Brock Purdy vs Sam Darnold

Originally posted by Cosmo:
Can't believe this thread is a thing.

Originally posted by Cosmo:
Can't believe this thread is a thing.

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:
Only to clueless fans.

Originally posted by CatchMaster80:
I don't see any real advantage to going with Darnold. He's shown he can be capable but I don't see him as an elite QB. Better to stay with Purdy until they can find someone really better. They coud get lucky in the mid to late rounds but they may need to do something like what the Rams did. Find a talented QB stuck on a lousy team and make a trade.

Originally posted by Niner4ever:
It's a little hard to dissect since Darnold is playing half of his games in doors. We know Purdy doesn't have the physical ability to overcome bad weather.

Stature and arm Darnold. A little more mobility Purdy. Darnold seems to have more command of the offense while it seems that Purdy cedes.

I've always rooted for Purdy but I'd roll with Darnold before giving the bag to Purdy.

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:
Mullens has been better across the board with the Vikings other than TDs, so it's not some slam dunk for Kyle. Schaub had a better season without Kyle

All I know is Hoyer and Ryan do not speak kindly of his offense, nor do former QBs that breakdown the film. Something needs to change

Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:

Originally posted by Niner4ever:
It's a little hard to dissect since Darnold is playing half of his games in doors. We know Purdy doesn't have the physical ability to overcome bad weather.

Stature and arm Darnold. A little more mobility Purdy. Darnold seems to have more command of the offense while it seems that Purdy cedes.

I've always rooted for Purdy but I'd roll with Darnold before giving the bag to Purdy.

You're going to have to give the bag to Darnold too. No, he's not signing a deal for $20 mil or $30 mil or whatever number people are fantasizing that about, convincing themselves that a 27 year old QB coming off a Pro Bowl season will take less than full value on the market value.

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:

Originally posted by Cosmo:
Can't believe this thread is a thing.

Only to clueless fans.

Originally posted by CatchMaster80:
I don't see any real advantage to going with Darnold. He's shown he can be capable but I don't see him as an elite QB. Better to stay with Purdy until they can find someone really better. They coud get lucky in the mid to late rounds but they may need to do something like what the Rams did. Find a talented QB stuck on a lousy team and make a trade.

Originally posted by FootballExpert49ers:
The game wasn't meaningless for Darnold. Darnold was auditioning for a starting job for another team. You think he was just mailing it in?

Mullens had as many picks as TDs in 2020 with Kyle, and a 13/10 ratio with Kyle in 2018. The TD/INT ratio in Minnesota are in line with what Mullens always was with Kyle, and he had a higher yards per attempt. Also, Mullens outperformed Josh Dobbs by a landslide in Minnesota.

If Kyle were some kind of incredible play caller, Mullens should've been significantly better with him.

Yeah, right. You're the guy who didn't even know when Purdy's go ball to Aiyuk down the sideline for a TD was last season. Forgetting that is already telling about how little you actually study football, but the fact you couldn't even be bothered to look it up to find it is even more telling. Your smugness is comical. You don't know enough to know you don't know enough.

Originally posted by 5thSFG:

Originally posted by CatchMaster80:
I don't see any real advantage to going with Darnold. He's shown he can be capable but I don't see him as an elite QB. Better to stay with Purdy until they can find someone really better. They coud get lucky in the mid to late rounds but they may need to do something like what the Rams did. Find a talented QB stuck on a lousy team and make a trade.

A potential $20 million in saving is the advantage. Said differently, it could be as simple as do you want purdy or do you want darnold and greenlaw