Who holds this offense back more?

Originally posted by ninerfan818:
Kyle is the culprit. Jimmy is not great but with consistent play calling and these weapons at his disposal, no excuse for not being able to put up 28 a game.

Kyle is his own worst enemy most of the time. Gets in his own way and out smarts himself. The Chargers we're pretty banged up yet the wide receivers weren't able to do much.

I'm torn. I really wish Kyle could consistently call a better game. Keep defenses off balance and not be so predictable.

Give McDaniels Jimmy G as QB1 you would still get the same results 🤣
OH WAIT, McDaniels was here with Jimmy G as QB1 and still SB choke and NFCC fail just last season..

The clueless malcontent forty whiners will always be malcontents just like Jimmy G will never be a probowl QB and that is exactly why he is the highest paid backup QB in the NFL, too funny.. 🤣

Originally posted by ChillninDaBay:
Give McDaniels Jimmy G as QB1 you would still get the same results 🤣
OH WAIT, McDaniels was here with Jimmy G as QB1 and still SB choke and NFCC fail just last season..

The clueless malcontent forty whiners will always be malcontents just like Jimmy G will never be a probowl QB and that is exactly why he is the highest paid backup QB in the NFL, too funny.. 🤣

So McDaniels actually called plays while he was here? Interesting

Originally posted by krizay:

Originally posted by ChillninDaBay:
Give McDaniels Jimmy G as QB1 you would still get the same results 🤣
OH WAIT, McDaniels was here with Jimmy G as QB1 and still SB choke and NFCC fail just last season..

The clueless malcontent forty whiners will always be malcontents just like Jimmy G will never be a probowl QB and that is exactly why he is the highest paid backup QB in the NFL, too funny.. 🤣

So McDaniels actually called plays while he was here? Interesting

I was under the impression that Shanny called the plays. Not sure though

Originally posted by ninerfan818:
I was under the impression that Shanny called the plays. Not sure though

Oh he did! So him talking about what MM had and didn't have is moot. Though I failed to closely look at who I was replying to.

Originally posted by krizay:

Originally posted by ChillninDaBay:
Give McDaniels Jimmy G as QB1 you would still get the same results 🤣
OH WAIT, McDaniels was here with Jimmy G as QB1 and still SB choke and NFCC fail just last season..

The clueless malcontent forty whiners will always be malcontents just like Jimmy G will never be a probowl QB and that is exactly why he is the highest paid backup QB in the NFL, too funny.. 🤣

So McDaniels actually called plays while he was here? Interesting

He didn't make Jimmy G any better, how interesting is that? Too still complain when Jimmy is STILL QB1 is pretty ridiculous when everyone knows his limitations.

A win is a win in the NFL especially vs a 5-3 team, enjoy and move on or stay miserable because your life sucks and you are unhappy that's whole other issue no one can fix on a forum 🤣

Originally posted by krizay:

Originally posted by ninerfan818:
I was under the impression that Shanny called the plays. Not sure though

Oh he did! So him talking about what MM had and didn't have is moot. Though I failed to closely look at who I was replying to.

Not sure what you're getting at here. I just said I thought Shanahan called the offensive plays.

I don't know if MM called the plays or Shanny did. I always thought Shanny to be too much of a control freak to relinquish play calling. I don't know for sure though. I do think Kyle, if he is calling the plays needs some help in that dept.

Originally posted by 49ers81:
How about a little truth in advertising. Perhaps you should have just called this thread, "I got tired of sh*tting on Jimmy in his own thread so I'll start a new one"

Originally posted by ninerfan818:
Not sure what you're getting at here. I just said I thought Shanahan called the offensive plays.

I don't know if MM called the plays or Shanny did. I always thought Shanny to be too much of a control freak to relinquish play calling. I don't know for sure though. I do think Kyle, if he is calling the plays needs some help in that dept.

Was referring to Chillin

Originally posted by ChillninDaBay:
He didn't make Jimmy G any better, how interesting is that? Too still complain when Jimmy is STILL QB1 is pretty ridiculous when everyone knows his limitations.

A win is a win in the NFL especially vs a 5-3 team, enjoy and move on or stay miserable because your life sucks and you are unhappy that's whole other issue no one can fix on a forum 🤣

Originally posted by ninerfan818:

Originally posted by krizay:

Originally posted by ninerfan818:
I was under the impression that Shanny called the plays. Not sure though

Oh he did! So him talking about what MM had and didn't have is moot. Though I failed to closely look at who I was replying to.

Not sure what you're getting at here. I just said I thought Shanahan called the offensive plays.

I don't know if MM called the plays or Shanny did. I always thought Shanny to be too much of a control freak to relinquish play calling. I don't know for sure though. I do think Kyle, if he is calling the plays needs some help in that dept.

Nothing will change much on offense until Jimmy isn't QB1 anymore which will be 2023. So the malcontents either deal with it or keep whining to no avail 🤣
It is what it is, it will take a miracle and lots of luck to win the SB with Jimmy G at QB1 this season and a healthy team going forward wouldn't hurt the chances either but another playoff choke or SB choke isn't unlikely with Jimmy at QB1 regardless who is play calling and who is HC, KS McDaniels or even Bill Walsh himself whoever the f**k it really doesn't matter 🤣

Originally posted by krizay:

Originally posted by DonnieDarko:
david lombardi said that kyle needs to trust jimmy more now, and open up the passing game. that jimmy is playing great football and defenses are committing to stop the run. i tend to agree with this. if we pass to set up the run more, there will then be a point where we can strike that perfect balance in time for the playoffs.

Exactly how I feel. Though not sure I'd say great. Nonetheless I think this is the best version of Jimmy we've had.

I'd like to see that! I think if we get a chance to pull 2 or 3 games ahead, KS would let him throw a bit.

Originally posted by krizay:

Originally posted by ChillninDaBay:
Give McDaniels Jimmy G as QB1 you would still get the same results 🤣
OH WAIT, McDaniels was here with Jimmy G as QB1 and still SB choke and NFCC fail just last season..

The clueless malcontent forty whiners will always be malcontents just like Jimmy G will never be a probowl QB and that is exactly why he is the highest paid backup QB in the NFL, too funny.. 🤣

So McDaniels actually called plays while he was here? Interesting

Who the f**k is McDaniels? The raiders coach

Originally posted by 49ers_Life:
Who the f**k is McDaniels? The raiders coach

Dolphins head coach

The O-line

Originally posted by Bay2Bay9erAllday:

Originally posted by 49ers81:
How about a little truth in advertising. Perhaps you should have just called this thread, "I got tired of sh*tting on Jimmy in his own thread so I'll start a new one"

Well considering the results is 50/50 so far with 86 votes. Kyle and Jimmy are equally being "s**t on".

Edit: not to mention I've praised Jimmy for his game against the Falcons, Panthers, and Rams. But you can lie and say I didn't if that suits your "everyone's mean to Jimmy narrative" while ignoring half of the webzone thinks Kyle is as much to blame.