49ERS at PACKERS Thread - 2024 Season Week 12

Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:

Originally posted by _Goldblooded_:

Originally posted by 49erfaninPA:
Hmmm.

Was told last night that Brock's injury is a tricky one.

Was told that a few weeks ago he began dealing with elbow tightness/fatigue.

He then had the shoulder injury that was labeled to me as AC/Labrum injury. MRI was for the Labrum.

This is a tricky situation to be in for…

— Marco Martinez (@marco_mart1205) November 24, 2024

as a physician albeit not an orthopedic surgeon this report is all over the place.

and the AC and Labrum are completely different things

The Twitter guy isn't a doctor of any kind, people are just posting from random accounts.

Agree but Ive been questioning his arm for the last 4-5 games. Something has been off and he's been sailing balls for a while. Now I'm not doctor obviously but he's had some Shaun Hill type ducks.

Originally posted by tommyncal:

Originally posted by BOI49er:

Originally posted by 9ersLiferInChicago:
Shanny isn't a HC, he's a OC. Period.

Bump

99% of you guys says he can't call plays. Why would he be a good OC then ?

I can find fault there too. Let's say he's a really good play designer, but what to call when, especially in big games, still requires judgement I'd rather not count on.

Originally posted by Montana:
How bad is Dobbs that we didn't even let him get one snap?

This. If Shanny want to even try and win he should have given him some reps. I feel like he should have started. He has more recent starting experience than Allen has.

Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:

Originally posted by Fanaticofnfl:
This team pushed all of its chips and then some
into the middle last season just to hand the Chiefs another Lombardi.

That Super Bowl loss destroyed this franchise. Those NFC Championship losses and other two SB losses combined don't even add up to the damage February 11th did to this team.

We went from having a Super Bowl winning QB/HC set for the next 15+ years to it all getting flushed down the toilet in one game. Really,
really sucks.

Like I said, these panic reactions are absurd.

Not panicked reaction at all. Kyle's tenure here:
1) Can't win unless ALL his horses are healthy on offense & can't adjust to his talent that's left
2) Calls plays to not lose instead of to win
3) Can't play from behind
4) Has neglected the O-Line all tenure so when teams know we have to pass, they can't protect the QB (Jimmie G Super Bowl & all like today)
5) Can't call a fast tempo game when they need to catch-up
6) Has neglected to fix special teams since he got here and are getting WORST!
7) If he can't get a veteran team to dig in & grind out a game like today & they lay down like dogs, then what does Kyle Bring to the table? NOTHING!!

Originally posted by jds_49ers:
Where you getting money to go acquire said players? Pay Purdy and you are about done with money. Going to have to do it in the draft and how many years will that take till enough of them pan out?

They don't need to build a whole roster, this isn't 2017 again. You need some upgrades on the OL and DL, maybe find another TE that you can develop into Kittle's replacement eventually. People are making it seem incredibly dire when this team still has a ton of talent and some good looking rookies.

PENALTY PENALTY PENALTY!
INJURY INJURY INJURY!
TURNOVER TURNOVER TURNOVER!
MISSED TACKLE AFTER MISSED TACKLE!
UNSPECIAL TEAMS!
KYLE THE GAME MISMANAGER!
KYLE THE PERSONNEL MISMANAGER!

THAT'S HOW THE 49ERS ROLL!!!

Originally posted by Montana:
How bad is Dobbs that we didn't even let him get one snap?

I don't think he can do any better tackling Jacob's.

This will most likely be the last 49ers Green Bay game I will watch with my mother. She will be passing soon and is a big packer fan. I was happy her team won one last time against us. It has been really disappointing for her for years. Too bad it wasn't a closer game

Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
Sure but those guys didn't just magically appear, they were acquired. Gotta go out and acquire some more impact players. They look like they have some nice pieces with Green, Mustapha and Puni, needs to get some more guys like that in the draft.

Bosa will be back, Warner will be back, Purdy will be back, Jennings will be back, Green and Lenoir will be back, Aiyuk hopefully recovers well, Kittle will be back, they really just need to fill up the roster around them.

OL and DL, and a 2nd pass catching TE. And a more serviceable backup QB than Allen.

Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:

Originally posted by jds_49ers:
Where you getting money to go acquire said players? Pay Purdy and you are about done with money. Going to have to do it in the draft and how many years will that take till enough of them pan out?

They don't need to build a whole roster, this isn't 2017 again. You need some upgrades on the OL and DL, maybe find another TE that you can develop into Kittle's replacement eventually. People are making it seem incredibly dire when this team still has a ton of talent and some good looking rookies.

Lol, you're delusional.

Where is this "ton of talent"?

Originally posted by kray28:
Also Sorensen should be fired and replaced by Staley immediately.

Staley should've never been added to the staff. f**k him. Get him off the team now and send Sorensen with him.

Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:

Originally posted by jds_49ers:
Where you getting money to go acquire said players? Pay Purdy and you are about done with money. Going to have to do it in the draft and how many years will that take till enough of them pan out?

They don't need to build a whole roster, this isn't 2017 again. You need some upgrades on the OL and DL, maybe find another TE that you can develop into Kittle's replacement eventually. People are making it seem incredibly dire when this team still has a ton of talent and some good looking rookies.

They don't? Need a new LT, RT, C, DT, LB, S, and that's just starters. New backup TE, more DL depth, and who know what is going to happen to the ridiculously expensive WR group that under performs their contracts. And that isn't even touching the league worst special teams.

The players the Niners didn't have today.

Brock
Aiyuk
Trent
Bosa
Hargraves
Huf
Greenlaw
Ward

And basically a healthy CMC.

You are not beating anybody losing that many star players.

#1 QB
#1 WR
#1Olineman
#1 DE
#1 DT
#1 S
#2 LB who I think should really be called 1B
#2 CB who again could be called 1A or 1B.

And your #1 RB who is nowhere close to 100%.

We still are only 1 game back of both division and the wildcard. We are still in the hunt!

roster is old and not that good anymore. rook QB contract window closed.