed a major contract not too long ago.. then wanted more money

CMC wanted more money too, Jimmy G had 1 good year before getting a huge contract so what's your point?

CMC's privilidge, what do you mean what privilidge are we talking about???
i have no idea where you are going with this.. You are the one bringing up privilege and talking about lying, but can't say what the lie is about ?

Now you're comparing Jimmy g half season to BA's 4 seasons.

CMC did show up for a few days in June
BA/TW took the entire offseason off

not the same

Baby sitter, water boy, O.C's son, head coaches son...???

Why do you keep bringing up priviledge (strawman tactic)??? I know folks are triggered by terms, but holy smokes!

What the lie is about?

I said how do you know CMC's dad wasn't lying, what do you mean I can't say what the lie is about???
like i said i don't where you are going with this

No other person would question CMCs rigorous offseason workout training nor lie about it.

Why question any of our players work ethic?
you are, saying his dad lied

I'm saying two things:

1. How do you know CMC's dad didn't lie? (wouldn't be the first dad to tell a lie in favor of his son)
2. How do you know what B.A & T.W did in the off season? (You are assuming they didn't work as hard as CMC/Their dad's didn't speak to the media)

Quoting a players dad as fact isn't a good move IMO.
1 His dad didn't say anything new, we all know CMC and it's why we don't need to question it
2 I'm sure TW/BA did their offseason regiment to their best, but that all stopped when camp started. The reason to hold out is to not get injured while negotiating for more money. Not being in camp is what hurt them at the start of the season.
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
Originally posted by glorydayz:
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
Originally posted by glorydayz:
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
Originally posted by glorydayz:
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
Originally posted by glorydayz:
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
Originally posted by glorydayz:
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
Originally posted by glorydayz:
So how did B.A work himself into his current contract? By sitting on the couch???

B.A's dad didn't go on the radio to discuss his injury or offseason training so who knows what he did in the off season.

CMC, B.A, & Trent Williams all went about their contract business in the same manner and all ended the season on IR.

I see no difference in these players.
lol, BA and TW took the offseason off and it showed. CMC went through all of camp

that is not the same+

TW & BA were the best at their positions too, only they had to go to social media and hold out cause they didn't have the privlidge of having it handed to them. Luckily it worked out for them in the end, so they did what they had to do.
lying about what exactly?

and what privilege are we talking about, BA had one good year and TW just signed a major contract not too long ago.. then wanted more money

CMC wanted more money too, Jimmy G had 1 good year before getting a huge contract so what's your point?

CMC's privilidge, what do you mean what privilidge are we talking about???
i have no idea where you are going with this.. You are the one bringing up privilege and talking about lying, but can't say what the lie is about ?

Now you're comparing Jimmy g half season to BA's 4 seasons.

CMC did show up for a few days in June
BA/TW took the entire offseason off

not the same

Baby sitter, water boy, O.C's son, head coaches son...???

Why do you keep bringing up priviledge (strawman tactic)??? I know folks are triggered by terms, but holy smokes!

What the lie is about?

I said how do you know CMC's dad wasn't lying, what do you mean I can't say what the lie is about???
like i said i don't where you are going with this

No other person would question CMCs rigorous offseason workout training nor lie about it.

Why question any of our players work ethic?
you are, saying his dad lied

I'm saying two things:

1. How do you know CMC's dad didn't lie? (wouldn't be the first dad to tell a lie in favor of his son)
2. How do you know what B.A & T.W did in the off season? (You are assuming they didn't work as hard as CMC/Their dad's didn't speak to the media)

Quoting a players dad as fact isn't a good move IMO.
1 His dad didn't say anything new, we all know CMC and it's why we don't need to question it
2 I'm sure TW/BA did their offseason regiment to their best, but that all stopped when camp started. The reason to hold out is to not get injured while negotiating for more money. Not being in camp is what hurt them at the start of the season.

I don't know anything, I just read whats out there.

What do you think B.A & T.W's fathers would say about their off season training? Have you seen TW training videos? Maybe that's why TW is always injured during the season, maybe he works harder than everyone else?
Originally posted by glorydayz:
I don't know anything, I just read whats out there.

What do you think B.A & T.W's fathers would say about their off season training? Have you seen TW training videos? Maybe that's why TW is always injured during the season, maybe he works harder than everyone else?
the question was asked why does CMC get a pass between CMC, BA & TW

CMC held out for a few days and was there for the entire Training camp and overworked himself.
BA/TW didn't train in camp and came out slow to begin the season

The reason CMC gets a pass, is because he showed up.
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
Originally posted by glorydayz:
I don't know anything, I just read whats out there.

What do you think B.A & T.W's fathers would say about their off season training? Have you seen TW training videos? Maybe that's why TW is always injured during the season, maybe he works harder than everyone else?
the question was asked why does CMC get a pass between CMC, BA & TW

CMC held out for a few days and was there for the entire Training camp and overworked himself.
BA/TW didn't train in camp and came out slow to begin the season

The reason CMC gets a pass, is because he showed up.

He showed up because the F/O paid him prior to camp starting, showing up was easy for him.

Priviledge
Originally posted by glorydayz:
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
Originally posted by glorydayz:
I don't know anything, I just read whats out there.

What do you think B.A & T.W's fathers would say about their off season training? Have you seen TW training videos? Maybe that's why TW is always injured during the season, maybe he works harder than everyone else?
the question was asked why does CMC get a pass between CMC, BA & TW

CMC held out for a few days and was there for the entire Training camp and overworked himself.
BA/TW didn't train in camp and came out slow to begin the season

The reason CMC gets a pass, is because he showed up.

He showed up because the F/O paid him prior to camp starting, showing up was easy for him.

Priviledge
that is not privilege lol
What can we get back if we traded cmc? Draft pick wise..
Originally posted by Bringbackedjr:
What can we get back if we traded cmc? Draft pick wise..

Good question, we traded a 2nd & 3rd for him right?
Originally posted by glorydayz:
Originally posted by Bringbackedjr:
What can we get back if we traded cmc? Draft pick wise..

Good question, we traded a 2nd & 3rd for him right?

I would take that for him now. We need the picks and we are deep at RB. Paying a dude to rehab is not a winning strategy. History dictates he will continue to miss significant time.
Originally posted by Bringbackedjr:
Originally posted by glorydayz:
Originally posted by Bringbackedjr:
What can we get back if we traded cmc? Draft pick wise..

Good question, we traded a 2nd & 3rd for him right?

I would take that for him now. We need the picks and we are deep at RB. Paying a dude to rehab is not a winning strategy. History dictates he will continue to miss significant time.

  • A-R-S
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 8,200
Originally posted by bmvanthiel:
Originally posted by A-R-S:
Can someone help me understand why fans hate Aiyuk for holding out / being bad / getting injured, but everyone is cool with what CMC did?

He handled his contract extension/raise like a man instead of a high school girl. Aiyuk and Deebo for example decided to play the whole social media, complain in the media/leak stuff, and teenager game where Trent, CMC, Bosa, etc. didn't so there's just more bitterness towards them w/their big deals.

This is very reasonable, but I am surprised more people don't suspect the potentially obvious: that he worked the 9ers over for more money knowing something wasn't right with his health
[ Edited by A-R-S on Jan 4, 2025 at 10:21 PM ]
I hope Lynch pulls rank on Kyle and moves forward with the mindset that CMC won't play that much next year.
We need a healthy CMC to make a super bowl run next year.
He is our second best player with kittle being one, I would hope he has one more good season left in him to make a superbowl run or why have him here
Search Share 49ersWebzone