Originally posted by Furlow:
Originally posted by boast:
the loss to the NYG in '90 NFCCG was far more crushing to me personally.
i really should hate that team more than i do.
I was at the Kyle Williams game and it was crushing. 1990 was 10x worse. We were on the cusp of a three peat which has never been done. And Joe broke his back. Devastating on all levels.
No guarantee we 3peat.........none whatsoever, especially considering we lost to Buffalo in '92 at home with the better Steve Young than would have went out there a week later (instead of two). Buffalo in '90 I think was a different beast than '91-'93, where they nearly beat the Giants and by the time they faced Dallas, weren't quite the same team (or maybe they were figured out better.......the '90 team was a monster offensively....Belichick had to come up with an insanely counterintuitive game plan to beat them, that almost failed - the Bills had almost no time of possession but still scored about 1 point a minute...19 points!).
Trust me, I watched that game and remember crying as an 11 year old. It hurt and for many years left a hole in my heart, but now I look at the big picture a bit better and chalk it up to destiny. Niners inability to really run the ball, and the Giants taking advantage of every single opportunity (except dropping that FB option pass in the end zone.....Maurice Carthon's son was with the Niners until recently before going to Tennessee btw).
The fake punt, the fumble, and hell every play Hostetler seemingly made in that game......it seems like winning it would've been luck in hindsight. Even the field goal at the end was nearly missed (and nearly blocked too).
The Niners were a shocking 8 point favorite in that game, which seemed BS given the 7-3 MNF dogfight several weeks earlier. A healthier Craig very likely wins the game with some level of comfort.
As for the 2011 game, I think for me the big difference in *loss* was that it was a far more underrated/underappreciated squad. Seeing Smith, Gore, Davis, Willis and the defense overlooked despite a 13-3 season and beating the Saints hurt a lot. I remember Brian Baldinger on NFL Network before the Super Bowl expressing sadness we never got to see our defense go against New England.......he felt we would have really shut them down, and given the Giants held them to 17, I think we would've held them to like 10 points.
You could argue we deserved to lose the 2011 game more initially because we seemingly had no answer for Cruz until Fangio figured some stuff out in the second half. At that point, we had to play perfectly to win and we didn't.
Dropped Eli picks......the Bradshaw fumble that wasn't.
It never ends, haha.
No running game in 1990, no QB in 2011.
Hopefully we have both for the next big one....
[ Edited by JTsBiggestFan on Aug 23, 2023 at 9:01 AM ]