Originally posted by miked1978:
I have been keeping up with draft grades for all 32 teams since the 2000 draft and if we are talking 1st rounders then there is about a 70% hit rate. When I say hit rate I mean that player is a C or above on a grading scale. Mike McGlinchey is a C or borderline B. His 2nd contract kinda proves that he is a B. But to each his own.
So we have hit on 3 of 7 picks which is 43%. That's lower than the league Avg for sure. Foster had the talent and his on field performance he was a hit but his off field issues with his crazy girlfriend did him in.
But if you take into account an entire draft class, like we do in real life, the hit rate for all teams is 28%. This means a teams draft classes will only produce 2 players that are viewed as hits (Grade C or above) per year. 49ers are well above that. I don't have my spreadsheet to give you the exact #
So the 49ers are good at drafting but not good in the first round. I'm going to go back and see if any other teams are as bad as us in the first round. I'm sure there are some.
They need to drastically increase the rate for offering their 1st, 2nd and 3rd round picks second contracts. I've always looked at that as a measure of drafting success, along with other teams offering those players solid second contracts.
You're not going to be able to keep everyone but hopefully you're drafting well enough that other teams want the guys that you can't sign so you wind up with a steady supply of comp picks.
This next draft is going to be absolutely crucial. They are running out of cap space and running low on depth. They need to have a really good draft to refill the cupboard, especially for a few years down the road when, if everything works out with Purdy, he'll be looking for a huge new deal.
No more getting cute or blowing picks on non-core positions. I hope they seriously address OL, DL, CB and S to build up crucial depth for more future playoff runs.