There are 359 users in the forums

How would you rank the roster in tiers, like stars, role players, etc....

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Apr 16, 2023 at 12:24 PM
Like the title says, how would you rank the current 66 players, which I'll list below with their cap number, except Hyder, since it's not known, as he hasn't officially signed the deal.

  1. QB 5 Trey Lance(2024)- $9,301,434
  2. QB 13 Brock Purdy(2025)- $889,253
  3. QB 14 Sam Darnold(2023)- $5,111,765
  4. RB 23 Christian McCaffrey(2025)- $12,000,000
  5. RB 25 Elijah Mitchell(2024)- $985,893
  6. RB 32 Tyrion Davis-Price(2025)- $1,161,033
  7. RB 24 Jordan Mason(2024)- $873,333
  8. FB 44 Kyle Juszczyk(2025)- $6,565,221
  9. WR 19 Deebo Samuel(2025)- $8,653,529
  10. WR 11 Brandon Aiyuk(2023)- $3,987,248
  11. WR 15 Jauan Jennings(2023)- $940,000
  12. WR/KR/PR 3 Ray-Ray McCloud III(2023)- $2,090,000
  13. WR 6 Danny Gray(2025)- $1,146,569
  14. WR 86 Tay Martin(2023)- $750,000
  15. WR 84 Dazz Newsome(2023)- $870,000
  16. WR – Tyron Johnson(2023)- $1,010,000
  17. TE 85 George Kittle(2025)- $18,033,751
  18. TE 89 Charlie Woerner(2023)- $1,055,258
  19. TE 82 Ross Dwelley(2023)- $1,080,000
  20. C 64 Jake Brendel(2026)- $2,272,000
  21. C – Jon Feliciano(2023)- $2,250,000
  22. C 67 Keith Ismael(2023)- $940,000
  23. LG 65 Aaron Banks(2024)- $1,929,166
  24. LG 63 Nick Zakelj(2025)- $917,590
  25. RG 74 Spencer Burford(2025)- $1,038,014
  26. RG 62 Jason Poe(2023)- $750,000
  27. LT 71 Trent Williams(2026)- $27,227,424
  28. LT – Matt Pryor(2023)- $990,000
  29. LT 78 Leroy Watson(2023)- $750,000
  30. RT 68 Colton McKivitz(2024)- $1,515,412
  31. RT 76 Jaylon Moore(2024)- $1,020,759
  32. RT 77 Alfredo Gutierrez(2023)- $750,000
  33. DE 97 Nick Bosa(2023)- $17,859,000
  34. DE/DT 92 Kerry Hyder Jr.(2023)-
  35. DE 95 Drake Jackson(2025)- $1,339,180
  36. DE 94 Clelin Ferrell(2023)- $2,460,000
  37. DE 58 Alex Barrett(2023)- $870,000
  38. DE — Austin Bryant(2023)- $965,000
  39. DT 91 Arik Armstead(2024)- $23,755,883
  40. DT 90 Kevin Givens(2023)- $2,000,000
  41. DT/NT 99 Javon Kinlaw(2023)- $4,928,223
  42. DT/NT 96 T.Y. McGill Jr.(2023)- $940,000
  43. NT/DT 98 Javon Hargrave(2026)- $6,555,000
  44. NT 93 Kalia Davis(2025)- $783,003
  45. SLB 45 Demetrius Flannigan-Fowles(2023)- $1,825,000
  46. SLB 40 Marcelino McCrary-Ball(2023)- $750,000
  47. WLB 57 Dre Greenlaw(2024)- $5,648,558
  48. WLB 59 Curtis Robinson(2023)- $940,000
  49. MLB 54 Fred Warner(2026)- $9,049,000
  50. MLB 48 Oren Burks(2023)- $2,773,000
  51. CB 7 Charvarius Ward(2024)- $6,421,000
  52. CB 20 Ambry Thomas(2024)- $1,305,232
  53. CB 38 Deommodore Lenoir(2024)- $1,011,217
  54. CB – Isaiah Oliver(2024)- $1,686,000
  55. CB 26 Samuel Womack III(2025)- $940,831
  56. CB 43 Qwuantrezz Knight(2023)- $750,000
  57. CB – A.J. Parker(2023)- $940,000
  58. CB – Tre Swilling(2023)- $750,000
  59. FS 31 Tashaun Gipson Sr.(2023)- $2,100,000
  60. FS 41 Tayler Hawkins(2023)- $750,000
  61. FS – Myles Hartsfield(2023)- $1,010,000
  62. SS 29 Talanoa Hufanga(2024)- $1,000,038
  63. SS 30 George Odum(2024)- $2,340,000
  64. PK — Zane Gonzalez(2023)- $1,465,000
  65. P 18 Mitch Wishnowsky(2026)- $1,700,000
  66. LS 46 Taybor Pepper(2025)- $1,225,000
Apr 16, 2023 at 1:01 PM
Originally posted by AB81Rules:
Like the title says, how would you rank the current 66 players, which I'll list below with their cap number, except Hyder, since it's not known, as he hasn't officially signed the deal.

