Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
We are talking Mahomes vs Goff, they are on different planets dude. If your answer is go look at the numbers, I say go watch em play the position, how they operate under duress, the plays they are capable of making off schedule. Goff was never at any time playing better than Mahomes, putting up numbers isn't playing better. If you want to say the DET team was better, that's a dif conversation. This will be the top QB we've faced this postseason, by a long shot, granted Love was playing very well coming into that game but he's no Mahomes, not yet.
I'm talking about this year. Goff was better overall than Mahomes. His offense was better. Putting up numbers is absolutely part of saying who had a better season.
I don't care how they play under duress…the results are there. I watched a lot of damn football this yr. This was one of Mahomes' worst seasons. I'm not saying he's not elite.
weren't you the one that said making plays off schedule was such a small part of playing the position lol?
People gotta stop with it being a QB vs a QB. It's not that….ever. It's a team vs a team.
I think Justin Herbert is one of the most talented QBs in the league…doesn't mean s**t when the team (or coach) overall isn't at his level…end of the day we're talking about winning a football game. Not which QB can throw a ball off one foot 50 yards.
Watch Mahomes vs DET, he played out of his mind, and it was an L. When the ball clangs off Toney for a pick 6, that impacts the numbers. Did Pat play it wrong? No, he threw a perfect ball. You ding Mahomes for the numbers, but no one in their right mind would fault Mahomes on that play, watching the play as it happened.
I really dislike the this was a bad season for Mahomes takes, why cuz MVS sucked? Or Toney sucked? That means it's a bad season for Toney. Not Patrick. Understand where the fault lies, and who's playing well and who isn't. Mahomes is every bit the stud he was as league MVP, now if the numbers have changed, maybe it's cuz Tyreek is in MIA, sure that hits your numbers, doesn't mean Mahomes isn't playing as well as ever, just means the roster has changed.