Is the season over without Jimmy G?

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by NotAFinga42:
Agreed. But what if he reaches 100%? It's obviously a long shot, but Kyle did leave the door open, saying
"I haven't been told there's a chance, so I think things would have to be pretty drastic," Well, things are pretty drastic. I wouldn't consider it for a second if he wasn't 100%, but what if he is?

Bro his foot was 90 degrees pointing out. He ain't gonna be 100% to play NFL football this year.

Originally posted by Wubbie:
Honestly, Purdy is probably a better QB at this point than Lance right NOW, having more overall football experience and having a full season of scout-team reps... while Trey has been rehabbing all year.

Obviously, assuming we roll into 2023 with Lance and Purdy as QB1 and QB2, you go back to the plan of having Lance as the long-term starter, but as of right NOW, even if Trey can get medically cleared, Purdy gives us the best shot.

Originally posted by Youngone:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by NotAFinga42:
Agreed. But what if he reaches 100%? It's obviously a long shot, but Kyle did leave the door open, saying
"I haven't been told there's a chance, so I think things would have to be pretty drastic," Well, things are pretty drastic. I wouldn't consider it for a second if he wasn't 100%, but what if he is?

Bro his foot was 90 degrees pointing out. He ain't gonna be 100% to play NFL football this year.

Kyle literally said yesterday that Lance can't come back this season. Time to hitch onto the Purdy Porsche and race to the SB

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by NotAFinga42:
Agreed. But what if he reaches 100%? It's obviously a long shot, but Kyle did leave the door open, saying
"I haven't been told there's a chance, so I think things would have to be pretty drastic," Well, things are pretty drastic. I wouldn't consider it for a second if he wasn't 100%, but what if he is?

Bro his foot was 90 degrees pointing out. He ain't gonna be 100% to play NFL football this year.

Originally posted by Youngone:
Kyle literally said yesterday that Lance can't come back this season. Time to hitch onto the Purdy Porsche and race to the SB

Originally posted by Youngone:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by NotAFinga42:
Agreed. But what if he reaches 100%? It's obviously a long shot, but Kyle did leave the door open, saying
"I haven't been told there's a chance, so I think things would have to be pretty drastic," Well, things are pretty drastic. I wouldn't consider it for a second if he wasn't 100%, but what if he is?

Bro his foot was 90 degrees pointing out. He ain't gonna be 100% to play NFL football this year.

Kyle literally said yesterday that Lance can't come back this season. Time to hitch onto the Purdy Porsche and race to the SB

Originally posted by Waterbear:
While I agree with this... hypothetically now, wouldn't you feel better with Lance as our backup to Purdy rn over Josh Johnson?

I've been on the "let Trey rest until 2023" bandwagon but the injury to Jimmy makes me question that a little bit.

Just playing devils advocate because I'd still shut him down for the year.

Originally posted by NotAFinga42:
I guess I missed that. Where can I find it?

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Kyle Shanahan on Baker Mayfield in 2019:

"I love that type of person. You can tell football means everything to him. He's going to give everything he has….I think he's a very good player. I loved him coming out of college." pic.twitter.com/W8nIzAE8fw

— Kyle Brandt (@KyleBrandt) December 5, 2022

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by NotAFinga42:
I guess I missed that. Where can I find it?

After game transcript

Originally posted by NotAFinga42:

Originally posted by Youngone:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by NotAFinga42:
Agreed. But what if he reaches 100%? It's obviously a long shot, but Kyle did leave the door open, saying
"I haven't been told there's a chance, so I think things would have to be pretty drastic," Well, things are pretty drastic. I wouldn't consider it for a second if he wasn't 100%, but what if he is?

Bro his foot was 90 degrees pointing out. He ain't gonna be 100% to play NFL football this year.

Kyle literally said yesterday that Lance can't come back this season. Time to hitch onto the Purdy Porsche and race to the SB

I guess I missed that. Where can I find it?

Originally posted by NotAFinga42:

Originally posted by DonnieDarko:
you grab baker and use him as insurance if purdy s**ts the bed, its all we can do at this point

I still think there has to be serious discussions about whether or not Trey could be healthy by the playoffs. I realize Kyle has shot that down, but find it hard to believe it's not a consideration behind the scenes.

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by Wubbie:
Honestly, Purdy is probably a better QB at this point than Lance right NOW, having more overall football experience and having a full season of scout-team reps... while Trey has been rehabbing all year.

Obviously, assuming we roll into 2023 with Lance and Purdy as QB1 and QB2, you go back to the plan of having Lance as the long-term starter, but as of right NOW, even if Trey can get medically cleared, Purdy gives us the best shot.

Nah disagree there. Scout team reps are pointless. s**t doesn't help a QB learn their offense. It's all predetermined play calls and reads that he has to make (based on the QB he's trying to be) and the scout QB does is give the defense looks.

if anything he's just in better shape and doesn't have a broke ankle.

Originally posted by Wubbie:
The larger point is that Purdy has been practicing, throwing, getting reps all year, while Trey would be coming in to high-level playoff football and has to shake off rust.