  1. QB 5 Trey Lance(2024)- $9,301,434. 2nd tier based on insufficient info
  2. QB 13 Brock Purdy(2025)- $889,253. Stud
  3. QB 14 Sam Darnold(2023)- $5,111,765. 3rd tier, unfortunately
  4. RB 23 Christian McCaffrey(2025)- $12,000,000. Stud
  5. RB 25 Elijah Mitchell(2024)- $985,893. Stud
  6. RB 32 Tyrion Davis-Price(2025)- $1,161,033. 2nd tier
  7. RB 24 Jordan Mason(2024)- $873,333. 2nd tier
  8. FB 44 Kyle Juszczyk(2025)- $6,565,221. Stud
  9. WR 19 Deebo Samuel(2025)- $8,653,529. Stud
  10. WR 11 Brandon Aiyuk(2023)- $3,987,248. Stud
  11. WR 15 Jauan Jennings(2023)- $940,000. Stud
  12. WR/KR/PR 3 Ray-Ray McCloud III(2023)- $2,090,000. Tier 1, I hope
  13. WR 6 Danny Gray(2025)- $1,146,569. Tier 1, I hope
  14. WR 86 Tay Martin(2023)- $750,000. Tier 2
  15. WR 84 Dazz Newsome(2023)- $870,000. Tier 3, insufficiency info
  16. WR – Tyron Johnson(2023)- $1,010,000. "". 3. "
  17. TE 85 George Kittle(2025)- $18,033,751. Stud
  18. TE 89 Charlie Woerner(2023)- $1,055,258. Tier 1.5
  19. TE 82 Ross Dwelley(2023)- $1,080,000. Tier 1
  20. C 64 Jake Brendel(2026)- $2,272,000. Tier 1
  21. C – Jon Feliciano(2023)- $2,250,000. Tier 3. Insuff info
  22. C 67 Keith Ismael(2023)- $940,000. ". 3. ". "
  23. LG 65 Aaron Banks(2024)- $1,929,166. Tier 1
  24. LG 63 Nick Zakelj(2025)- $917,590 Tier 2. Insuff. Info
  25. RG 74 Spencer Burford(2025)- $1,038,014. Tier 1
  26. RG 62 Jason Poe(2023)- $750,000. Tier 1.5
  27. LT 71 Trent Williams(2026)- $27,227,424
  28. LT – Matt Pryor(2023)- $990,000. Insuff info
  29. LT 78 Leroy Watson(2023)- $750,000 Insuff info
  30. RT 68 Colton McKivitz(2024)- $1,515,412. Tier 1.5
  31. RT 76 Jaylon Moore(2024)- $1,020,759. Tier 1 I hope
  32. RT 77 Alfredo Gutierrez(2023)- $750,000. Tier3 Insuff info
  33. DE 97 Nick Bosa(2023)- $17,859,000. Studly stud
  34. DE/DT 92 Kerry Hyder Jr.(2023)- stud
  35. DE 95 Drake Jackson(2025)- $1,339,180. Tier 1.5
  36. DE 94 Clelin Ferrell(2023)- $2,460,000. Tier2 Insuff info
  37. DE 58 Alex Barrett(2023)- $870,000. Insuff info
  38. DE — Austin Bryant(2023)- $965,000. Insuff info
  39. DT 91 Arik Armstead(2024)- $23,755,883. Stud
  40. DT 90 Kevin Givens(2023)- $2,000,000. Stud
  41. DT/NT 99 Javon Kinlaw(2023)- $4,928,223. Insuff info
  42. DT/NT 96 T.Y. McGill Jr.(2023)- $940,000. Tier 2 Insuff info
  43. NT/DT 98 Javon Hargrave(2026)- $6,555,000. Stud
  44. NT 93 Kalia Davis(2025)- $783,003. Tier 3
  45. SLB 45 Demetrius Flannigan-Fowles(2023)- $1,825,000. Tier2 Insuff info
  46. SLB 40 Marcelino McCrary-Ball(2023)- $750,000. Tier 2-3 Insuff info
  47. WLB 57 Dre Greenlaw(2024)- $5,648,558. Stud
  48. WLB 59 Curtis Robinson(2023)- $940,000. Insuff info
  49. MLB 54 Fred Warner(2026)- $9,049,000. Stud
  50. MLB 48 Oren Burks(2023)- $2,773,000. Tier 1.5 but coming on
  51. CB 7 Charvarius Ward(2024)- $6,421,000. Tier 1
  52. CB 20 Ambry Thomas(2024)- $1,305,232. Tier 2.5 unfortunately
  53. CB 38 Deommodore Lenoir(2024)- $1,011,217. Stud
  54. CB – Isaiah Oliver(2024)- $1,686,000. Insuff info
  55. CB 26 Samuel Womack III(2025)- $940,831. Tier 1.5
  56. CB 43 Qwuantrezz Knight(2023)- $750,000. Tier 2 Insuff info
  57. CB – A.J. Parker(2023)- $940,000. Insuff info
  58. CB – Tre Swilling(2023)- $750,000. Insuff info
  59. FS 31 Tashaun Gipson Sr.(2023)- $2,100,000. Tier 1, sometimes tier 2
  60. FS 41 Tayler Hawkins(2023)- $750,000. Insuff info
  61. FS – Myles Hartsfield(2023)- $1,010,000 ". "
  62. SS 29 Talanoa Hufanga(2024)- $1,000,038. Stud
  63. SS 30 George Odum(2024)- $2,340,000. Tier 1.5, but coming on
  64. PK — Zane Gonzalez(2023)- $1,465,000. Insuff info
  65. P 18 Mitch Wishnowsky(2026)- $1,700,000. Stud
  66. LS 46 Taybor Pepper(2025)- $1,225,000. Tier 1

