Is the season over without Jimmy G?

Originally posted by PRIMETIME21:

Originally posted by brodiebluebanaszak:
ya its over. well have a couple more good games, but eventually the scouts will do their job on purdy. this is the mullin situation all over again

pretty much

Agreed

Originally posted by Ark49er:

Originally posted by 49ersRing:
It was over when Trey went down. Maybe Purdy can change my mind.

???

Dont you know we're 0-12. No playoff hopes. Season ended week two.

to answer he question, he'll no it's not over.

Originally posted by Ark49er:

Originally posted by 49ersRing:
It was over when Trey went down. Maybe Purdy can change my mind.

???

And people get upset when the term "Jimmy Hater" gets thrown around

Originally posted by Niners99:
I didn't see Jimmy do anything Purdy didn't do today. Nothing changes. We will go as far as our skill position guys and defense will take us.

This was my initial thought as well.

Originally posted by Bay2Bay9erAllday:

Originally posted by Ark49er:

Originally posted by 49ersRing:
It was over when Trey went down. Maybe Purdy can change my mind.

???

Dont you know we're 0-12. No playoff hopes. Season ended week two.

The season is "over" when there is no longer a realistic chance to win the Super Bowl. We have seen this story with Jimmy enough times to know how it'd end and that's exactly what happened. It doesn't mean I'm not a fan of Jimmy as a person and it doesn't mean I don't see him as a top 10-15 QB when healthy, but it is what it is.

I wasn't confident in us winning the SB with Trey either, but there was at least hope he'd develop as the season went along.

Originally posted by Bay2Bay9erAllday:
Dont you know we're 0-12. No playoff hopes. Season ended week two.

to answer he question, he'll no it's not over.

It was over when Trey went down. This season was all about developing him. Jimmy wasn't gonna lead this team to the promise land. Not with his play and not with his injury history.

Originally posted by JoseCortez:

Originally posted by PRIMETIME21:

Originally posted by brodiebluebanaszak:
ya its over. well have a couple more good games, but eventually the scouts will do their job on purdy. this is the mullin situation all over again

pretty much

Agreed

Maybe. Mullens couldn't handle the pressure. They are different people though. You never know.

You got Brady and Warner as exceptions. Purdy could be one. We don't know yet.

Was anyone shocked or surprised Jimmy's injury is season ending? I've become so numb to injuries I just took it in stride. I had no feeling at all

Reading through this maybe I'm confused. By the OP asking if the season is over; that includes the postseason?

it's sick to me how many people are doing victory laps on this injury news. 'we all knew how it'd end'. when jimmy took that awkward hit against the saints to his leg, i'm sure all these losers were ready to hop on twitter with injury memes and were disappointed when he got back up and won the game. qb's get hit in the nfl, it happens. the way jimmy got rolled up on there could have happened to anyone. it sucks for him and the team, and no one can predict an injury like that occuring.

if the niners goal was a super bowl win, the season is probably over barring a miracle. if there's any team in the league that can mask mediocre qb play, though, it's this one.

Originally posted by Silky:
Was anyone shocked or surprised Jimmy's injury is season ending? I've become so numb to injuries I just took it in stride. I had no feeling at all

Not to harp on it,....but his attitude for that hit he got in the game last week vs. NO told me that his mentality has not really changed on this stuff. Complaining about guys that he knows are going to go hunting either way.

I would've loved to hear "you know what,...I just gotta go back to getting rid of that thing when a defender's heat seeking" instead.

But he's a former linebacker, right? So he is who he is.

Originally posted by 49ers808:
Reading through this maybe I'm confused. By the OP asking if the season is over; that includes the postseason?

Season isn't over. We'll still make the playoffs.

any chance at a SB berth is officially over…

Originally posted by 49ersRing:

Originally posted by Bay2Bay9erAllday:

Originally posted by Ark49er:

Originally posted by 49ersRing:
It was over when Trey went down. Maybe Purdy can change my mind.

???

Dont you know we're 0-12. No playoff hopes. Season ended week two.

The season is "over"

Stopped reading right there. Only thing established is you're definitely not a faithful lol

Originally posted by JDTical:
it's sick to me how many people are doing victory laps on this injury news. 'we all knew how it'd end'. when jimmy took that awkward hit against the saints to his leg, i'm sure all these losers were ready to hop on twitter with injury memes and were disappointed when he got back up and won the game. qb's get hit in the nfl, it happens. the way jimmy got rolled up on there could have happened to anyone. it sucks for him and the team, and no one can predict an injury like that occuring.

if the niners goal was a super bowl win, the season is probably over barring a miracle. if there's any team in the league that can mask mediocre qb play, though, it's this one.

I don't think anyone is taking victory laps. I think the thought is that Jimmy will eventually disappoint, either by his play or getting injured. It's been the story of his NFL career. Sad that is how he leaves this team…

Originally posted by DrEll:

Originally posted by 49ers808:
Reading through this maybe I'm confused. By the OP asking if the season is over; that includes the postseason?

Season isn't over. We'll still make the playoffs.

any chance at a SB berth is officially over…

See this I agree with and makes more sense to me. Maybe it's just me