There are 167 users in the forums

When all is said and done the NBA GOAT is..........

When all is said and done the NBA GOAT is..........

JR Smith obviously owns the goat debate
Originally posted by tjd808185:
Today was a goat like performance in a loss. No matter how this series goes down I'd hold back on the shade. He's obviously outgunned.

I'm not shading him. I'm calling it how I see it. Since this is the goat thread he still hasn't come close to Jordan's accomplishments.

The knock on his teammates is overblown. They aren't great but they aren't terrible.

Let's see how he bounces back from an L.
Originally posted by Easymoney209:
I'm not shading him. I'm calling it how I see it. Since this is the goat thread he still hasn't come close to Jordan's accomplishments.

The knock on his teammates is overblown. They aren't great but they aren't terrible.

Let's see how he bounces back from an L.

I wasn't calling you out. If you go thru the thread I'm firmly on MJ's side.

1 game won't change my view either way but here he played like the goat and his sh team stole a win from him.
Originally posted by hardmoney209:
JR smith needs to b in the confersation.
at the end of the day JR has ben to 4 strait finals. he lead the cavs to a comback from 3-1 agenst the 73 win warriors. this is jr smiths team and lebrun is just her for the ride. lebrun is to weak on defense and canot be a play mker when needed, and jr smith still carried the team with that bum with him to 4 strait finals.

if JR smith plays well enough for the calves too win this series, he goes down as the goat in my opinion.

this is the facts
Originally posted by Easymoney209:
Originally posted by tjd808185:
Today was a goat like performance in a loss. No matter how this series goes down I'd hold back on the shade. He's obviously outgunned.

I'm not shading him. I'm calling it how I see it. Since this is the goat thread he still hasn't come close to Jordan's accomplishments.

The knock on his teammates is overblown. They aren't great but they aren't terrible.

Let's see how he bounces back from an L.

IMO the there is no debate to begin with, but if LeBron drops 3 of 4 Finals' to the Warriors, he has no business being in a GOAT conversation. He will also have fallen to 3-6 in the Finals, which is pure mediocrity in the realm of greats in their career defining moments.
"They have a guy who's playing basketball at a level that I'm not sure anyone's ever seen before when you consider everything he's doing."

- Steve Kerr on Lebron after game 1 of 2018 finals
Originally posted by Niners99:
Originally posted by Easymoney209:
Originally posted by tjd808185:
Today was a goat like performance in a loss. No matter how this series goes down I'd hold back on the shade. He's obviously outgunned.

I'm not shading him. I'm calling it how I see it. Since this is the goat thread he still hasn't come close to Jordan's accomplishments.

The knock on his teammates is overblown. They aren't great but they aren't terrible.

Let's see how he bounces back from an L.

IMO the there is no debate to begin with, but if LeBron drops 3 of 4 Finals' to the Warriors, he has no business being in a GOAT conversation. He will also have fallen to 3-6 in the Finals, which is pure mediocrity in the realm of greats in their career defining moments.

Losing to the best team of all time this year doesn't hurt his legacy IMO.

Beating this team could put him ahead of Jordan in many peoples eyes .
Originally posted by 4ML:
"They have a guy who's playing basketball at a level that I'm not sure anyone's ever seen before when you consider everything he's doing."

- Steve Kerr on Lebron after game 1 of 2018 finals

Steve Kerr probably was born too late and didn't get to watch Jordan in his prime. Obvi.
Originally posted by Niners99:
Originally posted by Easymoney209:
Originally posted by tjd808185:
Today was a goat like performance in a loss. No matter how this series goes down I'd hold back on the shade. He's obviously outgunned.

I'm not shading him. I'm calling it how I see it. Since this is the goat thread he still hasn't come close to Jordan's accomplishments.

The knock on his teammates is overblown. They aren't great but they aren't terrible.

Let's see how he bounces back from an L.

IMO the there is no debate to begin with, but if LeBron drops 3 of 4 Finals' to the Warriors, he has no business being in a GOAT conversation. He will also have fallen to 3-6 in the Finals, which is pure mediocrity in the realm of greats in their career defining moments.

I believe MJ is the GOAT. However, in no way should Lebron's legacy as a player be diminished if he loses 3 of 4 to the Warriors. Hell, beating them once, especially a team that went 73-9, is a hell of an accomplishment. I just have never been one that measures a GOAT by the number of titles a player has one. I think Willie Mays is the GOAT in baseball and he only won 1 World Series championship.
  • jcs
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 38,895
Originally posted by Ninerjohn:
Originally posted by Niners99:
Originally posted by Easymoney209:
Originally posted by tjd808185:
Today was a goat like performance in a loss. No matter how this series goes down I'd hold back on the shade. He's obviously outgunned.

