There are 136 users in the forums
*** 2024-25 Depth Chart, 53-Man Roster, & TC Battles***
May 3, 2024 at 2:03 AM
- the_dynasty
- Veteran
- Posts: 2,632
I dont see Ya-Sin as a lock. Everyone else I agree on.
May 3, 2024 at 5:18 AM
- JTB1974
- Veteran
- Posts: 14,044
- NFL Pick 'em
Originally posted by JustinNiner:
QB: Purdy/ Dobbs/ Allen
RB: CMC/Mitchell/Mason/Guerendo
FB: Juice
WR: Aijuk/Samuel/Pearsall/Cowing/Jennings/Conley
TE: Kittle/Latu/Saubert
IOL: Banks/Puni/Feliciano/Brendel/Burford/Kingston
OT: Williams/McKitvitz/Moore
DE: Bosa/Floyd/Matus-Gross/Jackson/Beal
DT: Hargrave/Collins/Givens/Anderson
LB: Warner/Campbell/Flannigan-Fowles/Winters/Graham
CB: Ward/Lenoir/Green/Yiadom/Womack
S: Brown/Hufanga/Mustapha/Odum
ST: Moody/Witchnowsky/Pepper
You forgot about Jordan Elliot who the Niners signed this offseason and gave him a 2 year deal worth $10 million.
May 3, 2024 at 3:45 PM
- kirkscrafford
- Veteran
- Posts: 382
With the new qb rule, Allen goes to the practice squad.
May 3, 2024 at 3:52 PM
- AB81Rules
- Veteran
- Posts: 33,095
Originally posted by kirkscrafford:
With the new qb rule, Allen goes to the practice squad.
Only if the 3rd QB off the PS doesn't count towards the games the PS player can be active for, if so, I agree Allen could be on the PS, which opens a roster spot for someone you might lose off waivers, plus Allen doesn't have to go thru waivers.
May 4, 2024 at 1:25 AM
- kirkscrafford
- Veteran
- Posts: 382
What happened to Manning? Not invited to camp?
May 4, 2024 at 1:30 AM
- maxsmart
- Veteran
- Posts: 2,579
OT looks weak, definitely need to sign or trade for a better back-up OT
May 4, 2024 at 3:32 AM
- AB81Rules
- Veteran
- Posts: 33,095
Originally posted by kirkscrafford:
What happened to Manning? Not invited to camp?
Ilm Manning? I think he got poached last season by I think CAR.
May 4, 2024 at 6:58 AM
- 49ers81
- Veteran
- Posts: 2,442
Originally posted by AB81Rules:
I think I'd put the following players as locked into a roster spot for the 53-man roster, or to begin on short term IR/PUP/NFI
- QB Brock Purdy(2025)
- QB Joshua Dobbs(2024)
- QB Brandon Allen(2024)
- RB Christian McCaffrey(2025)
- RB Isaac Guerendo(2027)
- FB Kyle Juszczyk(2025)
- WR Brandon Aiyuk(2024)
- WR Deebo Samuel(2025)
- WR Jauan Jennings(2024)
- WR Ricky Pearsall(2027)
- WR Jacob Cowing(2027)
- TE George Kittle(2025)
- C Jake Brendel(2026)
- LG Aaron Banks(2024)
- RG Jon Feliciano(2024)
- LT Trent Williams(2026)
- RT Colton McKivitz(2025)
- OL Dominick Puni(2027)
- DE Nick Bosa(2028)
- DE Leonard Floyd(2025)
- DE Yetur Gross-Matos(2025)
- DT Maliek Collins(2025)
- DT Kevin Givens(2024)
- DT Jordan Elliott(2025)
- NT Javon Hargrave(2026)
- LB Fred Warner(2026)
- LB Dre Greenlaw(2024)
- LB De'Vondre Campbell(2024)
- LB Demetrius Flannigan-Fowles(2024)
- CB Charvarius Ward(2024)
- CB Deommodore Lenoir(2024)
- CB Isaac Yiadom(2024)
- CB Rock Ya-Sin(2024)
- CB Renardo Green(2027)
- FS Ji'Ayir Brown(2026)
- SS Talanoa Hufanga(2024)
- SS George Odum(2026)
- SS/FS Malik Mustapha(2027)
- PK Jake Moody(2026)
- P Mitch Wishnowsky(2026)
- LS Taybor Pepper(2025)
So, 41 locks, with Dre being the guy that would make it just 40 if he begins on PUP, so 13 potential roster spots open.
The following are close to being on the roster or as of now have the best shot to make the final 53.