tier 1 and Stud are self explanatory…the insufficient info just relates to me, as i have not enough or no info on those players. Tier 2 self explanatory, and tier 1.5 means close to tier 1 but not yet quite there. Tier 3s are self explanatory, but there are very few.

that comes close to 26 studs/tier 1 and half a dozen 1.5s. That seems like a huge number of studs to me, but it is no secret our team is stacked except for ?? At QB, as well as ?? Along the OL…the OL is promising however. The insufficient infos, may very well have another dozen, perhaps even two, but i am just not familiar enough with them. The gravedigger, that was a no brainer as i have seen plenty of him.
[ Edited by pasodoc9er on Apr 16, 2023 at 1:08 PM ]
Apr 16, 2023 at 1:05 PM
Originally posted by pasodoc9er:
Originally posted by AB81Rules:
Like the title says, how would you rank the current 66 players, which I'll list below with their cap number, except Hyder, since it's not known, as he hasn't officially signed the deal.

  1. QB 5 Trey Lance(2024)- $9,301,434. 2nd tier based on insufficient info
  2. QB 13 Brock Purdy(2025)- $889,253. Stud
  3. QB 14 Sam Darnold(2023)- $5,111,765. 3rd tier, unfortunately
  4. RB 23 Christian McCaffrey(2025)- $12,000,000. Stud
  5. RB 25 Elijah Mitchell(2024)- $985,893. Stud
  6. RB 32 Tyrion Davis-Price(2025)- $1,161,033. 2nd tier
  7. RB 24 Jordan Mason(2024)- $873,333. 2nd tier
  8. FB 44 Kyle Juszczyk(2025)- $6,565,221. Stud
  9. WR 19 Deebo Samuel(2025)- $8,653,529. Stud
  10. WR 11 Brandon Aiyuk(2023)- $3,987,248. Stud
  11. WR 15 Jauan Jennings(2023)- $940,000. Stud
  12. WR/KR/PR 3 Ray-Ray McCloud III(2023)- $2,090,000. Tier 1, I hope
  13. WR 6 Danny Gray(2025)- $1,146,569. Tier 1, I hope
  14. WR 86 Tay Martin(2023)- $750,000. Tier 2
  15. WR 84 Dazz Newsome(2023)- $870,000. Tier 3, insufficiency info
  16. WR – Tyron Johnson(2023)- $1,010,000. "". 3. "
  17. TE 85 George Kittle(2025)- $18,033,751. Stud
  18. TE 89 Charlie Woerner(2023)- $1,055,258. Tier 1.5
  19. TE 82 Ross Dwelley(2023)- $1,080,000. Tier 1
  20. C 64 Jake Brendel(2026)- $2,272,000. Tier 1
  21. C – Jon Feliciano(2023)- $2,250,000. Tier 3. Insuff info
  22. C 67 Keith Ismael(2023)- $940,000. ". 3. ". "
  23. LG 65 Aaron Banks(2024)- $1,929,166. Tier 1
  24. LG 63 Nick Zakelj(2025)- $917,590 Tier 2. Insuff. Info