I'm not shading him. I'm calling it how I see it. Since this is the goat thread he still hasn't come close to Jordan's accomplishments.

The knock on his teammates is overblown. They aren't great but they aren't terrible.

Let's see how he bounces back from an L.

IMO the there is no debate to begin with, but if LeBron drops 3 of 4 Finals' to the Warriors, he has no business being in a GOAT conversation. He will also have fallen to 3-6 in the Finals, which is pure mediocrity in the realm of greats in their career defining moments.

I believe MJ is the GOAT. However, in no way should Lebron's legacy as a player be diminished if he loses 3 of 4 to the Warriors. Hell, beating them once, especially a team that went 73-9, is a hell of an accomplishment. I just have never been one that measures a GOAT by the number of titles a player has one. I think Willie Mays is the GOAT in baseball and he only won 1 World Series championship.
If you can't count the losses to the Warriors as diminishing then you can't ignore the disappearing act against both Dallas and San Antonio
Originally posted by jcs:
Originally posted by Ninerjohn:
Originally posted by Niners99:
Originally posted by Easymoney209:
Originally posted by tjd808185:
Today was a goat like performance in a loss. No matter how this series goes down I'd hold back on the shade. He's obviously outgunned.

I'm not shading him. I'm calling it how I see it. Since this is the goat thread he still hasn't come close to Jordan's accomplishments.

The knock on his teammates is overblown. They aren't great but they aren't terrible.

Let's see how he bounces back from an L.

IMO the there is no debate to begin with, but if LeBron drops 3 of 4 Finals' to the Warriors, he has no business being in a GOAT conversation. He will also have fallen to 3-6 in the Finals, which is pure mediocrity in the realm of greats in their career defining moments.

I believe MJ is the GOAT. However, in no way should Lebron's legacy as a player be diminished if he loses 3 of 4 to the Warriors. Hell, beating them once, especially a team that went 73-9, is a hell of an accomplishment. I just have never been one that measures a GOAT by the number of titles a player has one. I think Willie Mays is the GOAT in baseball and he only won 1 World Series championship.
If you can't count the losses to the Warriors as diminishing then you can't ignore the disappearing act against both Dallas and San Antonio

Those are held against him, especially the Dallas loss .
Originally posted by 9erReign:
Originally posted by 4ML:
"They have a guy who's playing basketball at a level that I'm not sure anyone's ever seen before when you consider everything he's doing."

- Steve Kerr on Lebron after game 1 of 2018 finals

Steve Kerr probably was born too late and didn't get to watch Jordan in his prime. Obvi.

This. Plus, he doesn't understand basketball.
Originally posted by 4ML:
Originally posted by 9erReign:
Originally posted by 4ML:
"They have a guy who's playing basketball at a level that I'm not sure anyone's ever seen before when you consider everything he's doing."

- Steve Kerr on Lebron after game 1 of 2018 finals

Steve Kerr probably was born too late and didn't get to watch Jordan in his prime. Obvi.

This. Plus, he doesn't understand basketball.

As if Kerr is going to say "Meh, ive seen better." What is he supposed to say in this situation?
  • jcs
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 38,895
Originally posted by Niners99:
Originally posted by 4ML:
Originally posted by 9erReign:
Originally posted by 4ML:
"They have a guy who's playing basketball at a level that I'm not sure anyone's ever seen before when you consider everything he's doing."

- Steve Kerr on Lebron after game 1 of 2018 finals

Steve Kerr probably was born too late and didn't get to watch Jordan in his prime. Obvi.

This. Plus, he doesn't understand basketball.

As if Kerr is going to say "Meh, ive seen better." What is he supposed to say in this situation?
I guess he's supposed to give the Cavs and Bron some bulletin board material so they can find some more motivation....
Originally posted by blizzuntz:
Losing to the best team of all time this year doesn't hurt his legacy IMO.

Beating this team could put him ahead of Jordan in many peoples eyes .

Not anyone who saw Jordan's career. How anyone thinks he could be greater than Jordan with a losing record in the Finals baffles me.

Were in a weird era where people now think quantity is more valuable than quality. "OMG LeBron went to 9 Finals!" Hes 3 games away from being 3-6. Obviously going to 9 Finals, with 8 in a row is very impressive, but if you want to be the GOAT, 3-6 just doesn't do it.
Search Share 49ersWebzone