- RB Elijah Mitchell(2024)
- RB Jordan Mason(2024)
- RB Patrick Taylor Jr.(2024)
- WR Chris Conley(2024)
- WR Trent Taylor(2024)
- WR Ronnie Bell(2026)
- WR Danny Gray(2025)
- TE Cameron Latu(2026)
- TE Brayden Willis(2026)
- TE Eric Saubert(2024)
- C Ben Bartch(2024)
- LG Nick Zakelj(2025)
- RG Spencer Burford(2025)
- LT Jaylon Moore(2024)
- RT Brandon Parker(2024)
- OL Jarrett Kingston(2027)
- DE Drake Jackson(2025)
- DE Robert Beal Jr.(2026)
- DT T.Y. McGill Jr.(2024)
- NT Kalia Davis(2025)
- NT Evan Anderson(2026)
- LB Ezekiel Turner(2024)
- LB Jalen Graham(2026)
- LB Dee Winters(2026)
- LB Tatum Bethune(2027)
- LB Curtis Robinson(2024)
- CB Samuel Womack III(2025)
- CB Ambry Thomas(2024)
- CB Darrell Luter Jr.(2026)
- CB Chase Lucas(2024)
- FS Tayler Hawkins(2024)
Yeah 31 players who I think will compete for roster spots in camp this offseason, I added Evan Anderson just because of the huge guarantee they gave him, no he's not locked in, but he should have a legit shot, he'll be a PS guy for sure at worst IMO.
The rest of the roster I see as just camp bodies.
- QB Tanner Mordecai(2026)
- RB Cody Schrader(2026)
- WR Tay Martin(2024)
- WR Terique Owens(2026)
- TE Jake Tonges(2024)
- TE Mason Pline(2026)
- C Corey Luciano(2024)
- C Drake Nugent(2026)
- C Briason Mays(2026)
- LT Isaac Alarcon(2024)
- LT Sebastian Gutierrez(2024)
- DE Alex Barrett(2024)
- DE Earnest Brown IV(2024)
- DE Austin Bryant(2024)
- DE Sam Okuayinonut(2024)
- DT Spencer Waege(2024)
- DT Raymond Johnson III(2024)
- CB Kemon Hall(2024)
- FS Jaylen Mahoney(2026)
- SS Erik Harris(2024)
FYI, Alacron doesn't count against the offseason 90-man roster, due to the team getting a roster exemption so he'll be on the PS, as he's the International Pathway Program player, like we had with Alfredo Gutierrez, who wasn't signed back, so team needs to cut 1 player when they sign their 8 UDFAs.
I didn't see Javon Kinlaw on your list or the one that was posted above it. Did he get traded or something? I mean I don't really expect he will be on the team much longer, but I haven't heard that they have moved him yet.
May 4, 2024 at 7:35 AM
- JMyaer
- Veteran
- Posts: 507
Originally posted by 49ers81:
I didn't see Javon Kinlaw on your list or the one that was posted above it. Did he get traded or something? I mean I don't really expect he will be on the team much longer, but I haven't heard that they have moved him yet.
DT Javon Kinlaw (Adam Schefter, 1-yr, $7.25M deal w/ Jets)
May 4, 2024 at 12:04 PM
- JTB1974
- Veteran
- Posts: 14,044
- NFL Pick 'em
I think we should just go with two QB's. Last season our #3 QB turned out to be a wasted roster spot. If we go with three QB's we are likely going to cut a decent player at another position. A player we can use more than a #3 QB that will probally never play. I know Fans and the team have PTSD from what happened 2 years ago but that was just a very rare situation. What's the chances of that happening again? And to the same team. If our #3 QB has to play we are screwed anyways.
May 4, 2024 at 12:46 PM
- AB81Rules
- Veteran
- Posts: 33,095
Posted my first projection for the 2024 roster on my site, https://49erscap.com/index.php/2024/05/03/my-first-53-man-roster-projection-with-practice-squad-injured-lists-version-1-0/
I go over why I chose who I chose, as well as 2024 & 2025 cap with my roster.
I go over why I chose who I chose, as well as 2024 & 2025 cap with my roster.
Originally posted by JTB1974:This depends on the actual rule about the 3rd QB(emergency 3rd QB), now that a PS QB can be the 3rd QB, so if Allen can go to the PS, and be the 3rd QB each week without counting against the max amount of games a player can be called up each week(3 games), and also against the max players you can call up each week(2), then ok, if not, the 49ers will definitely keep 3 QBs, we weren't the only team who went thru more than 3 QBs, Minnesota had that last year, may have been another team or 2, with the way this regime is, they'll likely keep all 3 QBs on the 53-man roster.
I think we should just go with two QB's. Last season our #3 QB turned out to be a wasted roster spot. If we go with three QB's we are likely going to cut a decent player at another position. A player we can use more than a #3 QB that will probally never play. I know Fans and the team have PTSD from what happened 2 years ago but that was just a very rare situation. What's the chances of that happening again? And to the same team. If our #3 QB has to play we are screwed anyways.