  25. RG 74 Spencer Burford(2025)- $1,038,014. Tier 1
  26. RG 62 Jason Poe(2023)- $750,000. Tier 1.5
  27. LT 71 Trent Williams(2026)- $27,227,424
  28. LT – Matt Pryor(2023)- $990,000. Insuff info
  29. LT 78 Leroy Watson(2023)- $750,000 Insuff info
  30. RT 68 Colton McKivitz(2024)- $1,515,412. Tier 1.5
  31. RT 76 Jaylon Moore(2024)- $1,020,759. Tier 1 I hope
  32. RT 77 Alfredo Gutierrez(2023)- $750,000. Tier3 Insuff info
  33. DE 97 Nick Bosa(2023)- $17,859,000. Studly stud
  34. DE/DT 92 Kerry Hyder Jr.(2023)- stud
  35. DE 95 Drake Jackson(2025)- $1,339,180. Tier 1.5
  36. DE 94 Clelin Ferrell(2023)- $2,460,000. Tier2 Insuff info
  37. DE 58 Alex Barrett(2023)- $870,000. Insuff info
  38. DE — Austin Bryant(2023)- $965,000. Insuff info
  39. DT 91 Arik Armstead(2024)- $23,755,883. Stud
  40. DT 90 Kevin Givens(2023)- $2,000,000. Stud
  41. DT/NT 99 Javon Kinlaw(2023)- $4,928,223. Insuff info
  42. DT/NT 96 T.Y. McGill Jr.(2023)- $940,000. Tier 2 Insuff info
  43. NT/DT 98 Javon Hargrave(2026)- $6,555,000. Stud
  44. NT 93 Kalia Davis(2025)- $783,003. Tier 3
  45. SLB 45 Demetrius Flannigan-Fowles(2023)- $1,825,000. Tier2 Insuff info
  46. SLB 40 Marcelino McCrary-Ball(2023)- $750,000. Tier 2-3 Insuff info
  47. WLB 57 Dre Greenlaw(2024)- $5,648,558. Stud
  48. WLB 59 Curtis Robinson(2023)- $940,000. Insuff info
  49. MLB 54 Fred Warner(2026)- $9,049,000. Stud
  50. MLB 48 Oren Burks(2023)- $2,773,000. Tier 1.5 but coming on
  51. CB 7 Charvarius Ward(2024)- $6,421,000. Tier 1
  52. CB 20 Ambry Thomas(2024)- $1,305,232. Tier 2.5 unfortunately
  53. CB 38 Deommodore Lenoir(2024)- $1,011,217. Stud
  54. CB – Isaiah Oliver(2024)- $1,686,000. Insuff info
  55. CB 26 Samuel Womack III(2025)- $940,831. Tier 1.5
  56. CB 43 Qwuantrezz Knight(2023)- $750,000. Tier 2 Insuff info
  57. CB – A.J. Parker(2023)- $940,000. Insuff info
  58. CB – Tre Swilling(2023)- $750,000. Insuff info
  59. FS 31 Tashaun Gipson Sr.(2023)- $2,100,000. Tier 1, sometimes tier 2
  60. FS 41 Tayler Hawkins(2023)- $750,000. Insuff info
  61. FS – Myles Hartsfield(2023)- $1,010,000 ". "
  62. SS 29 Talanoa Hufanga(2024)- $1,000,038. Stud
  63. SS 30 George Odum(2024)- $2,340,000. Tier 1.5, but coming on
  64. PK — Zane Gonzalez(2023)- $1,465,000. Insuff info
  65. P 18 Mitch Wishnowsky(2026)- $1,700,000. Stud
  66. LS 46 Taybor Pepper(2025)- $1,225,000. Tier 1

