49ers 2023 Active Injury Report

Originally posted by 9ers4eva:

Originally posted by NCommand:
LMAO. Dude's been waiting 6 years and 5 games to say this.

Dudes been right for 6 years and 5 games. Was never the scheme.

It isn't scheme, it's philosophy. Every game it gets mentioned that this team is the most physical in the league. Remember last year when every team we played lost the following week? It's because they got so beat up and the flip side of that coin is that the Niners get pretty beat up too.

No Dre, I will be watching the LBs today

Originally posted by SLCNiner:

Originally posted by 9ers4eva:

Originally posted by NCommand:
LMAO. Dude's been waiting 6 years and 5 games to say this.

Dudes been right for 6 years and 5 games. Was never the scheme.

It isn't scheme, it's philosophy. Every game it gets mentioned that this team is the most physical in the league. Remember last year when every team we played lost the following week? It's because they got so beat up and the flip side of that coin is that the Niners get pretty beat up too.

PS: There were several videos by pro QB's who also highlighted some scheme issues too that put QB's at risk. But I agree overall, it's more the reliance on run blocking, the volume of it and the team mentality to get every inch possible.

Edit: Annnnnnd, right on cue.

Originally posted by SLCNiner:
It isn't scheme, it's philosophy. Every game it gets mentioned that this team is the most physical in the league. Remember last year when every team we played lost the following week? It's because they got so beat up and the flip side of that coin is that the Niners get pretty beat up too.

It's the fact that we have HAPPILY taken on previously-injured guys if they are talented,...and factoring that in with the law of averages.

Nothing more really. It's always been a non-topic.

Our top guys are pretty much only into collecting top talent to fit the scheme and we're now reaping the rewards of such.

We'll go through our injury problems this year just like everyone else and the only thing we can do is cross our fingers.

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by 9ers4eva:

Originally posted by NCommand:
LMAO. Dude's been waiting 6 years and 5 games to say this.

Dudes been right for 6 years and 5 games. Was never the scheme.

forgot about this NC fairytale

Nice work fellas.

You restarted the curse.

Those oblique injuries can be very tricky. Glad Deebo's shoulder is negative on X-rays but it sounds like he is in a lot of pain. MRI coming up.

Originally posted by NCommand:
Those oblique injuries can be very tricky. Glad Deebo's shoulder is negative on X-rays but it sounds like he is in a lot of pain. MRI coming up.

Probably tore something and might not be seeing him again until a quite a while.

Originally posted by SLCNiner:
It isn't scheme, it's philosophy. Every game it gets mentioned that this team is the most physical in the league. Remember last year when every team we played lost the following week? It's because they got so beat up and the flip side of that coin is that the Niners get pretty beat up too.

Which hs a completely different concept that takes more nuance then blaming it on scheme.

Originally posted by SlipAndSlideBosa:
Probably tore something and might not be seeing him again until a quite a while.

Reports are saying they don't think the injury is serious. I didn't see any postgame comments though.

Hopefully nothing major.

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:

Originally posted by SlipAndSlideBosa:
Probably tore something and might not be seeing him again until a quite a while.

Reports are saying they don't think the injury is serious. I didn't see any postgame comments though.

Hopefully nothing major.

Looked at the news today, nothing about any serious injuries thank God. Glad the Browns game was on grass. This next Vikings game is on astro-turf. it may be a blessing that Deebo and Christian are out right now.

Originally posted by 9ers4eva:

Originally posted by SLCNiner:
It isn't scheme, it's philosophy. Every game it gets mentioned that this team is the most physical in the league. Remember last year when every team we played lost the following week? It's because they got so beat up and the flip side of that coin is that the Niners get pretty beat up too.

Which hs a completely different concept that takes more nuance then blaming it on scheme.

LOL. Philosophy is the heart and foundation of scheme.

Originally posted by NCommand:

Originally posted by 9ers4eva:

Originally posted by SLCNiner:
It isn't scheme, it's philosophy. Every game it gets mentioned that this team is the most physical in the league. Remember last year when every team we played lost the following week? It's because they got so beat up and the flip side of that coin is that the Niners get pretty beat up too.

Which hs a completely different concept that takes more nuance then blaming it on scheme.

LOL. Philosophy is the heart and foundation of scheme.

YAC guys on astro-turf, the good is that those YAC guys will able to cut sharper and have good traction in their route running and ability to break tackles. The Bad is that the surface causes so much ligament injuries because the traction is so grippy and good.

Originally posted by Giedi:

Originally posted by NCommand:

Originally posted by 9ers4eva:

Originally posted by SLCNiner:
It isn't scheme, it's philosophy. Every game it gets mentioned that this team is the most physical in the league. Remember last year when every team we played lost the following week? It's because they got so beat up and the flip side of that coin is that the Niners get pretty beat up too.

Which hs a completely different concept that takes more nuance then blaming it on scheme.

LOL. Philosophy is the heart and foundation of scheme.