May 15, 2024 at 3:17 PM
- AB81Rules
- Veteran
- Posts: 33,095
New updated projection after the Chris Hubbard signing.
OFFENSE:
QB(2): 13 Brock Purdy(2025), & 5 Joshua Dobbs(2024)
RB(4): 23 Christian McCaffrey(2025), 25 Elijah Mitchell(2024), 24 Jordan Mason(2024), & 49 Isaac Guerendo(2027)
FB(1): 44 Kyle Juszczyk(2025)
WR(5): 11 Brandon Aiyuk(2024), 1 Deebo Samuel Sr.(2025), 15 Jauan Jennings(2024), 14 Ricky Pearsall(2027), & 83 Jacob Cowing(2027)
TE(4): 85 George Kittle(2025), 82 Eric Saubert(2024), 81 Cameron Latu(2026), & 9 Brayden Willis(2026)
C(1): 64 Jake Brendel(2026)
LG(2): 65 Aaron Banks(2024), & 77 Dominick Puni(2027)
RG(2): 55 Jon Feliciano(2024), & 62 Jarrett Kingston(2027)
LT(1): 71 Trent Williams(2026)
RT(2): 68 Colton McKivitz(2025), & 61 Chris Hubbard(2024)
DEFENSE:
DE(5): 97 Nick Bosa(2028), 56 Leonard Floyd(2025), 94 Yetur Gross-Matos(2025), 95 Drake Jackson(2025), & 51 Robert Beal Jr.(2026)
DT(3): 99 Maliek Collins(2025), 92 Jordan Elliott(2025), & 90 Kevin Givens(2024)
NT(3): 98 Javon Hargrave(2026), 93 Kalia Davis(2025), & 66 Evan Anderson(2026)
WLB(2): 59 De'Vondre Campbell(2024), & 53 Dee Winters(2026)
MLB(2): 54 Fred Warner(2026), & 50 Jalen Graham(2026)
SLB(1): 45 Demetrius Flannigan-Fowles(2024)
CB(6): 7 Charvarius Ward(2024), 2 Deommodore Lenoir(2024), 22 Isaac Yiadom(2024), 33 Rock Ya-Sin(2024), 31 Renardo Green(2027), & 28 Darrell Luter Jr.(2026)
S(4): 29 Talanoa Hufanga(2024), 27 Ji'Ayir Brown(2026), 43 Malik Mustapha(2027), & 30 George Odum(2026)
SPECIAL TEAMS:
PK(1): 4 Jake Moody(2026)
P(1): 3 Mitch Wishnowsky(2026)
LS(1): 46 Taybor Pepper(2025)
INJURED LISTS:
PUP: WLB 57 Dre Greenlaw(2024)
PRACTICE SQUAD:
QB 17 Brandon Allen* (Has $400K of base salary GTD)
RB 38 Cody Schrader
WR 18 Chris Conley* (Has $210K of base salary GTD)
WR 84 Terique Owens
TE 89 Mason Pline
C 66 Drake Nugent
LG 78 Ben Bartch* (Has $302,400 of base salary GTD)
RG 74 Spencer Burford
LT 67 Isaac Alarcon** (Doesn't count against the PS limit or Cap as he'd be the International Pathway Program player like how Alfredo Gutierrez was for the last 3 years)
RT 75 Brandon Parker* (Has no GTD money)
DE 58 Alex Barrett
IDL 96 T.Y. McGill Jr.* (Has no GTD money)
SLB 48 Tatum Bethune
SLB 47 Ezekiel Turner* (Has no GTD money)
CB 0 Samuel Womack III
CB 26 Chase Lucas
FS 49 Jaylen Mahoney
Some notes:
Brandon Allen goes to the PS if he wouldn't count against the max games allowed in a season(3) and max players allowed per week(2), if Cody Schrader out plays Mitchell or Mason, I would try & trade one of them for a mid-late round pick, & keep Schrader on the 53, I kept 4 TEs cause I still like Latu & Willis' upside, Saubert makes it as #2 TE unless someone better comes available, and I went with just 8 OL for now, if I had to choose a 9th, I'd go with Ben Bartch, he can play all IOL spots.
I went with an 11th DL(Evan Anderson) because I don't want to lose him or Davis off of waivers, LB wise, I'm tempted by Bethune as a 6th LB, CB wise I kept 6, I like Luter, but Womack could win it, or they go with Bethune as a 6th LB if they fear he'll get claimed off waivers, and Safety wise is obvious, same for ST'ers.