tier 1 and Stud are self explanatory…the insufficient info just relates to me, as i have not enough or no info on those players. Tier 2 self explanatory, and tier 1.5 means close to tier 1 but not yet quite there. Tier 3s are self explanatory, but there are very few.

I like it, but you missed Trent, he has to GOD TIER no one else as good as him at LT IMO.
Apr 16, 2023 at 1:18 PM
Originally posted by AB81Rules:
Originally posted by pasodoc9er:
Originally posted by AB81Rules:
Like the title says, how would you rank the current 66 players, which I'll list below with their cap number, except Hyder, since it's not known, as he hasn't officially signed the deal.

  1. QB 5 Trey Lance(2024)- $9,301,434. 2nd tier based on insufficient info
  2. QB 13 Brock Purdy(2025)- $889,253. Stud
  3. QB 14 Sam Darnold(2023)- $5,111,765. 3rd tier, unfortunately
  4. RB 23 Christian McCaffrey(2025)- $12,000,000. Stud
  5. RB 25 Elijah Mitchell(2024)- $985,893. Stud
  6. RB 32 Tyrion Davis-Price(2025)- $1,161,033. 2nd tier
  7. RB 24 Jordan Mason(2024)- $873,333. 2nd tier
  8. FB 44 Kyle Juszczyk(2025)- $6,565,221. Stud
  9. WR 19 Deebo Samuel(2025)- $8,653,529. Stud
  10. WR 11 Brandon Aiyuk(2023)- $3,987,248. Stud
  11. WR 15 Jauan Jennings(2023)- $940,000. Stud
  12. WR/KR/PR 3 Ray-Ray McCloud III(2023)- $2,090,000. Tier 1, I hope
  13. WR 6 Danny Gray(2025)- $1,146,569. Tier 1, I hope
  14. WR 86 Tay Martin(2023)- $750,000. Tier 2
  15. WR 84 Dazz Newsome(2023)- $870,000. Tier 3, insufficiency info
  16. WR – Tyron Johnson(2023)- $1,010,000. "". 3. "
  17. TE 85 George Kittle(2025)- $18,033,751. Stud
  18. TE 89 Charlie Woerner(2023)- $1,055,258. Tier 1.5
  19. TE 82 Ross Dwelley(2023)- $1,080,000. Tier 1
  20. C 64 Jake Brendel(2026)- $2,272,000. Tier 1
  21. C – Jon Feliciano(2023)- $2,250,000. Tier 3. Insuff info
  22. C 67 Keith Ismael(2023)- $940,000. ". 3. ". "
  23. LG 65 Aaron Banks(2024)- $1,929,166. Tier 1
  24. LG 63 Nick Zakelj(2025)- $917,590 Tier 2. Insuff. Info
  25. RG 74 Spencer Burford(2025)- $1,038,014. Tier 1
  26. RG 62 Jason Poe(2023)- $750,000. Tier 1.5
  27. LT 71 Trent Williams(2026)- $27,227,424. Studly studliest Stud
  28. LT – Matt Pryor(2023)- $990,000. Insuff info
  29. LT 78 Leroy Watson(2023)- $750,000 Insuff info
  30. RT 68 Colton McKivitz(2024)- $1,515,412. Tier 1.5
  31. RT 76 Jaylon Moore(2024)- $1,020,759. Tier 1 I hope
  32. RT 77 Alfredo Gutierrez(2023)- $750,000. Tier3 Insuff info
