There are 145 users in the forums
Originally posted by CatchMaster80:
Joe Montana+Bill Walsh. They were almost the perfect combo. Joe understood his system and had the field vision and cool to execute it. This might surprise some but I would also consider John Unitas. He played in the era when QBs called their own plays. He was the master during his time.
Originally posted by genus49:
Originally posted by CatchMaster80:
Joe Montana+Bill Walsh. They were almost the perfect combo. Joe understood his system and had the field vision and cool to execute it. This might surprise some but I would also consider John Unitas. He played in the era when QBs called their own plays. He was the master during his time.
You're one of those guys who doesn't like instructions huh?
Originally posted by thl408:
I'd go with Kyle and Steve. I think Harbaugh's offense would lower Joe's potential to be great, and Walsh is no longer with us.
Originally posted by JTsBiggestFan:
I went with Young over Montana just because the coaching difference was so significant, and one needs to score to win.
What I don't like about Harbaugh being in this poll is that he's not the OC, and despite him being an HC just as much as Bill and Kyle, he didn't call plays like they did, so it isn't an accurate comparison IMO.
If it's Harbaugh with Gary Kubiak at OC and Joseph Montana at QB, that could be something. With Gregory Roman, totally different.
Originally posted by 9ers4eva:
Originally posted by JTsBiggestFan:
I went with Young over Montana just because the coaching difference was so significant, and one needs to score to win.
What I don't like about Harbaugh being in this poll is that he's not the OC, and despite him being an HC just as much as Bill and Kyle, he didn't call plays like they did, so it isn't an accurate comparison IMO.
If it's Harbaugh with Gary Kubiak at OC and Joseph Montana at QB, that could be something. With Gregory Roman, totally different.
Harbaugh could never put together an elite offensive staff. It'd always be a 2nd rate OC.
Answer is clearly Young and Shanny. Young in todays game would be unstoppable.