OFFENSE:
QB(2): 13 Brock Purdy(2025), & 5 Joshua Dobbs(2024)
RB(4): 23 Christian McCaffrey(2025), 25 Elijah Mitchell(2024), 24 Jordan Mason(2024), & 49 Isaac Guerendo(2027)
FB(1): 44 Kyle Juszczyk(2025)
WR(5): 11 Brandon Aiyuk(2024), 1 Deebo Samuel Sr.(2025), 15 Jauan Jennings(2024), 14 Ricky Pearsall(2027), & 83 Jacob Cowing(2027)
TE(4): 85 George Kittle(2025), 82 Eric Saubert(2024), 81 Cameron Latu(2026), & 9 Brayden Willis(2026)
C(1): 64 Jake Brendel(2026)
LG(2): 65 Aaron Banks(2024), & 77 Dominick Puni(2027)
RG(2): 55 Jon Feliciano(2024), & 62 Jarrett Kingston(2027)
LT(1): 71 Trent Williams(2026)
RT(2): 68 Colton McKivitz(2025), & 61 Chris Hubbard(2024)
DEFENSE:
DE(5): 97 Nick Bosa(2028), 56 Leonard Floyd(2025), 94 Yetur Gross-Matos(2025), 95 Drake Jackson(2025), & 51 Robert Beal Jr.(2026)
DT(3): 99 Maliek Collins(2025), 92 Jordan Elliott(2025), & 90 Kevin Givens(2024)
NT(3): 98 Javon Hargrave(2026), 93 Kalia Davis(2025), & 66 Evan Anderson(2026)
WLB(2): 59 De'Vondre Campbell(2024), & 53 Dee Winters(2026)
MLB(2): 54 Fred Warner(2026), & 50 Jalen Graham(2026)
SLB(1): 45 Demetrius Flannigan-Fowles(2024)
CB(6): 7 Charvarius Ward(2024), 2 Deommodore Lenoir(2024), 22 Isaac Yiadom(2024), 33 Rock Ya-Sin(2024), 31 Renardo Green(2027), & 28 Darrell Luter Jr.(2026)
S(4): 29 Talanoa Hufanga(2024), 27 Ji'Ayir Brown(2026), 43 Malik Mustapha(2027), & 30 George Odum(2026)
SPECIAL TEAMS:
PK(1): 4 Jake Moody(2026)
P(1): 3 Mitch Wishnowsky(2026)
LS(1): 46 Taybor Pepper(2025)
INJURED LISTS:
PUP: WLB 57 Dre Greenlaw(2024)
PRACTICE SQUAD:
QB 17 Brandon Allen* (Has $400K of base salary GTD)
RB 38 Cody Schrader
WR 18 Chris Conley* (Has $210K of base salary GTD)
WR 84 Terique Owens
TE 89 Mason Pline
C 66 Drake Nugent
LG 78 Ben Bartch* (Has $302,400 of base salary GTD)
RG 74 Spencer Burford
LT 67 Isaac Alarcon** (Doesn't count against the PS limit or Cap as he'd be the International Pathway Program player like how Alfredo Gutierrez was for the last 3 years)
RT 75 Brandon Parker* (Has no GTD money)
DE 58 Alex Barrett
IDL 96 T.Y. McGill Jr.* (Has no GTD money)
SLB 48 Tatum Bethune
SLB 47 Ezekiel Turner* (Has no GTD money)
CB 0 Samuel Womack III
CB 26 Chase Lucas
FS 49 Jaylen Mahoney
Some notes:
Brandon Allen goes to the PS if he wouldn't count against the max games allowed in a season(3) and max players allowed per week(2), if Cody Schrader out plays Mitchell or Mason, I would try & trade one of them for a mid-late round pick, & keep Schrader on the 53, I kept 4 TEs cause I still like Latu & Willis' upside, Saubert makes it as #2 TE unless someone better comes available, and I went with just 8 OL for now, if I had to choose a 9th, I'd go with Ben Bartch, he can play all IOL spots.
I went with an 11th DL(Evan Anderson) because I don't want to lose him or Davis off of waivers, LB wise, I'm tempted by Bethune as a 6th LB, CB wise I kept 6, I like Luter, but Womack could win it, or they go with Bethune as a 6th LB if they fear he'll get claimed off waivers, and Safety wise is obvious, same for ST'ers.
May 15, 2024 at 3:56 PM
- mcwoot
- Veteran
- Posts: 1,301
Wouldn't shock me if Bartch or Burford made it over Kingston.
May 15, 2024 at 5:28 PM
- jreff22
- Veteran
- Posts: 66,145
I love Mitchell but he's not going to stay healthy, need to move on IMO.
May 16, 2024 at 12:19 PM
- kirkscrafford
- Veteran
- Posts: 382
I think Jaylon Moore or Bartch would get a spot before Kingston.