  33. DE 97 Nick Bosa(2023)- $17,859,000. Studly stud
  34. DE/DT 92 Kerry Hyder Jr.(2023)- stud
  35. DE 95 Drake Jackson(2025)- $1,339,180. Tier 1.5
  36. DE 94 Clelin Ferrell(2023)- $2,460,000. Tier2 Insuff info
  37. DE 58 Alex Barrett(2023)- $870,000. Insuff info
  38. DE — Austin Bryant(2023)- $965,000. Insuff info
  39. DT 91 Arik Armstead(2024)- $23,755,883. Stud
  40. DT 90 Kevin Givens(2023)- $2,000,000. Stud
  41. DT/NT 99 Javon Kinlaw(2023)- $4,928,223. Insuff info
  42. DT/NT 96 T.Y. McGill Jr.(2023)- $940,000. Tier 2 Insuff info
  43. NT/DT 98 Javon Hargrave(2026)- $6,555,000. Stud
  44. NT 93 Kalia Davis(2025)- $783,003. Tier 3
  45. SLB 45 Demetrius Flannigan-Fowles(2023)- $1,825,000. Tier2 Insuff info
  46. SLB 40 Marcelino McCrary-Ball(2023)- $750,000. Tier 2-3 Insuff info
  47. WLB 57 Dre Greenlaw(2024)- $5,648,558. Stud
  48. WLB 59 Curtis Robinson(2023)- $940,000. Insuff info
  49. MLB 54 Fred Warner(2026)- $9,049,000. Stud
  50. MLB 48 Oren Burks(2023)- $2,773,000. Tier 1.5 but coming on
  51. CB 7 Charvarius Ward(2024)- $6,421,000. Tier 1
  52. CB 20 Ambry Thomas(2024)- $1,305,232. Tier 2.5 unfortunately
  53. CB 38 Deommodore Lenoir(2024)- $1,011,217. Stud
  54. CB – Isaiah Oliver(2024)- $1,686,000. Insuff info
  55. CB 26 Samuel Womack III(2025)- $940,831. Tier 1.5
  56. CB 43 Qwuantrezz Knight(2023)- $750,000. Tier 2 Insuff info
  57. CB – A.J. Parker(2023)- $940,000. Insuff info
  58. CB – Tre Swilling(2023)- $750,000. Insuff info
  59. FS 31 Tashaun Gipson Sr.(2023)- $2,100,000. Tier 1, sometimes tier 2
  60. FS 41 Tayler Hawkins(2023)- $750,000. Insuff info
  61. FS – Myles Hartsfield(2023)- $1,010,000 ". "
  62. SS 29 Talanoa Hufanga(2024)- $1,000,038. Stud
  63. SS 30 George Odum(2024)- $2,340,000. Tier 1.5, but coming on
  64. PK — Zane Gonzalez(2023)- $1,465,000. Insuff info
  65. P 18 Mitch Wishnowsky(2026)- $1,700,000. Stud
  66. LS 46 Taybor Pepper(2025)- $1,225,000. Tier 1

tier 1 and Stud are self explanatory…the insufficient info just relates to me, as i have not enough or no info on those players. Tier 2 self explanatory, and tier 1.5 means close to tier 1 but not yet quite there. Tier 3s are self explanatory, but there are very few.

I like it, but you missed Trent, he has to GOD TIER no one else as good as him at LT IMO.

Thx, AB but that was just an obvious oversight. Studly studliest Stud makes up for that. GOD TIER gets it also.

