Originally posted by Ninerjohn:Originally posted by Niners99:Originally posted by Ninerjohn:Originally posted by Rubberneck36:Originally posted by Ninerjohn:I think it will be tough for Duffy to make the AS game simply because of the position he plays. Arenado and Bryant will be locks if they come close to what they did last year.
Agreed. Panik could have a shot if he hits around.300 again. And so could Cueto.
Yep. There isnt the dominant 2B in the NL and Panik would have a better shot for sure than the Duff man. I put Pence on there more on a hunch that he comes back strong this year. Nothing at all to base this on though.
I just have a feeling that Matt Duffy is the real deal, and then some. Last year he had a breakout year that caught local attention. This year he could be poised to gain some national attention. I dont think its out of the question that he could be a top 2 NL 3B at the All-Star break. Bryant is going to have big pressure to take the next step. I wouldn't be shocked if he starts slow.
Either way, the Giants have about 12 guys that are good enough to end up in a spot to get an All-Star selection, so it should be a good year.
I like Duffy a lot but he isnt the player that Kris Bryant is. You can pretty much pencil in that Arenado and Bryant will be all stars. Maybe Duffy has a big year and gets in as a 3rd 3B. But to me its far more likely that Panik and Crawford make the team given the weakness at both 2B and SS in the league.
Right, but Duffy doesnt need to have the better career, just a better April, May, and June.
Youre right, Crawford does have a great shot. NL SS is so weak. If Seager, Russell, and Story dont have big breakout years, Crawford might be a mile ahead of Peralta and Segura.