Deebo versus Aiyuk

Originally posted by YACBros85:

Originally posted by thl408:
The more to the right, the more frequently the WR is "open". The more up, the more that WR is targeted. I think 'Open' is subjective. Whatever, the dots are pretty.

🔸Targets per Route (y) vs ESPN Open Score (x) pic.twitter.com/TeKzbtWrXG

— NFL Prospect Clips (@NflProspectClip) January 14, 2023

So that makes him top 5 in getting open?

Based on that chart that I don't know where it came from, yes. BA's dot looks slightly ahead of Tyreek's.

Comparing Aiyuk to Boldin and Wayne seems premature as far as game impact. He runs crisp routes and can block. Deebo might be the best open field playmaker in the game. I'll take him.

This shouldn't even be a question, Deebo easily. Game changer. Finding a big slow WR with brick hands isn't that hard. DO NOT PAY AIYUK. Just draft a couple more kids, keep those contracts small.

Originally posted by thl408:
The more to the right, the more frequently the WR is "open". The more up, the more that WR is targeted. I think 'Open' is subjective. Whatever, the dots are pretty.

🔸Targets per Route (y) vs ESPN Open Score (x) pic.twitter.com/TeKzbtWrXG

— NFL Prospect Clips (@NflProspectClip) January 14, 2023

Lol Russel Wilson really was bad

Originally posted by WINiner:
I like Aiyuk the person more, but I like Deebo the player better.

Agree. I really like Aiyuk. Tough call but if I had to choose, Deebs.

Originally posted by 9erReign:
This shouldn't even be a question, Deebo easily. Game changer. Finding a big slow WR with brick hands isn't that hard. DO NOT PAY AIYUK. Just draft a couple more kids, keep those contracts small.

Brick hands? Deebo has a career drop rate of 10.5% while Aiyuk has a 6.3% drop rate. Folks on this board love making s**t up.

Deebo is great at making things happen with the ball in his hands but most of his plays come off of screens, slants and dump offs. His average ADOT is 6.4 yards and this season was even less at 5.1 yards. Aiyuk on the other hand has a career ADOT of 10.5 yards and was even higher this past season at 11.1. Truth is, they are completely different players and we need both of them in this offense.

If you want a sb this next year, you keep Deebo. If Brock ends up as the man we don't need 2 aging horizontal dudes. CMC stays. More downfield Aiyuk type receivers. They are fantastic at finding Deebo type guys in the draft. The CAP runs the show.

I mean we ain't losing either this yr so whatever. they will pickup BA's 5th yr option so we got two more seasons there.

Deebo is one of it not the best playmakers in the league. When's he's got the ball in his hands good things happen.

BA is a better pure WR as far as getting open. Both complement each other and this offense. What we need is Gray to get with the program.

Originally posted by NYniner85:
I mean we ain't losing either this yr so whatever. they will pickup BA's 5th yr option so we got two more seasons there.

Deebo is one of it not the best playmakers in the league. When's he's got the ball in his hands good things happen.

BA is a better pure WR as far as getting open. Both complement each other and this offense. What we need is Gray to get with the program.

Deebp and Aiyuk compliment each other as each was different strengths. Deebo just gets beat up too much because of his style. That's why getting CMC was so big. If hew misses a game or 2 CMC can fill his roll.

https://www.ninersnation.com/2023/2/16/23602244/49ers-patriots-deebo-samuel-trade

DO IT

Originally posted by dmax:
https://www.ninersnation.com/2023/2/16/23602244/49ers-patriots-deebo-samuel-trade

DO IT

There's zero chance the 9ers trade Deebo a season after handing him a big contract.

Originally posted by Sickaa:

Originally posted by dmax:
https://www.ninersnation.com/2023/2/16/23602244/49ers-patriots-deebo-samuel-trade

DO IT

There's zero chance the 9ers trade Deebo a season after handing him a big contract.

They're sniffing, doesn't mean Niners have any interest.

If that was ever a choice it was made when Deebo signed. Dead money dictates he's not going anywhere. Let's hope without contract issues this off-season both come back their best ever. I'd draft any WR that falls to them as a value at any point. Next year might be the better year to draft an Aiyuk replacement. Purdy also allows the freedom to keep BA. He'll be 17m on his 5th year option and to me he's not worth 17m. Love the kid, nice player, but could Jennings get you 70/1000 with the same target share? Is Jennings production replaceable?

Deebo to me is a force multiplier who makes everyone better. Just my opinion.

Originally posted by davidboutte:
If that was ever a choice it was made when Deebo signed. Dead money dictates he's not going anywhere. Let's hope without contract issues this off-season both come back their best ever. I'd draft any WR that falls to them as a value at any point. Next year might be the better year to draft an Aiyuk replacement. Purdy also allows the freedom to keep BA. He'll be 17m on his 5th year option and to me he's not worth 17m. Love the kid, nice player, but could Jennings get you 70/1000 with the same target share? Is Jennings production replaceable?

Deebo to me is a force multiplier who makes everyone better. Just my opinion.

He can run and catch. Not many in the league can match that.

Originally posted by davidboutte:
If that was ever a choice it was made when Deebo signed. Dead money dictates he's not going anywhere. Let's hope without contract issues this off-season both come back their best ever. I'd draft any WR that falls to them as a value at any point. Next year might be the better year to draft an Aiyuk replacement. Purdy also allows the freedom to keep BA. He'll be 17m on his 5th year option and to me he's not worth 17m. Love the kid, nice player, but could Jennings get you 70/1000 with the same target share? Is Jennings production replaceable?

Deebo to me is a force multiplier who makes everyone better. Just my opinion.

I sure am glad fans on this board aren't running the show.