YAC guys on astro-turf, the good is that those YAC guys will able to cut sharper and have good traction in their route running and ability to break tackles. The Bad is that the surface causes so much ligament injuries because the traction is so grippy and good.

Meh. It's not philosophy and it's not scheme. Yes we are more physical....but the context is lacking on this one. I mean you just dont get to this level, nor do you stay at this level, without being a physical football player. Football is a game of inches so in THIS context, we are more physical than many other teams.

But if we're talking legit tackling and competition and the likelihood of injuries,...I think we're reducing our opponents to Division II opponents when we suggest that it has ANYTHING to do with injuries. In that context, we're not any more physical than any other NFL team and such a thought . And I'd be willing to bet that half-a$$ing against other NFL-level players can get you injured even more than playing with a chip on your shoulder.

So then why do we discuss it? One part is simply trying to fit that square peg into a round hole year after year. As fans we want to "control" luck that we're in all honestly hopeless when it comes to having anything to do with it.

And beyond that,... a certain previous poster probably just want to prove to people on a message board that they could actually be hired by an NFL team and improve their chances of winning the SB,...lol. I can't blame the poster because who here wouldn't dare to dream such? Now for this dream to fill up thread after thread, however,...is another story.

I think it's a given that nothing beats natural grass, and everyone knows such. I've never seen an NFL player prefer artificial turf to play on. But How does artificial turf currently enter the discussion when we've been nothing but luckily healthy all year and the 1st time 3 of our All-Pro had to leave the game due to injuries, it was on a natural grass field in Cleveland. I'm not replying to you personally as much as as reinforcing key point, which is you can't predict or prevent the injuries that happen in NFL games that you're actually trying to win. It's really just a wasted effort.

p.s.,....it probably hurts someone's heart and soul that we don't have a major one yet (with so many star players we eventually probably will) that they can make their case for why they deserve to replace John Lynch,...but Deebo, Trent, and CMac are all currently listed as day-to-day.

And oh yea,...on this them that grows tired and is not backed by science:

There is dogma that higher training load causes higher injury rates. However, there is also evidence that training has a protective effect against injury. For example, team sport athletes who performed more than 18 weeks of training before sustaining their initial injuries were at reduced risk of sustaining a subsequent injury, while high chronic workloads have been shown to decrease the risk of injury. Second, across a wide range of sports, well-developed physical qualities are associated with a reduced risk of injury. Clearly, for athletes to develop the physical capacities required to provide a protective effect against injury, they must be prepared to train hard. Finally, there is also evidence that under-training may increase injury risk. Collectively, these results emphasize that reductions in workloads may not always be the best approach to protect against injury.
https://bjsm.bmj.com/content/50/5/273

But obese couch potatoes like us know better than legit studies,...right?

I mean it's just silly. We don't want Christian McCaffrey worn out by the end of the year,...but we were 5 games in and he had 10 carries when he got injured,...lol. Should we only give him 7 carries a game?

Originally posted by Shorteous:
This topic will have up to date injury status for the 49ers 2023 season. I will update this post with the latest information. PM'ing with info is greatly appreciated

WK 7 Updated: 10/22/23 10PM EST

Questionable:
RB CMC - Oblique (Oct 16) - Limited practice Oct 21
LG Aaron Banks - Shoulder (Oct 8) - Full Practice Oct 21
LB Dre Greenlaw - Hamstring (Oct 8) - Limited practice Oct 21
CB Isiah Oliver - knee (Oct 16) - Full Practice Oct 21
LB George Odum - Quad (Oct 16) - Full Practice Oct 21

Doubtful:

Out:
WR Deebo Samuel - Shoulder (Oct 16) - Did not practice Oct 21
LT Trent Williams - Ankle (Oct 16) - Did not practice Oct 21

PUP:
CB - Darrell Luter Jr - Knee (Aug 29) - Available after wk 4

Injured Reserve:
CB Samuel Womack - Knee (Sep 13) - Available to return after wk 5
WR Danny Gray - Shoulder Sprain (Aug 20) - Available to return after wk 4
DE Robert Beal JR - Hammy (Aug 30) - Available to return after wk 4
TE Cameron Latu - Knee Meniscus (Aug 29) - Available 2024

Released with Injury Settlement
PK - Zane Gonzales - Calf (Aug 29) - Settled Sept 5th
CB - AJ Parker - Hammy (Aug 29) - Settled Sept 5th
S Tayler Hawkins - Hand (Aug 29) - Released on Injury Settlement

Week 7 snapshot

Opportunity for Purdy to make a statement in prime time! Part of me hopes they sit CMC as well, don't want him playing on that turf.

Can't wait

Inactives:

• QB Brandon Allen
• RB Tyrion Davis-Price
• DL Kalia Davis
• LB Jalen Graham
• WR Deebo Samuel (shoulder)
• T Trent Williams (ankle)
• TE Brayden Willis