Looking at this list, i sure hope we win it all this yr for everyone on team yes, but esp for big Trent, KS, JL, Nick, au Jus, Fred and Dre, Arik, and #85. Those guys are getting a bit longer in the tooth, (not KS /JL, but they have gotten so close and then torched by injuries), and they can't keep up their level of play forever. So i hope we win one this yr for these guys especially. I may have missed one or two but got most of them…the whole team is deserving but esp these studs.
Apr 16, 2023 at 1:49 PM
BOSA AND CMC : TOP TIER
Apr 17, 2023 at 7:19 AM
we need a official ranking system for this to work properly
Apr 17, 2023 at 8:37 AM
Bosa, Deebo, CMC, Warner, Kittle, Williams, Hargrave = Superstar tier

Aiyuk, Hufanga, Purdy, Greenlaw, Mitchell, Armstead, Ward = Probowl tier

Jennings, Lenoir, Juice, Gipson, Banks, Gould, = Real good roleplayer tier
Apr 17, 2023 at 9:13 AM
Originally posted by lamontb:
we need a official ranking system for this to work properly

Maybe like this, 5 tiers.

All-Pro/Superstar Caliber
Pro Bowl Caliber
Rising Players
Role Players
Camp Players
Apr 18, 2023 at 10:40 AM
Originally posted by AB81Rules:
Originally posted by lamontb:
we need a official ranking system for this to work properly

Maybe like this, 5 tiers.

All-Pro/Superstar Caliber
Pro Bowl Caliber
Rising Players
Role Players
Camp Players

Yes, a lot better, but still need a category for players with not enough info on. Of those there are two sets,

One where we know the guy but have insufficient info on, in that they are relative new bodies, or just haven't played much.

Two would be a guy we know but still have insufficient info on…case in point, javon Kinlaw, due to his arthritic knees. The part we don't know is will he be able to withstand NFL grind with arthritic knee/knees. I want him to be a stud, but the ??? Is health of knees…and there i am not very hopeful.
Apr 18, 2023 at 1:20 PM
Originally posted by AB81Rules:
Originally posted by lamontb:
we need a official ranking system for this to work properly

Maybe like this, 5 tiers.

All-Pro/Superstar Caliber
Pro Bowl Caliber
Rising Players
Role Players
Camp Players

this will work
Apr 18, 2023 at 1:34 PM
Originally posted by AB81Rules:
Like the title says, how would you rank the current 66 players, which I'll list below with their cap number, except Hyder, since it's not known, as he hasn't officially signed the deal.

  1. QB 5 Trey Lance(2024)- Rising Players
  2. QB 13 Brock Purdy(2025)- Rising Players
  3. QB 14 Sam Darnold(2023)- Role Players
  4. RB 23 Christian McCaffrey(2025)- All-Pro/Superstar Caliber
  5. RB 25 Elijah Mitchell(2024)- Rising Players
  6. RB 32 Tyrion Davis-Price(2025)- Camp Players
  7. RB 24 Jordan Mason(2024)- Rising Players
  8. FB 44 Kyle Juszczyk(2025)- Pro Bowl Caliber
  9. WR 19 Deebo Samuel(2025)- All-Pro/Superstar Caliber
  10. WR 11 Brandon Aiyuk(2023)- Pro Bowl Caliber
  11. WR 15 Jauan Jennings(2023)- Rising Players
  12. WR/KR/PR 3 Ray-Ray McCloud III(2023)- Role Players
  13. WR 6 Danny Gray(2025)- Camp Players
  14. WR 86 Tay Martin(2023)- Camp Players
  15. WR 84 Dazz Newsome(2023)- Camp Players
  16. WR – Tyron Johnson(2023)- Camp Players
  17. TE 85 George Kittle(2025)- All-Pro/Superstar Caliber
  18. TE 89 Charlie Woerner(2023)- Role Players
  19. TE 82 Ross Dwelley(2023)- Role Players
  20. C 64 Jake Brendel(2026)- Rising Players
  21. C – Jon Feliciano(2023)- Camp Players
  22. C 67 Keith Ismael(2023)- Camp Players
  23. LG 65 Aaron Banks(2024)- Rising Players
  24. LG 63 Nick Zakelj(2025)- Camp Players
  25. RG 74 Spencer Burford(2025)- Rising Players
  26. RG 62 Jason Poe(2023)- Rising Players
  27. LT 71 Trent Williams(2026)- All-Pro/Superstar Caliber
  28. LT – Matt Pryor(2023)- Camp Players
  29. LT 78 Leroy Watson(2023)- Camp Players
  30. RT 68 Colton McKivitz(2024)- Rising Players
  31. RT 76 Jaylon Moore(2024)- Camp Players
  32. RT 77 Alfredo Gutierrez(2023)- Camp Players
  33. DE 97 Nick Bosa(2023)- All-Pro/Superstar Caliber
  34. DE/DT 92 Kerry Hyder Jr.(2023)-Camp Players
  35. DE 95 Drake Jackson(2025)- Rising Players
  36. DE 94 Clelin Ferrell(2023)- Role Players
  37. DE 58 Alex Barrett(2023)- Camp Players
  38. DE — Austin Bryant(2023)- Camp Players
  39. DT 91 Arik Armstead(2024)- Pro Bowl Caliber
  40. DT 90 Kevin Givens(2023)- Role Players
  41. DT/NT 99 Javon Kinlaw(2023)- Camp Players
  42. DT/NT 96 T.Y. McGill Jr.(2023)- Rising Players
  43. NT/DT 98 Javon Hargrave(2026)- All-Pro/Superstar Caliber
  44. NT 93 Kalia Davis(2025)- Rising Players
  45. SLB 45 Demetrius Flannigan-Fowles(2023)- Role Players
  46. SLB 40 Marcelino McCrary-Ball(2023)- Camp Players
  47. WLB 57 Dre Greenlaw(2024)- Pro Bowl Caliber
  48. WLB 59 Curtis Robinson(2023)- Camp Players
  49. MLB 54 Fred Warner(2026)- All-Pro/Superstar Caliber
  50. MLB 48 Oren Burks(2023)- Rising Players
  51. CB 7 Charvarius Ward(2024)- Pro Bowl Caliber
  52. CB 20 Ambry Thomas(2024)- Camp Players
  53. CB 38 Deommodore Lenoir(2024)- Rising Players
  54. CB – Isaiah Oliver(2024)- Role Players
  55. CB 26 Samuel Womack III(2025)- Rising Players
  56. CB 43 Qwuantrezz Knight(2023)- Camp Players
  57. CB – A.J. Parker(2023)- Camp Players
  58. CB – Tre Swilling(2023)- Camp Players
  59. FS 31 Tashaun Gipson Sr.(2023)- Role Players
  60. FS 41 Tayler Hawkins(2023)- Camp Players
  61. FS – Myles Hartsfield(2023)- Camp Players
  62. SS 29 Talanoa Hufanga(2024)- Pro Bowl Caliber
  63. SS 30 George Odum(2024)- Role Players
  64. PK — Zane Gonzalez(2023)- Role Players
  65. P 18 Mitch Wishnowsky(2026)- Role Players
  66. LS 46 Taybor Pepper(2025)- Role Players

Here we go
Apr 19, 2023 at 8:42 PM
Originally posted by AB81Rules:
Originally posted by lamontb:
we need a official ranking system for this to work properly

Maybe like this, 5 tiers.

All-Pro/Superstar Caliber
Pro Bowl Caliber
Rising Players
Role Players
Camp Players

This is the way

also we need a God tier for Trent, bosa and javon
Apr 20, 2023 at 9:33 AM
Originally posted by GLT49ers:
Originally posted by AB81Rules:
Originally posted by lamontb:
we need a official ranking system for this to work properly

Maybe like this, 5 tiers.

All-Pro/Superstar Caliber
Pro Bowl Caliber
Rising Players
Role Players
Camp Players

This is the way

also we need a God tier for Trent, bosa and javon

Search
YouTube
Flipboard
Threads
×
Share 49ersWebzone